banner img
  • Home
  • Forums
  • Register
  • Contact Us

KINGDOM HEARTS 20th anniversary trailer + event announced

Kingdom Hearts Series Coming to Nintendo Switch as Cloud Versions

Sora from Kingdom Hearts announced as a new DLC fighter in Super Smash Bros. Ultimate

  • All
  • News
  • Interviews
  • Features
  • Editorials
  • Merchandise
  • KINGDOM HEARTS IV
  • KINGDOM HEARTS MISSING-LINK
  • Dark Seeker Saga
  • KINGDOM HEARTS III
  • KINGDOM HEARTS Melody of Memory
  • KINGDOM HEARTS χ series
  • MOBILE
  • The World Ends With You
  • NEO: The World Ends With You

RECENT DISCUSSION TOPICS

  • The writing team on the series has shrunk dramatically
  • What’s the Cost of Developing a Mobile App with Advanced Features?
  • Geoff Keighley x Kingdom Hearts: The Complete Compendium
  • Headcanon Voices for Characters
  • Winx/Kingdom Hearts
  • Changed Opinions on KH Games
  • KH4 Tease (Real Or Not)
  • What are your thoughts on Demyx being the Master of Masters Theories?
  • Mufasa the Lion King/Kingdom hearts dark road
  • Birth By Sleep is VERY similar to the Disney Princesses

MULTIMEDIA

  • Submissions
  • Avatars
  • Signatures
  • Wallpapers
  • iPhone Wallpapers
  • PSP Wallpapers
  • PS Vita Wallpapers
  • Video Game MIDI files
  • Video Game Music
  • Anime Downloads

COMMUNITY SPOTLIGHT

Let us know what you hope to see when Kingdom Hearts IV is next shown off!

NEWSLETTER

Subscribe to Kingdom Hearts News!

Enter your email address:

   

KHINSIDER

  • Membership FAQ
  • Contact Us
  • About Us
  • Staff
  • Affiliation

POLL

Who do you prefer to play as in Kingdom Hearts 3D?

Sora - 100%
Riku - 0%

Total votes: 1, but the poll doesn't work yet
View details
read the related article >>

Rumour: A World Based on Frozen 2 Reportedly Considered for Kingdom Hearts 4

Details
Published on September 8, 2020 @ 12:00 pm
Written by Joey
Tweet

Emre Kaya, one of the individuals who broke the news about a potential Kingdom Hearts Disney+ TV show being in development, has revealed that sources close to the game told them that a world based on the worldwide phenomenon Frozen 2 was being considered for the next big Kingdom Hearts game.

Pre-production on what will most likely be Kingdom Hearts 4 also allegedly began in November 2019, several months after the release of Kingdom Hearts III but a couple of months before Kingdom Hearts III Re Mind. This is when Frozen 2 was reportedly being considered as a world for the game.

As one of Disney's most successful IPs, a world based on Frozen 2 would naturally be a lock for the next big Kingdom Hearts game. Whether or not Disney will be as restrictive with what story Square Enix can tell with the world remains to be seen.

Like all rumours, take this information with a grain of salt. Plans and details can change and worlds are not a guarantee until confirmed by Square Enix and Disney.

Source: Emre Kaya (Tweet from May)

Follow Kingdom Hearts Insider on Facebook and Twitter for the latest updates on Kingdom Hearts Union χ [Cross], Kingdom Hearts Dark Road, Kingdom Hearts III, Kingdom Hearts Melody of Memory, and all things Kingdom Hearts and The World Ends With You!

COMMENTS

+ Reply

Bloodblade777

September 8, 2020 @ 11:53 amOffline

comment graphic

Arendelle in kh3 was so bad... I hope if it is the movie team give them more creative freedom

Chie

September 8, 2020 @ 12:03 pmOffline

comment graphic

Considering that there's supposed to be at least another unannounced game before KH4 and that Disney+ thing hasn't panned out yet, I'm just ignoring this. I doubt that a game called "KH4" is in any sort of development beyond in Nomura's mind.

Chaser

September 8, 2020 @ 12:05 pmOffline

comment graphic

Chie

Considering that there's supposed to be at least another unannounced game before KH4 and that Disney+ thing hasn't panned out yet, I'm just ignoring this. I doubt that a game called "KH4" is in any sort of development beyond in Nomura's mind.

Ignoring it is probably the healthiest thing to do lol (alas, being. news website.....)

But the team at Osaka haven't been sitting on their hands doing nothing. Remember that KH3 was in pre-production in 2012 when they were doing tests on the Unreal Engine 3.

Also Frozen 2 has the better music. I said what I said!

welken

September 8, 2020 @ 12:12 pmOffline

comment graphic

At least it will be a pretty forest. And I love that little salamander. Though I don't know what makes anyone (who's familiar with the series) think we're going into KH4 before Sora & Riku at the Reaper Games Tokyo 2022.

AegisXIII

September 8, 2020 @ 12:20 pmOffline

comment graphic

I highly doubt it. I think they should move away from movies and create custom disney worlds like disney castle, where more freedom would be possible.

Muke

September 8, 2020 @ 12:21 pmOffline

comment graphic

I‘m not surprised, but still excited! I genuinely enjoyed Frozen 2 and I imagine they cay do waaaay more with it. I think this could be so action packed and I HOPE they‘ll have Show Yourself in it.

SweetYetSalty

September 8, 2020 @ 12:55 pmOffline

comment graphic

Regardless if this is true or not, I think Frozen 2 is almost a 100% shoo-in for a big Kingdom Hearts game. Arendelle being unpopular among the KH fanbase doesn't mean much. They still used Pirates in KH3, even though many didn't like the world in KH2.

I want to say I hope they aren't as restrictive with this one, but this is Frozen.

Chaser

September 8, 2020 @ 01:00 pmOffline

comment graphic

I, for one, would be SHOCKED that Nomura would think to include a Disney world that is the home to two of the new seven hearts. /s

But seriously, and shilling for Disney + here, if you love behind the scenes then definitely check out the Frozen 2 BTS series. It's the best look you can get at the making of a modern Disney film, from getting to know those in the animation and rigging department, to the song writers, voice and music recording, being put into the writers room, and seeing the gigantic tub of advil on Jennifer Lee's desk.

It's insane and spectacular. I wasn't too big on Frozen 2 but this doco made me see it in a whole new light. And if you had issues with the plot, this series will tell you exactly why because they actually didn't come up with the crux of Elsa's motivation until a couple of months before release, so the story was effectively stitched together at the last moment.

The trailer puts the usual Disney fairy tale gloss over it, but it's an intensen and insane look at how the people at Disney put together a movie essentially in under a year.



[URL unfurl="true"]https://collider.com/into-the-unknown-making-of-frozen-2-documentary-disney-plus-review/[/URL]

And add me to the list of people who don't have hope that a Frozen 2 world would actually be used to its full potential.

NoWay

September 8, 2020 @ 01:06 pmOffline

comment graphic

I don’t want any Frozen world in KH anymore after they fu***d it up in KH3. It’s literally the worst world ever in my opinion.

TheGreatEphemera

September 8, 2020 @ 01:20 pmOffline

comment graphic

I hated the Frozen World, which is funny because ice themed levels are one of my favourites.
Much prefer a Zootopia world, which somewhat fits the Kingdom Hearts setting (wanted it for KH3 but they already have a city based world being San Fransokyo)

KeybladeOrder

September 8, 2020 @ 01:29 pmOffline

comment graphic

That would line up with my predictions for the remainder of the series.

Oracle Spockanort

September 8, 2020 @ 01:29 pmOffline

comment graphic

NoWay

I don’t want any Frozen world in KH anymore after they fu***d it up in KH3. It’s literally the worst world ever in my opinion.


It was, but I’m hoping that after the lukewarm reception to Frozen 2 (even though it made bank), the staff over the film aren’t as hyper-protective and Disney won’t try to limit SE this time around. I’d say SE more than proved themselves capable of handling the property. It was Disney’s own limitations that made it the worst world in the game. It was where Nomura and the Osaka staff were allowed to be more liberal with the story that the world felt enjoyable.

Marshmallow, the boss fight, the comedy, even that stupid Olaf minigame that makes me cry because I love Olaf after Frozen 2...It was all different. It was literally the Frozen stuff that was bland.

I doubt the Disney staff feel as protective of Frozen 2 considering how they cobbled it together last minute. Instead of hindering SE to stick to a plot they weren’t even sure about when they made it, they should let the writing staff have free reign over it. It might end up being better than they expect.

The best worlds in KH3 were the ones that were allowed to take liberties so we just have to hope they allow it this time around. At the very least, it doesn’t have to take place DURING the film. They could make it a post-film adventure.

user avatar

Deleted member 252753

September 8, 2020 @ 01:41 pmOffline

comment graphic

I think a Frozen 2 world could be quite good, even with similar story restrictions for Ana and Elsa, as there is more cool stuff in Frozen 2 like the Nokk and other elemental creatures that can be incorporated, as well as a more interesting landscape than just snowy mountains.

Ballad of Caius

September 8, 2020 @ 02:22 pmOffline

comment graphic

Chaser

I, for one, would be SHOCKED that Nomura would think to include a Disney world that is the home to two of the new seven hearts. /s

I know it's sarcasm, but I had entirely forgotten about the New Seven Hearts plot line, LOL. We're so engrossed in everything post KH3 that I'm starting to wonder if the N7H will be used in the future or not.

Also, I'm on Chaser's sarcasm boat as well. To add even more sarcasm: I'm surprised they'll include the sequel of a commercial success.

Cumguardian69

September 8, 2020 @ 02:29 pmOffline

comment graphic

No no no, a million times NO. Frozen is GARBAGE for KH. The creators have massive sticks up their bootyboxes, same as Disney head management. Pick literally anything else. PLEASE.

welken

September 8, 2020 @ 02:56 pmOffline

comment graphic

Wasn't there imagery found in the files of KH3 (or ReMind?) that appeared to be elemental symbols. That would line right up with F2's elemental spirits, which were sorely underused. Elsa catching the salamander was my favorite part, and then he never got to do anything! Except be very cute. He'd be a nice summon, should Disney deign to allow such a thing as summons again.

I remember watching the opening to Frozen, and thinking, wow this could actually be an awesome fantasy movie. And then the mom starts singing that forced song and I knew something had gone deeply wrong in the story department. Did anyone else get the sense that there was supposed to be a new character (the mist witch) who was completely cut from the story?

Anyway, while it wouldn't be my pick for a KH world, I personally think you could do worse. There can never be enough forests, and it has a lovely autumnal one. And I personally don't think Arendelle even came close to approaching how terrible San Fransokyo was.

edit: Oh, I do hate the New Seven Princesses thing, though. How could I forget.

Zettaflare

September 8, 2020 @ 03:06 pmOffline

comment graphic

Even if it's just a rumor Arendelle will definitely return at some point.

Are Elsa and Anna even going to remember SDG? They barely even acknowledged them in KH3, lol

Oracle Spockanort

September 8, 2020 @ 03:20 pmOffline

comment graphic

Zettaflare

Even if it's just a rumor Arendelle will definitely return at some point.

Are Elsa and Anna even going to remember SDG? They barely even acknowledged them in KH3, lol


Riku arrives in Arendelle “hello, I’m looking for my friend Sora. Have you seen him?”

Elsa:

Anna:

Kristoff:

Olaf:

Sven:

Marshmallow: SORA

SweetYetSalty

September 8, 2020 @ 03:33 pmOffline

comment graphic

Oracle Spockanort

Riku arrives in Arendelle “hello, I’m looking for my friend Sora. Have you seen him?”

Elsa:

Anna:

Kristoff:

Olaf:

Sven:

Marshmallow: SORA

I don't even think Marshmallow was in Frozen 2, was he? Regardless he'll be the perfect party member for a Frozen 2 world because any plot with him will take the heroes out of the Frozen 2 story, perfect to retell Frozen 2's story without Sora and crew.

user avatar

Xagzan

September 8, 2020 @ 03:36 pmOffline

comment graphic

I just want more 2D animated films in KH dammit -3-

Oracle Spockanort

September 8, 2020 @ 03:39 pmOffline

comment graphic

SweetYetSalty

I don't even think Marshmallow was in Frozen 2, was he? Regardless he'll be the perfect party member for a Frozen 2 world because any plot with him will take the heroes out of the Frozen 2 story, perfect to retell Frozen 2's story without Sora and crew.


He was at the very end I believe with the little snow bbys. He’s still living on the Northern mountain.

user avatar

disney233

September 8, 2020 @ 03:59 pmOffline

comment graphic

Cumguardian69

No no no, a million times NO. Frozen is GARBAGE for KH. The creators have massive sticks up their bootyboxes, same as Disney head management. Pick literally anything else. PLEASE.

Why anything else? Disney screwed up all the modern movie worlds. Big Hero 6, Corona, and especially Tangled. Honestly, so long as Disney's in the game, is there really any hope for any other modern movie? Odds are, Disney'll just screw it up.

I...kinda lost hope in Disney worlds after BBS. So, I'm neutral with Frozen 2. But uhh...yeah. Odds are, Disney's iron grip'll come in and butcher it up. This is Frozen we're talking about. And odds are, Zootopia, Moana, they'll probably share the same fate.

Cumguardian69

September 8, 2020 @ 04:03 pmOffline

comment graphic

disney233

Why anything else? Disney screwed up all the modern movie worlds. Big Hero 6, Corona, and especially Tangled. Honestly, so long as Disney's in the game, is there really any hope for any other modern movie? Odds are, Disney'll just screw it up.

At least they pretended to try with BH6. God Arendelle is one of the worst KH worlds I have ever had the displeasure of playing. SDG completely unrelated to the Disney plot, boss battles that had nothing to do with Frozen, and more. Hella neutered plotline that skips all over the place not unlike The Caribbean - but unlike TC, it didn't have gorgeous graphics or a good OST to distract from the lifeless storyline. Like jesus christ. Don't touch that IP with a ten foot pole. Yeah, it gets newbies into the series...but sales shouldn't inherently compromise portions of the product IMO.

MATGSY

September 8, 2020 @ 04:09 pmOffline

comment graphic

SweetYetSalty

I don't even think Marshmallow was in Frozen 2, was he? Regardless he'll be the perfect party member for a Frozen 2 world because any plot with him will take the heroes out of the Frozen 2 story, perfect to retell Frozen 2's story without Sora and crew.

He got a post-credits scene.

Elysium

September 8, 2020 @ 04:13 pmOffline

comment graphic

This isn’t even real news to me. If anyone thought Frozen 2 wasn’t going to be in the next game, they were lying to themselves.

Anna and Elsa better darn well be party members this time.

the red monster

September 8, 2020 @ 05:00 pmOffline

comment graphic

They gonna make the world with a little creativity as possible because disney, sad news but predictable

Squood!

September 8, 2020 @ 05:05 pmOffline

comment graphic

the red monster

They gonna make the world with a little creativity as possible because disney, sad news but predictable

I recall someone who used to work at Disney or whatever talking about how the "Frozen team" wouldn't even allow Elsa to face a different direction on an ad because the style guide explicitly said she can only do things or poses from the movie or something.

the red monster

September 8, 2020 @ 05:08 pmOffline

comment graphic

KeybladeLordSora

I recall someone who used to work at Disney or whatever talking about how the "Frozen team" wouldn't even allow Elsa to face a different direction on an ad because the style guide explicitly said she can only do things or poses from the movie or something.

I guess fun isn't allowed when it comes down to disney getting involved

MATGSY

September 8, 2020 @ 05:15 pmOffline

comment graphic

Look Disney, just give me my Zootopia & P&tF worlds & we'll call it even.

Elysium

September 8, 2020 @ 05:26 pmOffline

comment graphic

Well, a lot of this micromanaging every facet of the company came from Lasseter. Even though he's gone now, some of that thinking in the way the studio does things in marketing and so onis probably still followed (hopefully to dissipate as time passes). And you have to look at the fact, too, that Disney was really trying to make a comeback for a long time and Frozen was the first time in forever that they got to be above all the other animation studios again since the '90s. Dreamworks and PIXAR had been running the show for the last decade before that.

So Disney's very careful with Frozen for that reason. Zootopia's the only film that's made as much as Frozen and Frozen 2 did at the box office of their newer films, and yet for whatever reason that film still doesn't sell merchandise, have the brand recognition, or get the same amount of attention that Frozen does from the public. Which is a shame, because Judy and Nick are great characters.

Squood!

September 8, 2020 @ 05:33 pmOffline

comment graphic

Yep. Frozen is their big cash cow. If anything they'd rather be caught dead than let Elsa be a party member.

Cumguardian69

September 8, 2020 @ 05:36 pmOffline

comment graphic

Their brand should lick the players' nuts. I know Disney is intrinsically tied to KH but damn. If you don't want the branding or image to be tarnished/altered, then don't include it in this anime crossover.

Oracle Spockanort

September 8, 2020 @ 05:52 pmOffline

comment graphic

I will acknowledge that Frozen was their biggest hit, but that shouldn’t not mean that they have to limit Frozen 2 this time around. The film was a mess. We know it was a mess because they let us see them develop it and struggle with it the whole way.

At this point, they should be happy for people to come in with fresh eyes and make something that barely came together into something fun and enjoyable for a group of fans.

Cumguardian69

Their brand should lick the players' nuts. I know Disney is intrinsically tied to KH but damn. If you don't want the branding or image to be tarnished/altered, then don't include it in this anime crossover.


I don’t disagree. If they aren’t going to let them do anything interesting with the IP, why bother having it in the game at all?

It just sucks because the KH team loved the film and was so happy to include it, so it is a shame it turned out the way it did.

user avatar

disney233

September 8, 2020 @ 05:54 pmOffline

comment graphic

Cumguardian69

Their brand should lick the players' nuts. I know Disney is intrinsically tied to KH but damn. If you don't want the branding or image to be tarnished/altered, then don't include it in this anime crossover.

That's it. That's what Disney has come to. They don't even want their own summons in Disney worlds now despite the fact that they done it in the past. Disney somehow completely ruined their own crossover.

Reagan Rayden

September 8, 2020 @ 06:10 pmOffline

comment graphic

As long as Larxene doesn't drop in and create a really boring maze level I'm good with it.

Cumguardian69

September 8, 2020 @ 06:11 pmOffline

comment graphic

Reagan Rayden

As long as Larxene doesn't drop in and create a really boring maze level I'm good with it.

Instead, the Master will drop in and create TWO boring maze levels, one for Yozora and another for Riku + Kairi ?

NoWay

September 8, 2020 @ 06:17 pmOffline

comment graphic

Reagan Rayden

As long as Larxene doesn't drop in and create a really boring maze level I'm good with it.

The maze was like the only thing about Arendelle I enjoyed :ROFLMAO:

WhinyAcademic

September 8, 2020 @ 06:21 pmOffline

comment graphic

Ugh. Arendelle was trash. Frozen II was trash. No thanks.

Xblade13

September 8, 2020 @ 06:26 pmOffline

comment graphic

Muke

I‘m not surprised, but still excited! I genuinely enjoyed Frozen 2 and I imagine they cay do waaaay more with it. I think this could be so action packed and I HOPE they‘ll have Show Yourself in it.

I had an idea for a Kairi game where she's going to different worlds to recover her own power and self-worth after the events of KH3, and each of the worlds she visits is the New Seven Hearts worlds to get advice from them. Maybe even have a running theme of their songs opening up their inner light or something (Show Yourself and The Next Right Thing for Elsa and Ana respectively, etc) culminating in Disney actually writing a Kairi song for the climax. Have it so she has to find her own worth outside of Sora and decides at the end to defend the world's from the Fortellers/Maleficent/whatever is doing evil stuff during the game, instead of just trying to find Sora. Idk, it sounds neat to me...

SweetYetSalty

September 8, 2020 @ 06:35 pmOffline

comment graphic

I love Frozen and really enjoyed the Frozen Fever short. But everything after that has been decent to bad when it comes to Frozen. Frozen's popularity has really come back to give it frostbite. The restrictions on Arendelle made it the least fun KH3 world for many, and certainly didn't win over anyone who already didn't like Frozen going into the game. Then there is Frozen 2 the movie. I like the movie, but I also felt it had a lot of missed opportunities in the film too which make it just a okay movie, but not a great one.

A lot of elements (lol) from Frozen 2 could work in the KH universe but only if they are allowed to. The fact that Elsa or Anna were not party members and barely interact with Sora was such a bad choice and one I cannot forgive no matter what the reason. I have no doubt Frozen 2 will be used, but I hope the leash is loosened. Who's even going to be the villain in a Frozen 2 world in a KH game?

Squood!

September 8, 2020 @ 06:35 pmOffline

comment graphic

Oracle Spockanort

I will acknowledge that Frozen was their biggest hit, but that shouldn’t not mean that they have to limit Frozen 2 this time around. The film was a mess. We know it was a mess because they let us see them develop it and struggle with it the whole way.

At this point, they should be happy for people to come in with fresh eyes and make something that barely came together into something fun and enjoyable for a group of fans.

I hope so. But if this rumor is true, yet they still keep the KH team from doing anything with Frozen 2, I'm gonna be completely convinced that the Frozen group is the worst group to work with.

Sakuraba Neku

September 8, 2020 @ 06:56 pmOffline

comment graphic

Doesn't matter which Kingdom Hearts is, there's no way Frozen wouldn't come back. Now I would be happy, if Disney doesn't ruin everything again.

Kingdom Hearts is going for its 20th anniversary and Square is the main reason why a lot of people are still on this ride. Let them have more freedom. They don't have to prove anything anymore.

In Kingdom Hearts 3 base game felt like Square priority was to please Disney first and then they decided to rush the rest.There was never a KH game that made me feel that way and of course that didn't end well.

Fortunately ReMind came out and that definitely felt like it was done for the fans and only us. So good!

Soldier

September 8, 2020 @ 07:43 pmOffline

comment graphic

*Reads initial post*
Now, I'm going to hope that this is just as it claims to be at the moment: A rumor and nothing more. As I've said countless times before, there are other disney properties worth pursuing that represents an ice level better than frozen II of all things that would give Square more freedom to do what they want. Everyone knows that Frozen sucked in KH 3 and shouldn't have been implemented. It's all based on popularity at this point. It's highly unlikely that we'll see Robin Hood or the Jungle book at this point, because most of what KH 3 had to offer were new worlds that were released after the year 2000 (Olympus Coliseum notwithstanding). Don't you just miss the days were Nomura actually LISTENED to fans instead of doing what he believes is fanservice. At this point, he might as well remake that crappy Olaf short that premiered before Coco in theaters and just shoehorn SDG into the plot.

SweetYetSalty

September 8, 2020 @ 07:57 pmOffline

comment graphic

Soldier

*Reads initial post*
Now, I'm going to hope that this is just as it claims to be at the moment: A rumor and nothing more. As I've said countless times before, there are other disney properties worth pursuing that represents an ice level better than frozen II of all things that would give Square more freedom to do what they want. Everyone knows that Frozen sucked in KH 3 and shouldn't have been implemented. It's all based on popularity at this point. It's highly unlikely that we'll see Robin Hood or the Jungle book at this point, because most of what KH 3 had to offer were new worlds that were released after the year 2000 (Olympus Coliseum notwithstanding). Don't you just miss the days were Nomura actually LISTENED to fans instead of doing what he believes is fanservice. At this point, he might as well remake that crappy Olaf short that premiered before Coco in theaters and just shoehorn SDG into the plot.

I'm curious, what Disney properties would do ice better then Frozen 2? Not saying I disagree, I'm generally curious as it's been awhile since I've seen a Disney movie with snow besides...Beauty and the Beast lol.

As for Nomura listening to the fans, I always assumed he was doing what he wanted. When did he listen to the fans about fanservice? I'm a bit confused there. One more thing, don't forget about 100 Acre Woods in KH3 along with Olympus...though I wouldn't blame you if you did forget it XD

Oracle Spockanort

September 8, 2020 @ 08:18 pmOffline

comment graphic

100 Acre Wood was wholly wasted. I cried, sure, but they didn’t give it the love and respect it deserved. Three minigames that were the same...barely even 10 minutes of a plot...what a waste.

But yes, Nomura and the development team decides what they want to do. It never been about the fans, although they try to take what feedback they receive into consideration.

Soldier

*Reads initial post*
Now, I'm going to hope that this is just as it claims to be at the moment: A rumor and nothing more. As I've said countless times before, there are other disney properties worth pursuing that represents an ice level better than frozen II of all things that would give Square more freedom to do what they want. Everyone knows that Frozen sucked in KH 3 and shouldn't have been implemented. It's all based on popularity at this point. It's highly unlikely that we'll see Robin Hood or the Jungle book at this point, because most of what KH 3 had to offer were new worlds that were released after the year 2000 (Olympus Coliseum notwithstanding). Don't you just miss the days were Nomura actually LISTENED to fans instead of doing what he believes is fanservice. At this point, he might as well remake that crappy Olaf short that premiered before Coco in theaters and just shoehorn SDG into the plot.


Frozen was added in before the film ever released. They got an early preview of it long before it released in any territory. I think that what we can glean from the way eat the world operates is that they did prototyping for a really interesting level design and plot, then Frozen blew up when it released and Disney reeled SE in with their plans. That left Nomura and Yasue to figure out what they could do within the new restrictions, and it led to what we got.

It’s the only explanation I can think of for that labyrinth and the weird backtracking and the weird final boss (great boss, just a weird transition to it).

But in general, Nomura has always done what he wants. Disney’s limitations were a result of a growing corporate interest in the franchise, which is why I think Nomura will likely aim for less recent films while still having a few of them in here and there like the old days. The older the IP, the less likely Disney will intervene and interject.

KH3 was a proof of concept in a way. This was their way to show off to Disney and it worked perfectly. Disney hates being involved in any aspect of game development, so I think they will hopefully step back in the future. It’s easy enough for Disney to see the reactions themselves, anyways. Fans hated Frozen in KH. Newcomers were perplexed at the strange scene-by-scene remake. It didn’t appease anybody.

I’m willing to let Frozen 2 be the second attempt where SE can show their real skills just as long as Disney lets them this time. If they can’t get that right, they Frozen needs to stay out of KH forever. I think even SE would agree because if it was rough for us fans to play, imagine how absolutely difficult it was for them to make it while dealing with Disney breathing on their necks.

Zettaflare

September 8, 2020 @ 08:29 pmOffline

comment graphic

Regardless of how the world is handled I just hope we get winter clothing this time. Still can't believe the world order decided to let SDG freeze to death instead of giving them proper clothing

Chie

September 8, 2020 @ 08:29 pmOffline

comment graphic

Maybe the reason Nomura is so interested in the concept of utilizing darkness but not letting it overpower you is because this is how it feels to work with Disney

Cumguardian69

September 8, 2020 @ 08:31 pmOffline

comment graphic

Chie

Maybe the reason Nomura is so interested in the concept of utilizing darkness but not letting it overpower you is because this is how it feels to work with Disney

Or conversely, how it feels to make something for the fans but not letting the fans get to you and undermine the creative process..

Face My Fears

September 8, 2020 @ 10:59 pmOffline

comment graphic

I didn't need this rumour to tell me this or to make me think it. What's next, someone going to report a rumour that the sky is blue?

Unfortunately, the reality is that Frozen 2 will probably be in KH4 - which doesn't excite me at all. I was excited for Frozen 1 in KH3, but after seeing how that panned out, I think I'll just wait for the other world "rumours". The only thing that could possibly make me the slightest bit interested in Frozen 2 being in KH4 is if Elsa is on your team... hopefully she doesn't take up the KH mandated "1 female Disney party member per game" quota, because I would rather other female Disney characters over her on the party.

Launchpad

September 8, 2020 @ 11:43 pmOffline

comment graphic

Seeing Kingdom Hearts 4 in a rumor headline fucks with me on extreme levels.

Ballad of Caius

September 9, 2020 @ 12:25 amOffline

comment graphic

Launchpad

Seeing Kingdom Hearts 4 in a rumor headline fucks with me on extreme levels.

I mean, am I too optimistic to expect KINGDOM HEARTS IV/4/WhateverIt'sCalled to be released by 2022?

P.S. I hope I don't have to buy a PS5 to get KH4.

Squood!

September 9, 2020 @ 12:30 amOffline

comment graphic

Zettaflare

Regardless of how the world is handled I just hope we get winter clothing this time. Still can't believe the world order decided to let SDG freeze to death instead of giving them proper clothing

Man, screw Donald, yo. It's his magic. He can make pirate clothes but not winter ones cuz it doesn't work that way?

Ballad of Caius

September 9, 2020 @ 12:31 amOffline

comment graphic

Forget about Donald's magic, I want 0.2's accessories back. #MakeKHstylishAgain

Squood!

September 9, 2020 @ 12:48 amOffline

comment graphic

Ballad of Caius

Forget about Donald's magic, I want 0.2's accessories back. #MakeKHstylishAgain

My hope is that someone manages to at least mod 0.2's color option into KH3

Launchpad

September 9, 2020 @ 01:33 amOffline

comment graphic

Ballad of Caius

I mean, am I too optimistic to expect KINGDOM HEARTS IV/4/WhateverIt'sCalled to be released by 2022?

P.S. I hope I don't have to buy a PS5 to get KH4.


In the name of pushing technology and performance forward, I'm fine with putting KH4 on PS5! Though if that perpetuates the 'lots of mobs that don't do much to fight back' design, we might have a problem, but I don't want to go there in this thread.

As for KH4 being released in 2022, no, that's actually not that unfair of an ask, all things considered. KH3 sold insanely well and I'm sure Disney and Square don't want to wait for the next big hit in the franchise. My guess would probably be 2023.

Chaser

September 9, 2020 @ 01:48 amOffline

comment graphic

Ballad of Caius

I mean, am I too optimistic to expect KINGDOM HEARTS IV/4/WhateverIt'sCalled to be released by 2022?

P.S. I hope I don't have to buy a PS5 to get KH4.

2022 for best case scenario, 2023 for realistically.

They pumped KH3 out in four years after resetting to UE4, but the pre-production on the game had been done (worlds selected, contracts with current Disney staff made etc).

If pre-prod for 4 began in 2019, then worlds and contracts would all be done. They don’t have to rebuild everything this time around, so they are reusing a lot of assets. They also have a UE4 workflow established and have their own system in place for it (even if it’s highly unoptimised like Digital Foundry suggested).

Who knows what the thing outside of UXDR, MoM, and 4 is though. Could be like MoM and not be as intense on developing fresh assets and stuff so maybe they could get that out in 2021 / 2022.

Then again, like everyone else on this forum, I’m not a game dev and games take longer to make so who knows! ??‍♂️

Chie

September 9, 2020 @ 01:55 amOffline

comment graphic

I just don't want to believe that KH4 is on the horizon because I liked games like Days, BBS, etc. a lot more, and would rather see more of that kind of episodic gradual storytelling than have to focus on Sora + Disney advertising for 16 hours again. People who think those other games are "spin-offs" (or as i saw a certain person call them, "tiny games") can just keep being wrong. But it might just be 3 being what it was that makes me apprehensive about 4, and it's entirely possible that 4 will be much better due to focusing on new story beats. I don't know.

The Dark Mamba

September 9, 2020 @ 04:08 amOffline

comment graphic

It's obviously highly likely to appear in KH4 but I can't get excited bout this. Arendelle was horribly done in KH3 and I wasn't a big fan of Frozen II.

I'd rather see Elsa and her water horse be summons/links rather than have to see a world based on that movie.

MATGSY

September 9, 2020 @ 04:37 amOffline

comment graphic

Chie

I just don't want to believe that KH4 is on the horizon because I liked games like Days, BBS, etc. a lot more, and would rather see more of that kind of episodic gradual storytelling than have to focus on Sora + Disney advertising for 16 hours again. People who think those other games are "spin-offs" (or as i saw a certain person call them, "tiny games") can just keep being wrong. But it might just be 3 being what it was that makes me apprehensive about 4, and it's entirely possible that 4 will be much better due to focusing on new story beats. I don't know.

Regardless of what other titles have come out, it taking 13 to get from 2 to 3 is no way to run a game series. In a better world we would be talking about KH6 about now!

Chie

September 9, 2020 @ 05:01 amOffline

comment graphic

Why is that "no way to run a game series"? The numbers are arbitrary and I like the vast majority of non-numbered games better anyway. The title of a game shouldn't change anything other than perception. And going by what the titles have signified thus far, I'd vastly rather have 6 interesting smaller-budget psychodramas than 6 big budget Disney ads.

Squood!

September 9, 2020 @ 05:06 amOffline

comment graphic

Chie

Why is that "no way to run a game series"? The numbers are arbitrary and I like the vast majority of non-numbered games better anyway. The title of a game shouldn't change anything other than perception. And going by what the titles have signified thus far, I'd vastly rather have 6 interesting smaller-budget psychodramas than 6 big budget Disney ads.

Imo KH should've just went with subtitles from CoM onward.

Chie

September 9, 2020 @ 05:10 amOffline

comment graphic

I was basically expecting them to only do subtitles from now on to avoid the number stigma, maybe using some kind of particularly snappy title to denote the biggest budgeted ones, but then Nomura's been using the word "KH4" on occasion so I guess not. But it would be the most accurate way to portray things.

MATGSY

September 9, 2020 @ 05:56 amOffline

comment graphic

Chie

Why is that "no way to run a game series"? The numbers are arbitrary and I like the vast majority of non-numbered games better anyway. The title of a game shouldn't change anything other than perception. And going by what the titles have signified thus far, I'd vastly rather have 6 interesting smaller-budget psychodramas than 6 big budget Disney ads.

Perhaps that's how it is for you, but there's so many other people that never gave a damn about the handheld titles & others that didn't know they existed to begin with. KH1/2/3 are all like 5-6 million sellers while the handheld entries are more like 1.5 million at best. You can look to the trophy completion percentages on 1.5+2.5& see just how many fewer people are even bothering to play CoM/BBS than they are KH1/2 despite being in the same collection. How often did the spin-offs get showvased on an E3 press conference while KH3 got many showings? To many players the numbers are not arbitrary at all.

Chie

September 9, 2020 @ 06:00 amOffline

comment graphic

Yes, and they are demonstrably wrong in thinking so.

Like I said, the title shouldn't change anything other than perception. Everything you just said is based on peoples perception of the series, not what's actually in the games.

Sign

September 9, 2020 @ 06:04 amOffline

comment graphic

Things were so much easier before Disney insiders realized KH is a really big deal and there's a lot of traffic and internet brownie points to be gained from it ?

Bloodblade777

September 9, 2020 @ 06:44 amOffline

comment graphic

BBS is just as major a game as KH1 and KH2, actually correct me if i'm wrong but BBS was originally planned for Ps2 and they had to cut a lot of content to have it fit on PSP

user avatar

Deleted member 252753

September 9, 2020 @ 06:59 amOffline

comment graphic

Bloodblade777

BBS is just as major a game as KH1 and KH2, actually correct me if i'm wrong but BBS was originally planned for Ps2 and they had to cut a lot of content to have it fit on PSP

Lore-wise, I think BBS is maybe even more important than KH1 and KH2. KH3 was billed as the finale of the Dark Seeker saga but that wasn't even really a thing until BBS and DDD incorporated the previous games into a wider narrative. And then KH3 left most of its lore building the mobile games. I do hope the next numbered title does reveal more of the lore itself as the way KH3 only lightly touches on UX stuff sort of makes it feel divorced from its own story.

AdrianXXII

September 9, 2020 @ 07:20 amOffline

comment graphic

Dast

Lore-wise, I think BBS is maybe even more important than KH1 and KH2. KH3 was billed as the finale of the Dark Seeker saga but that wasn't even really a thing until BBS and DDD incorporated the previous games into a wider narrative. And then KH3 left most of its lore building the mobile games. I do hope the next numbered title does reveal more of the lore itself as the way KH3 only lightly touches on UX stuff sort of makes it feel divorced from its own story.

Nomura has even referred to BBS as KH0, which it probably should have been called so that others could see it's importance.

That said, BBS didn't quite have the polish the other numbered games had. That's probably also part of why it doesn't get as many eyes and spotlight as the numbered games.

SuperSaiyanSora

September 9, 2020 @ 09:20 amOffline

comment graphic

Ballad of Caius

I mean, am I too optimistic to expect KINGDOM HEARTS IV/4/WhateverIt'sCalled to be released by 2022?

P.S. I hope I don't have to buy a PS5 to get KH4.


By 2022? You'd most likely have to start considering it by that point, and who knows when in 2022 this title would actually release.

Sign

Things were so much easier before Disney insiders realized KH is a really big deal and there's a lot of traffic and internet brownie points to be gained from it ?


Here's hoping that Square Enix won't have to deal with that anymore. After all, if they approached Nomura about a KH rhythm game, certainly there's some level of respect and admiration going on there.

Even from a business perspective though, Arendelle was a flop. It's consistently listed as the worst world in KH3, nobody even really likes it. I hope that teaches them to let the creators create and not be so damn stingy with their IPs. They've got Marvel and Star Wars now, a Kingdom Hearts game isn't gonna doom Disney because they make Elsa actually do something cool. But what do I know?

AdrianXXII

Nomura has even referred to BBS as KH0, which it probably should have been called so that others could see it's importance.

That said, BBS didn't quite have the polish the other numbered games had. That's probably also part of why it doesn't get as many eyes and spotlight as the numbered games.


Although among fans, everyone knows the importance of Birth by Sleep. In fact, if Square called it Kingdom Hearts Zero, I dunno if it'd get the same amount of love as KH1 and KH2 did regardless. I think it's more because of it being on the PSP and while it was a popular handheld, you can't really beat the home console base (unless you're Nintendo). Although Re: CoM was on the PS2 and that didn't get too much love either, but that's probably due to the battle system.

The battle system in BBS was a pretty big departure from what most people were used to at the time as well, which is a factor, plus no playable Sora (for obvious reasons). There's a lot that kinda worked against it at the time, despite it doing really well. But in current times though, everyone knows about BBS and most people really enjoy it.

Launchpad

September 9, 2020 @ 10:48 amOffline

comment graphic

Chie

Yes, and they are demonstrably wrong in thinking so.

Like I said, the title shouldn't change anything other than perception. Everything you just said is based on peoples perception of the series, not what's actually in the games.


Nah, nah, nah, not demonstrably wrong.

The only full Kingdom Hearts experiences that are built from the ground up as home console titles are KH1, KH2, and KH3. The overall asset quality, amount of content, and general formula is most similar across these three games and less so on the handheld games. The main titles are built to be climactic, the handhelds are used to set up concepts to pay off in main titles. Days, Coded, BBS and DDD are all lower-budget affairs with shorter development cycles, and these facts aren't invisible in the games. The main titles introduce lots of new Disney properties. The offshoots rarely introduce a previously unseen property. Only Hunchback comes to mind right now.

From a narrative standpoint, no, they're not less important, and they're absolutely essential to getting the full picture, but it was damaging to Kingdom Hearts as a franchise to go down such an esoteric and meandering road after KH2. There could have been a steady string of full budget games with better overall quality until now, and with the goliath success of KH3, it's hard to imagine Square and Disney letting it go down such a road again.

Chie

September 9, 2020 @ 10:58 amOffline

comment graphic

I could contest the individual points here pretty easily (i.e. 0.2, Back Cover and MoM are not handheld titles nor numbered entries / the differences you could point out for KH1-3 vs. others are a product of expectations and budget more than storytelling, etc.), but instead I'll just say that I don't find it damaging at all given that, again, I like esoteric and meandering stories vastly more than I like KH3. And if the series is primarily going to focus on high budget high profile games from now on, I will find it vastly less interesting a story.

Chaser

September 9, 2020 @ 12:33 pmOffline

comment graphic

Unrelated to the recent posts - remember that Disney will shill Frozen through multiple mediums. They made two short films and a 5 part Lego series so Disney would of course get their biggest video game property (outside of their side companies like Star Wars and Marvel) to throw Frozen 2 into it.

In fact, just tonight another Frozen short film was announced for Disney+, which takes place during Frozen 1. It's Olaf's origin story and follows his first moments of life following Let It Go. It's completely unnecessary but alas, it exists.

[URL unfurl="true"]https://tvline.com/2020/09/09/frozen-olaf-origins-disney-plus-once-upon-a-snowman/[/URL]



Disney will find ways to keep Frozen alive and relevant, and the next big budget Disney video game is absolutely right there for them to exploit.

We can all disagree with Disney on how they treated the world in Kingdom Hearts 3 and not be thrilled at what they're going to do to harm the future stories for this world, but to deny that Frozen would come back at all just seems ignorant.

[S]Now to spend my 5th year hoping Disney sneaks a KH reference into the background of one of their projects. Forever salty that Wreck-it-Ralph 2 didn't do it. Thankfully Ducktales was kind enough to give us a confirmed Kingdom Hearts reference.[/S]

user avatar

ultima-demi

September 9, 2020 @ 01:24 pmOffline

comment graphic

I'm more optimistic about Frozen 2 being a lot better. Even if it's still bad I can't see it being Frozen 1 bad. What they have to work with by default is already a big improvement.

(No let it go for one :)) I hope KH4 is only next gen tho. I would think square would want to continue "wowing" people in how close they can visually get to the films. Not sure how likely they're to move to ue5 but i hope it's on the table. The tech advances with it being next gen only and on ue5 would make kh4 look nuts

SweetYetSalty

September 9, 2020 @ 03:15 pmOffline

comment graphic

I mean Frozen 2's world already has one big disadvantage to it already. It won't have Larxene, who was one of the saving graces of Arendelle along with Marshmallow.

Chie

September 9, 2020 @ 03:19 pmOffline

comment graphic

SweetYetSalty

I mean Frozen 2's world already has one big disadvantage to it already. It won't have Larxene, who was one of the saving graces of Arendelle along with Marshmallow.

I mean, we don't KNOW that Elrena won't happen to be there...

AdrianXXII

September 9, 2020 @ 03:23 pmOffline

comment graphic

Chaser

Unrelated to the recent posts - remember that Disney will shill Frozen through multiple mediums. They made two short films and a 5 part Lego series so Disney would of course get their biggest video game property (outside of their side companies like Star Wars and Marvel) to throw Frozen 2 into it.

In fact, just tonight another Frozen short film was announced for Disney+, which takes place during Frozen 1. It's Olaf's origin story and follows his first moments of life following Let It Go. It's completely unnecessary but alas, it exists.

[URL unfurl="true"]https://tvline.com/2020/09/09/frozen-olaf-origins-disney-plus-once-upon-a-snowman/[/URL]



Disney will find ways to keep Frozen alive and relevant, and the next big budget Disney video game is absolutely right there for them to exploit.

We can all disagree with Disney on how they treated the world in Kingdom Hearts 3 and not be thrilled at what they're going to do to harm the future stories for this world, but to deny that Frozen would come back at all just seems ignorant.

[S]Now to spend my 5th year hoping Disney sneaks a KH reference into the background of one of their projects. Forever salty that Wreck-it-Ralph 2 didn't do it. Thankfully Ducktales was kind enough to give us a confirmed Kingdom Hearts reference.[/S]

WHHHYYY? Do kids really like Olaf, or why is he constantly shoved into our face?

Oracle Spockanort

September 9, 2020 @ 03:28 pmOffline

comment graphic

AdrianXXII

WHHHYYY? Do kids really like Olaf, or why is he constantly shoved into our face?


Yes, they do. Also after Frozen 2, even a lot of adults changed their mind about Olaf (myself included).

He tests really well with children. His morbid humor and quirky nature just hits well with that audience.

AdrianXXII

September 9, 2020 @ 07:30 pmOffline

comment graphic

Oracle Spockanort

Yes, they do. Also after Frozen 2, even a lot of adults changed their mind about Olaf (myself included).

He tests really well with children. His morbid humor and quirky nature just hits well with that audience.

That's fair, while I'm still not a big fan of him, Frozen 2 did make him a bit more likable.

the red monster

September 9, 2020 @ 07:54 pmOffline

comment graphic

Ballad of Caius

I mean, am I too optimistic to expect KINGDOM HEARTS IV/4/WhateverIt'sCalled to be released by 2022?

P.S. I hope I don't have to buy a PS5 to get KH4.

PS4 will be long dead by 2022 (and ps5 will already get a price drop), sony asked big publishers to focus on PS5 from now on.
KH4 is 100% gonna be a next gen only. hopefully using UE5 and all the other next gen stuff.

Elysium

September 9, 2020 @ 08:00 pmOffline

comment graphic

the red monster

PS4 will be long dead by 2022 (and ps5 will already get a price drop), sony asked big publishers to focus on PS5 from now on.
KH4 is 100% gonna be a next gen only. hopefully using UE5 and all the other next gen stuff.
For heaven's sake... Hopefully it's a long time away then still, because I'm not ready to buy the PS5 yet.

Zettaflare

September 9, 2020 @ 09:04 pmOffline

comment graphic

Oracle Spockanort

Yes, they do. Also after Frozen 2, even a lot of adults changed their mind about Olaf (myself included).

He tests really well with children. His morbid humor and quirky nature just hits well with that audience.

I so badly wanted to see Olaf interact with Larxene and annoy her. She would have constantly tried to blast him to pieces and he would have kept putting himself together to spite her

Ballad of Caius

September 10, 2020 @ 12:38 amOffline

comment graphic

Launchpad

KH3 sold insanely well and I'm sure Disney and Square don't want to wait for the next big hit in the franchise. My guess would probably be 2023.

Yep. Good points.

Chaser

2022 for best case scenario, 2023 for realistically.

They pumped KH3 out in four years after resetting to UE4, but the pre-production on the game had been done (worlds selected, contracts with current Disney staff made etc).

If pre-prod for 4 began in 2019, then worlds and contracts would all be done. They don’t have to rebuild everything this time around, so they are reusing a lot of assets. They also have a UE4 workflow established and have their own system in place for it (even if it’s highly unoptimised like Digital Foundry suggested).

Very good points. IF they choose to go for PS4 or PS4 and 5 or just PS5, I presume that Unreal Engine 5 facilitates the "porting" on work done on a previous engine version, were they to make KH4 multiplat.

Chaser

Who knows what the thing outside of UXDR, MoM, and 4 is though. Could be like MoM and not be as intense on developing fresh assets and stuff so maybe they could get that out in 2021 / 2022.

HmmMMmmmMMmm... I wonder how big of a game that project could be. Maybe it could be bigger than MoM, but not as big as KH3? Like a sort of middle point.

Chaser

Then again, like everyone else on this forum, I’m not a game dev and games take longer to make so who knows! ??‍♂️

I presume video game developments are handled like project managements. You've got a Director that oversees the entire project and a Sub-Director who micromanages more while the other Directors, Event Planner, Composer, etc. report to Nomura. I presume video game development is like a typical office: the workload is on auto pilot, there's a workload and there are status meetings.

Oracle Spockanort

Yes, they do. Also after Frozen 2, even a lot of adults changed their mind about Olaf (myself included).

He tests really well with children. His morbid humor and quirky nature just hits well with that audience.

My brain farted and read this in Olaf's voice, LOL.

the red monster

KH4 is 100% gonna be a next gen only. hopefully using UE5 and all the other next gen stuff.

Unrelated, but I'll be salty if they don't finish the VII Remake project in the PS4 as well :(

the red monster

September 10, 2020 @ 01:31 amOffline

comment graphic

Ballad of Caius

Yep. Good points.


Very good points. IF they choose to go for PS4 or PS4 and 5 or just PS5, I presume that Unreal Engine 5 facilitates the "porting" on work done on a previous engine version, were they to make KH4 multiplat.


HmmMMmmmMMmm... I wonder how big of a game that project could be. Maybe it could be bigger than MoM, but not as big as KH3? Like a sort of middle point.


I presume video game developments are handled like project managements. You've got a Director that oversees the entire project and a Sub-Director who micromanages more while the other Directors, Event Planner, Composer, etc. report to Nomura. I presume video game development is like a typical office: the workload is on auto pilot, there's a workload and there are status meetings.


My brain farted and read this in Olaf's voice, LOL.


Unrelated, but I'll be salty if they don't finish the VII Remake project in the PS4 as well :(

I doubt FFVIIR will even finish on ps5 lmao. it takes 3 years to get each part out.
FFVIIR2 should be out around 2022-2023 too, so i don't see it running on PS4.

bobgoesw00t

September 10, 2020 @ 03:38 amOffline

comment graphic

I hope we get to go back to Derpendelle at some point and the broken Spirit Lord of the Land Elsa joins the party :D

Face My Fears

September 10, 2020 @ 04:25 pmOffline

comment graphic

Tartarus

For heaven's sake... Hopefully it's a long time away then still, because I'm not ready to buy the PS5 yet.

I'm already saving to buy a PS5 - again, solely for KH.

AdrianXXII

September 10, 2020 @ 04:30 pmOffline

comment graphic

Face My Fears

I'm already saving to buy a PS5 - again, solely for KH.

Same, planning on getting a special KH PS5, if possible.

user avatar

Foxycian

September 10, 2020 @ 08:37 pmOffline

comment graphic

Frozen 2 was better then frozen 1 in my opinion, the songs were great and the story was simple and fresh.

Neo_

September 13, 2020 @ 03:12 amOffline

comment graphic



Pre-production on what will most likely be Kingdom Hearts 4 also allegedly began in November 2019, several months after the release of Kingdom Hearts III but a couple of months before Kingdom Hearts III Re Mind.


Remind me why KH3 took so long to come out again... cause Toy Story needed to be in the game?

I'm really just salty cause I would've liked to have seen a 2008 KH3 over a 2019 one, not only to eliminate the wait, but I'd also be curious what they'd have chosen instead of BH6, Frozen and Tangled.

The Dark Mamba

September 13, 2020 @ 05:01 amOffline

comment graphic

Neo_GFX

Remind me why KH3 took so long to come out again... cause Toy Story needed to be in the game?

I'm really just salty cause I would've liked to have seen a 2008 KH3 over a 2019 one, not only to eliminate the wait, but I'd also be curious what they'd have chosen instead of BH6, Frozen and Tangled.


If Pixar was still available and there were still only 7 worlds my guess would be
Hercules
Toy Story
Monsters Inc.
At World's End (Might've been too soon though since the movie came out in 2007)
Incredibles
Hunchback (2008 so no DDD)
Jungle Book

Like it or hate it, numeral titled KH games are likely gonna go with newer Disney stuff like Moana or the Pixar stuff that remains unused. Anything that's not that is probably "side game" material now.

Cumguardian69

September 13, 2020 @ 05:20 amOffline

comment graphic

Neo_GFX
I'm really just salty cause I would've liked to have seen a 2008 KH3 over a 2019 one,

Remember that KH3 (and really, all of the KH games post 2) took so long to come out because of FF14 disaster and other SE mismanagement. They basically had to do a total restructure from inside out. Development on the KH games after 3 was crazy hampered, because SE needed to make deals with Nintendo and Sony for their other platforms in order to churn a profit (developing for the PS3 was and never will be easy)

2 quid is good

September 13, 2020 @ 11:01 amOffline

comment graphic

Sakuraba Neku

Fortunately ReMind came out and that definitely felt like it was done for the fans and only us. So good!

Doesn't this worry anyone else? What if future KH games follow the pattern of a base game being a Disney fiesta and the dlc being catered to more hardcore fans. I can deal with it happening in this case but I certainly don't want that to happen again

AdrianXXII

September 13, 2020 @ 11:14 amOffline

comment graphic

2 quid is good

Doesn't this worry anyone else? What if future KH games follow the pattern of a base game being a Disney fiesta and the dlc being catered to more hardcore fans. I can deal with it happening in this case but I certainly don't want that to happen again

I honestly would be surprised, if that will be the formula. The main selling point for those outside of the fan base, are the Disney worlds, so seeing they move the units I feel they'll get priority.

Plus putting the fan catered stuff in DLC is a sure fire way to sell that DLC, seeing they're the ones willing to fork over the cash.

2 quid is good

September 13, 2020 @ 06:00 pmOffline

comment graphic

AdrianXXII

I honestly would be surprised, if that will be the formula. The main selling point for those outside of the fan base, are the Disney worlds, so seeing they move the units I feel they'll get priority.

Plus putting the fan catered stuff in DLC is a sure fire way to sell that DLC, seeing they're the ones willing to fork over the cash.

Yeah I understand how it'll make financial sense for Square but that just sounds really depressing to me, that the KH game that I would most be pleased with would be locked behind a paywall

Noivern

September 13, 2020 @ 06:25 pmOffline

comment graphic

Geez, this thread surely was.. a lot, lol.

I think people have a lot.. of residual anger towards Frozen as an IP because of how much Disney pushed it, but I think it was a really cool movie and all the kids I know love it as well.
You know. The target audience.

Haven't seen 2 yet but I know it's considered a much better movie and features more to work with as well (and the better soundtrack. I love Into the unknow SO MUCH.)

As for the world itself: I agree that Arandelle was probably the worst world in 3. But I felt the same towards Port Royale in 2 and I hate that franchise with passion. Turns out The Caribbean was probably my favorite world in 3, or at least the one I have the most memories of.

I'm personally excited to see what they'll do with this whenever we do get a fourth entry in the main series.

SweetYetSalty

September 13, 2020 @ 07:13 pmOffline

comment graphic

2 quid is good

Doesn't this worry anyone else? What if future KH games follow the pattern of a base game being a Disney fiesta and the dlc being catered to more hardcore fans. I can deal with it happening in this case but I certainly don't want that to happen again

This has crossed my mind for future big title KH games, like for KH4. I would not like that because I remember by San Fransokyo I stopped caring about the Disney plot and was rushing the game. I enjoyed the ReMind/Limitcut dlc more then base KH3, but I wouldn't want that to be a norm.

Elysium

September 13, 2020 @ 08:42 pmOffline

comment graphic

The Dark Mamba


At World's End (Might've been too soon though since the movie came out in 2007)

Even better, we would've got the superior Dead Man's Chest.

Noivern

Geez, this thread surely was.. a lot, lol.

I think people have a lot.. of residual anger towards Frozen as an IP because of how much Disney pushed it, but I think it was a really cool movie and all the kids I know love it as well.
You know. The target audience.

Haven't seen 2 yet but I know it's considered a much better movie and features more to work with as well (and the better soundtrack. I love Into the unknow SO MUCH.)
Yes, there's a lot of online rage directed at Frozen, not simply among KH fans... Well, tough cookie because Frozen is great, and definitely better than the other Disney Revival films, imo. TP&TF is the only other one I'm overly fond of. Moana was alright and Tangled grew on me thanks to the TV series being awesome.

I listened to the soundtrack before seeing the film, too. "Into the Unknown" was good beforehand, but I thought the scene itself really elevated the song. Speaking of the songs, I wonder if / when they do Frozen 2 in KH, if it'll include a few of the songs like "Let It Go" and "Do You Want to Build a Snowman?" in KH3. If they only do one of the songs, I hope they pick "Show Yourself." That one was gorgeous and makes me tear up a bit during the film.

Mog

September 14, 2020 @ 01:58 pmOffline

comment graphic

Arendelle better not become the new Atlantica/Agrabah.

Would rather they not include this world if Disney demands such a control over its content. We know how that turned out in KH3. A waste of time that did not even make narrative sense as a contained world in the game, with the omission of Hans.

If Nomura can negotiate more creative control from the getgo it could be somewhat entertaining. Not hyped for it in any scenario though. I am of the opinion that Kingdom Hearts needs to start pushing the ratio of worlds in the favour of original worlds, not Disney ones. It doesn't need them any longer.

Ballad of Caius

September 14, 2020 @ 07:45 pmOffline

comment graphic

Neo_GFX

Remind me why KH3 took so long to come out again... cause Toy Story needed to be in the game?

No. To the best of my memories, Toy Story has been a property that Nomura has been wanting to implement ever since the very first KH game. Other titles he's been trying to put in have been the Jungle Book and Treasure Planet.

Besides that point, KH3 took a long time to come out since it's announcement way back in 2013 because they lost, allegedly, a year worth of dev time (some of us argue that they lost a lot more, considering how butchered the original properties of KH are).

Neo_GFX

I'm really just salty cause I would've liked to have seen a 2008 KH3 over a 2019 one,

Correct me if I'm wrong, but didn't Nomura himself say that he was not satisfied with how limited the PS3 was in terms of implementing his vision towards what KH3 ended up being in the PS4?

Neo_GFX

but I'd also be curious what they'd have chosen instead of BH6, Frozen and Tangled.

Would be complicated to answer, seeing as how release after release it was criticized that the Worlds added nothing to the overarching narrative of the game. Whereas KH3, each World had its own story that either explicitly told you how it adds to the grand scheme of things, or foreshadows what's going to happen (the Toybox world's heart being split into two to experiment the behavior of split hearts foreshadowing Xion's return).

2 quid is good

Doesn't this worry anyone else? What if future KH games follow the pattern of a base game being a Disney fiesta and the dlc being catered to more hardcore fans. I can deal with it happening in this case but I certainly don't want that to happen again

KH3 had a... complicated dev cycle. I'm convinced that SE's management will push Nomura to release DLC for KH4, but I'm sure it'll be another case of a single piece of DLC. What could be a norm is that we'll get a "mainline" KH game and then a piece of DLC that foreshadows the next game. I don't think we'll get a plethora of DLC with customizing options, bosses, etc.

AdrianXXII

I honestly would be surprised, if that will be the formula. The main selling point for those outside of the fan base, are the Disney worlds, so seeing they move the units I feel they'll get priority.

Nomura himself said that building a world as DLC from the ground up would be too much work. If Re:MIND is any sort of precedent, only a fraction of the main KH dev team will be purposed to work on DLC, meaning that it would take too much time for a small team to develop something as big as a KH3 scale world.

Noivern

I think people have a lot.. of residual anger towards Frozen as an IP because of how much Disney pushed it, but I think it was a really cool movie and all the kids I know love it as well.

I'm gonna be conservative and expect nothing of KHwhatever's iteration of the Frozen 2 world. Arendelle personally felt to me like a chore, and this is coming after playing the Caribbean, which was basically a barebones fast forward of the two Pirates of the Caribbean movies. Though I'm hopeful that the Frozen 2 world will be AT LEAST better than KH3's Arandelle. Other than that, we'll have to see the Japanese fandom's reception towards the Frozen world and see how they expressed their sentiment in the game's survey (Q&A's).

AdrianXXII

September 14, 2020 @ 07:55 pmOffline

comment graphic

Ballad of Caius

Nomura himself said that building a world as DLC from the ground up would be too much work. If Re:MIND is any sort of precedent, only a fraction of the main KH dev team will be purposed to work on DLC, meaning that it would take too much time for a small team to develop something as big as a KH3 scale world.

I think you misunderstood me or maybe i just wasn't clear. I think that KH games will always prioritize the realization of the Disney Worlds for the main games release.

Meaning that the original conetent we fans are mostly here for will tend to get the short end of the stick and might be religated to most being realized in the DLC. Which would be a shame if all the meaning ful interactions and story beats are,behind an additional paywall.

the red monster

September 14, 2020 @ 07:57 pmOffline

comment graphic

Mog

am of the opinion that Kingdom Hearts needs to start pushing the ratio of worlds in the favour of original worlds, not Disney ones. It doesn't need them any longer.

This.
the original stuff is so much better and interesting, for me the disney worlds are just fillers and i mostly speedrun them. i enjoy them for what they are, but i don't really care about their plot. KH3 made them a bit better but still meh and took too much focus from the actual main plot.
50/50 would be the sweet spot.

Ballad of Caius

September 14, 2020 @ 08:57 pmOffline

comment graphic

AdrianXXII

I think you misunderstood me or maybe i just wasn't clear. I think that KH games will always prioritize the realization of the Disney Worlds for the main games release.

Meaning that the original conetent we fans are mostly here for will tend to get the short end of the stick and might be religated to most being realized in the DLC. Which would be a shame if all the meaning ful interactions and story beats are,behind an additional paywall.

Like I said: I think original content wasn't as prioritized as Disney is because more of the content they had to cut due to the one year (or more) of dev time they loss.

As to KH changing its Disney formula: I presume that years from now we may start to see more original worlds than Disney ones, or Disney will be more flexible and the KH team will have more creativity in terms of delivering more original content in Disney worlds.

SweetYetSalty

September 14, 2020 @ 09:04 pmOffline

comment graphic

I'm hoping for more flexible from Disney. I want the Disney elements of the world to better help the overall plot of Kingdom Hearts. I would name examples but I feel like I would just be a broken record at this point. In short when I go to a Disney world in a future KH game I want it to truly impact the plot, and for something important to happen. Remember when Sora found Kairi on Hook's pirate ship?

Noivern

September 14, 2020 @ 09:17 pmOffline

comment graphic

SweetYetSalty

I'm hoping for more flexible from Disney. I want the Disney elements of the world to better help the overall plot of Kingdom Hearts.I would name examples but I feel like I would just be a broken record at this point. In short when I go to a Disney world in a future KH game I want it to truly impact the plot, and for something important to happen. Remember when Sora found Kairi on Hook's pirate ship?


Unfortunately the fandom seems to have grow around the idea that more original worlds = more freedom and story, when the KH game with the most plot and less convoluted elements was the very first one that only featured three original worlds (four if we consider the last one a full fledged world, which I personally don't).

I have also talked about this in another thread, but I seriously doubt the lack of "meat" in Disney worlds is completely on Disney Side, but more so on the development team itself deciding to throw story bits in cutscenes and inbetween worlds to leave more freedom to the order in which we tackle worlds.

I personally don't really care for more original worlds when we have barely used the ones we have; Radiant Garden was barely playable, Skaia and Daybreak are both a joke, Twilight Town is just a hub world with a barebones mansion. I just want to see more Final Fantasy characters doing their thing again, I was really unhappy when neither Lightning nor Noctis showed up in 3 (well, Noctis kinda did in both Riku's new design and Yozora, I guess? lol).

I don't really care if the story for the Frozen 2 world is really strict again as long as the world itself is fun. KH3 features ridiculously oversized worlds but there are barely any secrets in them. Give us secret bosses, post-game secrets, anything besides the Hidden Mickeys and farming materials, really. lol

SweetYetSalty

September 14, 2020 @ 09:33 pmOffline

comment graphic

Noivern

Unfortunately the fandom seems to have grow around the idea that more original worlds = more freedom and story, when the KH game with the most plot and less convoluted elements was the very first one that only featured three original worlds (four if we consider the last one a full fledged world, which I personally don't).

I have also talked about this in another thread, but I seriously doubt the lack of "meat" in Disney worlds is completely on Disney Side, but more so on the development team itself deciding to throw story bits in cutscenes and inbetween worlds to leave more freedom to the order in which we tackle worlds.

I personally don't really care for more original worlds when we have barely used the ones we have; Radiant Garden was barely playable, Skaia and Daybreak are both a joke, Twilight Town is just a hub world with a barebones mansion. I just want to see more Final Fantasy characters doing their thing again, I was really unhappy when neither Lightning nor Noctis showed up in 3 (well, Noctis kinda did in both Riku's new design and Yozora, I guess? lol).

I don't really care if the story for the Frozen 2 world is really strict again as long as the world itself is fun. KH3 features ridiculously oversized worlds but there are barely any secrets in them. Give us secret bosses, post-game secrets, anything besides the Hidden Mickeys and farming materials, really. lol

I'm still pretty neutral on the Final Fantasy characters. I'd like appearances, of course, but I won't get upset if they don't appear. KH has more then enough original characters that cover it.

But for the Disney side of things, I just want them to play a more important role. Have the Disney villains truly working with the KH original villains to better connect the story, instead of just coming into a movie plot that has little to do with what is happening in the core game. Because that's where the feeling of filler comes from. Looking at you, Pride Lands!

Noivern

September 15, 2020 @ 12:02 amOffline

comment graphic

SweetYetSalty

I'm still pretty neutral on the Final Fantasy characters. I'd like appearances, of course, but I won't get upset if they don't appear. KH has more then enough original characters that cover it.

But for the Disney side of things, I just want them to play a more important role. Have the Disney villains truly working with the KH original villains to better connect the story, instead of just coming into a movie plot that has little to do with what is happening in the core game. Because that's where the feeling of filler comes from. Looking at you, Pride Lands!


I disagree. While we have a lot of original KH characters at this point, they all have very specific mainstory rules, while the FF ones used to add substance and a fun twist in the Disney worlds, making even the most monotonous ones a bit more interesting because of them.

We can't really have Hayner, Pence and Olette in Agrabah, for one, but we could have had Locke from FFVI or Snow Villiers from FFXIII in Arandelle.

Olympus Coliseum was a drag, but it brought us Cloud with a really cool unique design, and then later Auron and Zack.

For me, personally, it's about how they allow us to have a cool new twist over the stories we know by heart. The mobile games kinda did this (specially Dark Road), but it's not really the same over there.

SweetYetSalty

September 15, 2020 @ 02:49 amOffline

comment graphic

Noivern

I disagree. While we have a lot of original KH characters at this point, they all have very specific mainstory rules, while the FF ones used to add substance and a fun twist in the Disney worlds, making even the most monotonous ones a bit more interesting because of them.

We can't really have Hayner, Pence and Olette in Agrabah, for one, but we could have had Locke from FFVI or Snow Villiers from FFXIII in Arandelle.

Olympus Coliseum was a drag, but it brought us Cloud with a really cool unique design, and then later Auron and Zack.

For me, personally, it's about how they allow us to have a cool new twist over the stories we know by heart. The mobile games kinda did this (specially Dark Road), but it's not really the same over there.

Hey, who says Hayner, Pence, and Olette can't go to Agrabah? Now that they've broken the world order and went to another world, they are official world jumpers now. Next time we go to Agrabah I expect to see all three there. Olette can be the local belly dancer, Pence can be a fire breather, and Hayner can be the one to cut off people's arms for stealing. Or just cut off their ears if he doesn't like their face, it's up to him.

AdrianXXII

September 15, 2020 @ 03:29 amOffline

comment graphic

I think the FF chatacters just bring a different energy with them. The interaction between Yuffie and Cid is unlike any we had among the original characters.

Also like [USER=251825]@Noivern[/USER] said it's just kind of fun to see how they'd be reimagined to fit with a given Disney World, something we sadly didn't get to see that much in the series so far.

Ballad of Caius

Like I said: I think original content wasn't as prioritized as Disney is because more of the content they had to cut due to the one year (or more) of dev time they loss.

As to KH changing its Disney formula: I presume that years from now we may start to see more original worlds than Disney ones, or Disney will be more flexible and the KH team will have more creativity in terms of delivering more original content in Disney worlds.

Yeah, my point is just that when in a pinch like they ended up being with KH3, the Disney Worlds would be top priority. Not saying they're always going to be as neglected as they were in 3, but that because they are the big selling point, that SE will put the focus on them.

Hopefully they will start delivering more plot in the Disney Worlds or at least develop the universe and characters in them. I feel KH3 had worlds that were a step in the right direction.

Neo_

September 16, 2020 @ 06:39 amOffline

comment graphic

Ballad of Caius
No. To the best of my memories, Toy Story has been a property that Nomura has been wanting to implement ever since the very first KH game. Other titles he's been trying to put in have been the Jungle Book and Treasure Planet.

I could've sworn there was interview where he said that was the reason... can anyone back me up on this? An interview where Nomura said KH3 was put-off so much because he wouldn't do it until he could put Toy Story in the game.

Ballad of Caius
Besides that point, KH3 took a long time to come out since it's announcement way back in 2013 because they lost, allegedly, a year worth of dev time (some of us argue that they lost a lot more, considering how butchered the original properties of KH are).

I didn't really mean why it took so long to come out after being announced in 2013, but just why it took so long to be announced in general.

Chaser

September 16, 2020 @ 07:04 amOffline

comment graphic




“For me, because I wanted to put this world into [Kingdom Hearts] since KH2, I am deeply moved that it’s actually happened,” Nomura told Famitsu. Nomura added felt a Toy Story world was “absolutely necessary” for Kingdom Hearts 3 and explained that he began talking about the possibility of doing something with Toy Story while making the first Kingdom Hearts! So, for example, when Pixar’s John Lasseter came to Japan, Nomura met with him to discuss this. Lasseter asked him how he planned to bring Toy Story to KH, and Nomura explained his vision. Years later, it finally happened.

“It’s taken a long time,” Nomura told Famitsu, with a chuckle.

[URL unfurl="true"]https://www.kotaku.com.au/2017/07/how-toy-story-came-to-kingdom-hearts-3/[/URL]






Toy Story and Kingdom Hearts feel like a natural fit, and it's an IP that has been pushed for the game ever since the original Kingdom Hearts. For Nomura, Kingdom Hearts III would not have ever been made if Toy Story had not been approved for use.

Edge Magazine issue #328
[URL unfurl="true"]https://www.khinsider.com/news/Edge-Magazine-Features-Kingdom-Hearts-III-Cover-Story-14331[/URL]



Both statements are true so everyone is happy :). Nomura had wanted Toy Story since the early games and wouldn’t have made 3 without it.

user avatar

Idreamaboutcats

September 16, 2020 @ 07:06 amOffline

comment graphic

To be honest, I kind of expected it. Don't forget, some of the new princesses still are unaccounted for, and so far, Tiana, Merida, and Moana can fill in those gaps as they're already Disney Princesses, but the story of the new princesses obviously isn't over, so delving into sequel films isn't a stretch, especially if said film actually managed to be a success and didn't fall into the "sequel curse."

I am definitely not ready to buy a PS5 yet. I bought a PS3 for KH, turned out that the new numbered title skips a generation and all the games in that time were handheld. Lesson learned. I'll wait until there is a confirmation of a IV on PS5.

I do wonder if they'll really switch to UE5. That demo was gorgeous, and honestly, Luminous Engine was not worth the time. XV came out way past its initial announcement and it was still buggy as hell. I'm not looking forward to Project Athia...

Elysium

September 16, 2020 @ 07:45 amOffline

comment graphic



I bought a PS3 for KH, turned out that the new numbered title skips a generation and all the games in that time were handheld. Lesson learned. I'll wait until there is a confirmation of a IV on PS5.

Same thing happened to me. But at least there were the ReMIXes and some other non-KH games I've played on PS3, so I don't feel too angry about it in retrospect.

AdrianXXII

September 16, 2020 @ 08:10 amOffline

comment graphic

Idreamaboutcats

To be honest, I kind of expected it. Don't forget, some of the new princesses still are unaccounted for, and so far, Tiana, Merida, and Moana can fill in those gaps as they're already Disney Princesses, but the story of the new princesses obviously isn't over, so delving into sequel films isn't a stretch, especially if said film actually managed to be a success and didn't fall into the "sequel curse."

I am definitely not ready to buy a PS5 yet. I bought a PS3 for KH, turned out that the new numbered title skips a generation and all the games in that time were handheld. Lesson learned. I'll wait until there is a confirmation of a IV on PS5.

I do wonder if they'll really switch to UE5. That demo was gorgeous, and honestly, Luminous Engine was not worth the time. XV came out way past its initial announcement and it was still buggy as hell. I'm not looking forward to Project Athia...

I made that mistake twice. Once with the PS3 thinking it'd get KH3 and once with the PS Vita thinking that BBSv2 was definitely going to release on that... I was wrong both times. Luckily both consoles had enough other games to make them worth while, but I did learn my lesson to not buy until there's a game I really badly want for it.

Ballad of Caius

September 16, 2020 @ 01:06 pmOffline

comment graphic

Neo_GFX

but just why it took so long to be announced in general.

Kingdom Hearts III was always on Nomura's head, just that that they were preoccupied developing that other stories that needed to be told before KHIII.

Chaser

Both statements are true so everyone is happy :). Nomura had wanted Toy Story since the early games and wouldn’t have made 3 without it.

Ah, now I remember. Thanks for sharing, Sign.

Idreamaboutcats

I do wonder if they'll really switch to UE5.

If KHIV is multiplat, then no. If it's next gen exclusive, then yes.

Idreamaboutcats

XV came out way past its initial announcement and it was still buggy as hell.

We can't really compare FFXV with KH3. FINAL FANTASY 15 was an open-world game that had to be developed under three years; KH3 had a reasonable amount of time with experienced devs.

Idreamaboutcats

I'm not looking forward to Project Athia...

I'm sorta looking forward to Athia, even though it looks like a Black Mage FF15 mode game.

Somnus cealum

September 17, 2020 @ 01:58 pmOffline

comment graphic

i agree that frozen in kh3 was not good but if this is true, i hope it was way better then it was in kh3. i love frozen and i hope they do good in kh4

+ Reply

footer image

Since 2003, KINGDOM HEARTS Insider has been the largest fan community and news resource on the web for the series. We are your one stop shop for all your KINGDOM HEARTS news, media, discussion, and fandom, from the original, to Birth by Sleep, KINGDOM HEARTS 3, and beyond!

  • Video Game Music
  • Zophar's Domain Emulation
  • Final Fantasy Extreme
  • KH World

©2016 KHInsider. KINGDOM HEARTS official artwork, trailers, characters, merchandise, and music is copyrighted to Square Enix and Disney.
Original material is licensed under a Creative Commons License permitting non-commercial sharing with attribution.
Please read our privacy policy for more information | Legal Information