COMMUNITY SPOTLIGHT

Elsa, Anna, Rapunzel, and Kairi make up four of the new Princesses of Heart. Come theorise who the last three Princesses will be!

NEWSLETTER

Subscribe to Kingdom Hearts News!

Enter your email address:

   

POLL

Who do you prefer to play as in Kingdom Hearts 3D?

Sora - 100%
Riku - 0%

Total votes: 1, but the poll doesn't work yet

Tetsuya Nomura Leaves Final Fantasy XV, Focusing on Kingdom Hearts 3

Surfacing from out of nowhere to everyone's surprise, Tetsuya Nomura has left Final Fantasy XV and will be focusing on other titles, such as Kingdom Hearts III. Replacing his position as director will be Hajime Tabata, who had formerly joined the project as the Co-Director.

Although further details have not been released, it must come as a shock to the worldwide community. Final Fantasy XV was announced in 2005 and has experienced rather shaky development over the years. Could it be that Nomura was taken off due to the incredible period of time that has passed and lack of release? 

View the press release below:

The company also announced today that, as part of a development restructure, Hajime Tabata, director of the original FINAL FANTASY TYPE-0 and FINAL FANTASY TYPE-0 HD, will now serve as the director of FINAL FANTASY XV, as the development of the title moves towards completion. This move allows Tetsuya Nomura to focus his full efforts as the director of other highly anticipated titles, including KINGDOM HEARTS III.

“In reviewing our development structure, we have decided to assign Hajime Tabata as the new director for FINAL FANTASY XV. Currently, Tabata and the entire development team are working, whole-heartedly, towards completing the production of FINAL FANTASY XV and ensuring the delivery of the highest quality FINAL FANTASY title to date,” said Square Enix CEO Yosuke Matsuda regarding the staff changes. “We invite every one of our fans to view the fruits of our labor through FINAL FANTASY XV’s demo, and promise to present a game that further surpasses expectations when the finished product is released.

“As the director of FINAL FANTASY XV, Tetsuya Nomura has mainly worked on the original concept for the story and universe in addition to creating the characters. Hereafter, he will be focusing his efforts on the production of titles that can only be made possible by Nomura, himself, and delivering products that exceed the quality of past titles, starting with another one of his representative projects, KINGDOM HEARTS III. Square Enix will continue to work on these titles with the best staff formation in an effort to deliver them to everyone as soon as possible and appreciates your continued support.”

Square Enix Europe also commented on Nomura's departure from Final Fantasy XV:

If that wasn’t enough news, I’ve got a little something else to share with you. Now I know you guys want us at Square Enix to be more open with you and to keep you updated with all the goings on with our games so I’m going to talk to you a little more about Final Fantasy XV since I’m sure you guys are just as excited about it as I am (which is VERY excited).

The development of Final Fantasy XV is coming along really well and as a result Hajime Tabata (the director of the original Final Fantasy Type-0 and Type-0 HD) has taken over from Tetsuya Nomura as the director of Final Fantasy XV. 

Now before you start to freak out, let me explain how this is a good thing. There’s no denying that Tetsuya Nomura has been instrumental to the development of Final Fantasy XV and he’s done an incredible job. His main role as director was working on the original concept for the story and universe and also creating the characters. Now that development of Final Fantasy XV has come so far, Nomura’s work is pretty much all in place so instead of having him keep an eye on the more day to day stuff, we thought it’d be a better idea to pass the reigns over to Hajime Tabata and let Nomura move onto other projects and make games that only he could do, you know, like Kingdom Hearts III.

So now we have Hajime Tabata and the rest of his team working as hard as they can on Final Fantasy XV and making sure it’s the best game it can possibly be and we have Tetsuya Nomura and the Kingdom Hearts III team working as hard as they can to make that the best game that can be. It also means that both games will come out much sooner this way. Instead of waiting until Final Fantasy XV comes out before starting on Kingdom Hearts III, Tetsuya Nomura can now properly begin work on Kingdom Hearts III right now and with Tabata in the director’s chair, Final Fantasy XV won’t suffer either.

Hajime Tabata and his team are a bunch of really talented people and Final Fantasy XV is in good hands for the rest of its development but even if you don’t want to believe me, you can find out for yourself on 20th March 2015 when you can play Final Fantasy XV for yourself along with Final Fantasy Type-0 HD.

Why do you think Nomura has left the project? Do you think this will impact Kingdom Hearts 3 in any way, and if so, how?

COMMENTS

+ Reply

crash13

September 18, 2014 @ 01:12 amOffline

comment graphic

I'm hyped. I think this means KH3 is in full force now.

Face My Fears

September 18, 2014 @ 01:16 amOffline

comment graphic

I'm happy. I didn't even know about FF XV being announced back then. Now KHIII can get the focus that it deserves.

Sign

September 18, 2014 @ 01:21 amOffline

comment graphic

XV was his baby. I can't imagine he'd ever leave the project voluntarily. If he was forced off the project for one reason or another, the impact can't be good for him.

This puts KH3 in a questionable position.

Antifa Lockhart

September 18, 2014 @ 01:23 amOffline

comment graphic

EeL
I'm happy. I didn't even know about FF XV being announced back then. Now KHIII can get the focus that it deserves.

The post is off by a year, it was revealed in 2006, but yeah it's been a long haul. I wonder if this means that Nomura's happy enough with XV's development, or if he wasn't feeling the pressure. I vaguely recall him saying that FF XV would be his last time directing a final fantasy because of that. I could be misremembering that though. Either way, YAY KH3

LightUpTheSky452

September 18, 2014 @ 01:26 amOffline

comment graphic

I'm so torn about this. On one hand, it might mean that we'll get KH sooner and that it's getting Nomura's focus that it needs. XV also seems to be moving more swiftly now, but...

I feel so bad for Nomura. So bad, in fact. Poor man. I don't pity him his predicament at all. I wonder if this will end up effecting the mood of the game at all... Wow.

I also wonder if this is why they've been recruiting more people for KHIII lately, because they are moving along with III faster now that Nomura's more at the helm again.

mLahulia

September 18, 2014 @ 01:26 amOffline

comment graphic

im takin this as a good sign

Ruran

September 18, 2014 @ 01:26 amOffline

comment graphic

This is REALLY surprising, yet...idk. I don't see it as a bad thing. FFXV has been a thing for almost ten years now and with a playable demo coming out early next year I think this just might mean that there isn't much else for Nomura to "do". The story must've been finished forever ago as well as all the ground work, voice acting, music, etc. At this point it's just a matter of putting everything together. Unless Nomura hasn't actually been involved with FFXV for a long time and just recently chose to announce it, then he was already involved with most of the heavy lifting and Tabata will be putting the final touches. Unless Tabata does an enormous overhaul, it's still "Nomura's game".

I don't take it as a bad sign, I think it just means that Square is confident enough with XV's progress that Nomura doesn't have to be there because all the fundamentals are ready and Nomura can now focus on his one true love-Kingdom Hearts.

Or I'm being overly optimistic, lol.

Chaser

September 18, 2014 @ 01:29 amOffline

comment graphic

Tinny
The post is off by a year, it was revealed in 2006, but yeah it's been a long haul. I wonder if this means that Nomura's happy enough with XV's development, or if he wasn't feeling the pressure. I vaguely recall him saying that FF XV would be his last time directing a final fantasy because of that. I could be misremembering that though. Either way, YAY KH3

I don't think he's happy. He's spent the last 8 years trying to get it right and he couldn't. Now he lost his directors job on the game.

DefiantHeart

September 18, 2014 @ 01:33 amOffline

comment graphic

Personally I think they removed him since he already seemed to have his hands full with the other projects. They're putting a lot of demand on Nomura it seems lately, so I hope that helps makes things less stressful for him.

Luap

September 18, 2014 @ 01:37 amOffline

comment graphic

I really wonder what the specific circumstances behind this are. To be in charge of a project for 8 years, and then have it taken away from you sounds horrible... but, considering it's really bumpy development cycle, it could also be sort of a relief? It's possible he stepped down; got what he felt was a good foundation started, and then went on to KH3 which requires his involvement. But it's also possible that he was forced out. Depending on what happened, this could put KH3 in either a really bad or really good place.

Hopefully in an interview Nomura will address this. If he left voluntarily, I can't see a reason for him to not talk about it. If he was forced out, then he probably won't be allowed to talk about it. This is concerning, but I wanna stay hopeful and believe that this will be a good thing.

Lnds500

September 18, 2014 @ 01:44 amOffline

comment graphic

I am truly shocked. For me XV = Nomura. To be working on a game for so many years (yes, doing a shitty job - that's true) and being removed from it. What a terrible blow...

Zettaflare

September 18, 2014 @ 01:46 amOffline

comment graphic

Wow, I did not see this coming. I'm not quite sure how to feel. This was going to be Nomura's first FF title.


Though this does lead me to wonder what's going to happen with KH3, since this could mean he has more time to work on it. Maybe it might be released sooner than we thought.

Taochan

September 18, 2014 @ 01:50 amOffline

comment graphic

Knowing Nomura, he probably quit. I think he ran away back to the safety of Kingdom Hearts, where he has total creative freedom and far less pressure. Tabata joining must have ruffled feathers.

I'm honestly quite sad about the entire situation. Tabata is fantastic, but this was Nomura's baby and he spent a long time working on it only to not finish it.

Alpha Sonix

September 18, 2014 @ 01:50 amOffline

comment graphic

Honestly, I think this can only be good for the guy. I've always felt that Nomura likes to manage too many projects at once and ultimately that means he spends less time with his family so even if it is disheartening that he won't be able to oversee the project anymore, it probably is best for his health and it also means he can focus his full attention on KH3.

In terms of FFXV though, what does this say about its development cycle?

Ruran

September 18, 2014 @ 01:52 amOffline

comment graphic

As the director of FINAL FANTASY XV, Tetsuya Nomura has mainly worked on the original concept for the story and universe in addition to creating the characters. Hereafter, he will be focusing his efforts on the production of titles that can only be made possible by Nomura, himself, and delivering products that exceed the quality of past titles, starting with another one of his representative projects, KINGDOM HEARTS III. Square Enix will continue to work on these titles with the best staff formation in an effort to deliver them to everyone as soon as possible and appreciates your continued support.


This is such a weird phrasing... What does this even mean? It just gives me the mental image of Nomura working forever alone in a dark room trying to finish all his projects as a one man team.

Nomura exile confirmed.

gosoxtim

September 18, 2014 @ 01:57 amOffline

comment graphic

Ruran
This is such a weird phrasing... What does this even mean? It just gives me the mental image of Nomura working forever alone in a dark room trying to finish all his projects as a one man team.

Nomura exile confirmed.


that ign wording for you ign always word there articles like that you can't spell ignorant without ign

Chaser

September 18, 2014 @ 01:58 amOffline

comment graphic

gosoxtim
that ign wording for you ign always word there articles like that you can't spell ignorant without ign


Actually that's from an official press release from Square Enix.

Lnds500

September 18, 2014 @ 02:01 amOffline

comment graphic

Alpha Sonix
In terms of FFXV though, what does this say about its development cycle?





At this point, they just wanna piss us off.

robvandam111

September 18, 2014 @ 02:09 amOffline

comment graphic

Ruran
This is such a weird phrasing... What does this even mean? It just gives me the mental image of Nomura working forever alone in a dark room trying to finish all his projects as a one man team.

Nomura exile confirmed.



Maybe they're just complimenting him. Meaning, there was something wrong with the original production of the game. So he's been working on it immensely to make sure the quality exceeds expectations due to past negativities. And now he's onto bigger things and that's KH3.

Sdog

September 18, 2014 @ 02:14 amOffline

comment graphic

While im glad he'll be able to put more time into KH3 it's a little bittersweet with XV. I hope he thought his work was done with XV meaning it's close to being done, and not something that was taken from him.

He had enough on his plate, man has gotta take things one at a time.

Taochan

September 18, 2014 @ 02:15 amOffline

comment graphic

Ruran
This is such a weird phrasing... What does this even mean? It just gives me the mental image of Nomura working forever alone in a dark room trying to finish all his projects as a one man team.

Nomura exile confirmed.

Yeah, all this said to me was "Nomura is going back to KH and he's never allowed to touch anything else again."

WaveK89

September 18, 2014 @ 02:15 amOffline

comment graphic

I'm wondering what the whole atmosphere of their development team is going to be like after these two titles are finally released. I'm serious. When I think of the teams for FFXV and KH3, I imagine Atlas holding up the world for each person.

If Nomura is out of the FFXV picture, then he sure must be feeling lighter right now.

user avatar

The Conquerer

September 18, 2014 @ 02:17 amOffline

comment graphic

Well I long since stopped worrying about Versus or rather FFXV, but I can't say it isn't slightly worrisome that Nomura no longer has an input on its development cycle. FFXV meant so much to Nomura. It was his pet project, a dream that he wanted to pursue and make true. To say Kingdom Hearts was simply his calling all along isn't so clear. Nomura took precious time away from wrapping up the current series of KH due to him spending most of his energies toward FFXV. Nomura didn't even think KH would be a success, when it was, he felt he had to make a sequel. Nomura was torn with furthering the KH series right away, or starting and finishing what he wanted to be see done differently out of Final Fantasy, i.e., the Versus moniker. Nomura has received pressure from all sides, Disney, the fans, his bosses, etc, to work on KH3, but he adamantly said in the past that Versus (now FFXV) took precedent (obviously that isn't so much case now). I'm wondering how this is going to affect morale, knowing that he couldn't finish what he started.

Lnds500

September 18, 2014 @ 02:21 amOffline

comment graphic

Ruran
This is such a weird phrasing... What does this even mean? It just gives me the mental image of Nomura working forever alone in a dark room trying to finish all his projects as a one man team.

Nomura exile confirmed.


Taochan
Yeah, all this said to me was "Nomura is going back to KH and he's never allowed to touch anything else again."


Who else is starting to think that Nomura will quit after KH3?

Ruran

September 18, 2014 @ 02:25 amOffline

comment graphic

robvandam111
Maybe they're just complimenting him. Meaning, there was something wrong with the original production of the game. So he's been working on it immensely to make sure the quality exceeds expectations due to past negativities. And now he's onto bigger things and that's KH3.


idk, I'm with Taochan in that something's kind of iffy. The comment feels sort of...backhanded? It can be taken in a positive way but given light of the situation it comes across as saying that FFXV was out of Nomura's capabilities and now he can go back to that funny KH thing.

Taochan

September 18, 2014 @ 02:26 amOffline

comment graphic

Lnds500
Who else is starting to think that Nomura will quit after KH3?

Well he wanted to keep KH going after KH3 originally...

Really, only time will tell exactly how this entire situation has affected him. I hope he finds happiness in KH again, because I can't even imagine how this entire XV ordeal has been for him to deal with.

Sign

September 18, 2014 @ 02:27 amOffline

comment graphic

This isn't the first time something like this has happened, and all the past directors removed from their projects ended up quitting within a year or two.

Like Taochan said, we can only hope that he may find some solace or relief in returning to KH full-time. It was his baby before XV even existed.

Chaser

September 18, 2014 @ 02:29 amOffline

comment graphic

Directors who left a mainline FF game while it was still in development have usually left the company within a year. - https://twitter.com/APZonerunner/status/512426108109991937

Lonbilly

September 18, 2014 @ 02:31 amOffline

comment graphic

This is incredibly sad. On one hand, it could be good to help speed along projects, but I'm sure Nomura must be crushed, unless he left voluntarily. I actually feel pretty disheartened myself, because if I was booted off a project that was essentially my baby, I'd just be thrown asunder.

I'm also fully convinced this now means that KH3 may be our final Nomura title. Nowhere is this hinted at, but I just feel like after KH3 he's going to take a hiatus/leave all together. I can't blame him if he does.

I imagine this'll be good for KH3, but I'm curious about FFXV. Surely the development will hasten, but I'm more curious about how the story will be affected. Not to mention how XIII had so many staff changes/staff rearranging, that I can't help but fear FFXV may not be up to par with people's expectations even more than it already isn't going to be.

Poor Nomura. Even if it was taking forever for the project, I'm sure it didn't ever actually enter full development until around 2011/whenever it got switched to the PS4.

Chaser
Directors who left a mainline FF game while it was still in development have usually left the company within a year. - https://twitter.com/APZonerunner/status/512426108109991937


Welp, it's my worst fears come true.

robvandam111

September 18, 2014 @ 02:33 amOffline

comment graphic

That's not a good thing for the future of the Kingdom Hearts franchise.

SORA619

September 18, 2014 @ 02:42 amOffline

comment graphic

I will take it as a sign that XV has reached it's final development point. I don't think he would ever leave this project for any reason. Good news for KHIII <3 :D

LightUpTheSky452

September 18, 2014 @ 02:42 amOffline

comment graphic

There's a chance that if he quit Square he could join another company and continue the games there, right? Right?! Or... though I hate to think it, Square could continue it without Nomura?

Ugh. I pray it doesn't come to that! I need KH in my life and I need Nomura to write for it! KH's been a part of my life for so long, that I can't imagine a time without it. I'm like panicking now.

Ruran

September 18, 2014 @ 02:45 amOffline

comment graphic

If there's a silver lining here the article did emphasize that Nomura is working on several other projects, note worthy projects, besides KH3 so perhaps things aren't all that bad for him at Square at the moment. He does like to work on several projects at once and I get dropping one, but depending on what else he's working on (TWEWY 2?

[FONT=Source Sans Pro](゜-゜))[/FONT]

there still might be too much important work to be done. Despite the reputation of directors leaving soon after being booted off FF he may be too tied down for that. At least for a while.

Lonbilly

September 18, 2014 @ 02:47 amOffline

comment graphic

To be fair, I'm not against the idea of Nomura's involvement in KH being reduced/cut back after KH3. (In fact, I think the next series could benefit from some new talent). I do, however, feel like his role with SE may simply be reduced to only the KH series, which isn't bad, but I gotta imagine he doesn't only want to be known for one series/work on one series only.

But perhaps I should look at this in a more positive light. Perhaps he did leave because XV is near completion, and he wanted to be full throttle for KH3.

But probably not.

Ruran
If there's a silver lining here the article did emphasize that Nomura is working on several other projects, note worthy projects, besides KH3 so perhaps things aren't all that bad for him at Square at the moment. He does like to work on several projects at once and I get dropping one, but depending on what else he's working on (TWEWY 2?

[FONT=Source Sans Pro](゜-゜))[/FONT]

there still might be too much important work to be done. Despite the reputation of directors leaving soon after being booted off FF he may be too tied down for that. At least for a while.


TWEWY 2 yes please.

Sign

September 18, 2014 @ 02:48 amOffline

comment graphic

Mystery Osaka console game with online multiplayer please

Lnds500

September 18, 2014 @ 02:49 amOffline

comment graphic

LightUpTheSky452
There's a chance that if he quit Square he could join another company and continue the games there, right? Right?! Or... though I hate to think it, Square could continue it without Nomura?

Ugh. I pray it doesn't come to that! I need KH in my life and I need Nomura to write for it! KH's been a part of my life for so long, that I can't imagine a time without it. I'm like panicking now.


He wouldn't be able to touch KH though. He doesn't own the IP or the characters and he'd need a ton of money to continue the project.

Square would continue it and Nomura would become just another Japanese iOS developer/artist. At best he could be a freelancer for big companies.

All in all, the situation sounds awful and I have a sense that being forced out of a project is a much bigger slap in the face in Japan than in the West. And it was his pet project.

Sign

September 18, 2014 @ 02:51 amOffline

comment graphic

When you consider that he would have been returning to KH full-time after completing XV, it's even worse.

LightUpTheSky452

September 18, 2014 @ 02:54 amOffline

comment graphic

I'm just going to remain hopeful that Nomura will stay with the company (at least for a while), Osaka's working on TWEWY2 secretly and that's the mysterious multiplayer thing, and that Nomura left XV of his own free will. That's the future of SE and no one tell me any differently, please, I beg you. -enters state of denial, which sounds like a good idea right now, until I inevitably get my dreams crushed in a vicious way in the future-

Although, I am kind of curious about what KH would be like from another creator's PoV. Blasphemy, I know, and I'm not even going to think about it anymore. -blissfully goes back to denial land- I really don't want Nomura to lose KH of all things after this, though. Ouch.

rawpower

September 18, 2014 @ 02:58 amOffline

comment graphic

I guess since we don't know what the details are behind this, it's hard to know who to be mad at if we should even be mad or upset at all. Did the suits remove him or did he remove himself? Can't really tell. Not sure why a guy who's been working on a game for like 8 years suddenly leave.

Sdog

September 18, 2014 @ 02:59 amOffline

comment graphic

Chaser
Directors who left a mainline FF game while it was still in development have usually left the company within a year. - https://twitter.com/APZonerunner/status/512426108109991937


Ok now that is frightening... why must you do this to us chaser?

Taochan

September 18, 2014 @ 03:04 amOffline

comment graphic

rawpower
I guess since we don't know what the details are behind this, it's hard to know who to be mad at if we should even be mad or upset at all. Did the suits remove him or did he remove himself? Can't really tell. Not sure why a guy who's been working on a game for like 8 years suddenly leave.

All we can say for certain is that Tabata was only supposed to come on to help Nomura co-direct. Something happened between that point and now that either forced Nomura to leave or made Nomura decide to leave, either of which isn't good.

Everyone is safe to assume that Nomura didn't leave the XV project happily, as he has never given any indication of wanting to do so and this was a big deal for him.

user avatar

Xagzan

September 18, 2014 @ 03:07 amOffline

comment graphic

Jesus, one tweet about what other people have done and you guys are already clearing out Nomura's desk.

Sdog

September 18, 2014 @ 03:10 amOffline

comment graphic

Xagzan
Jesus, one tweet about what other people have done and you guys are already clearing out Nomura's desk.


Not just quite, it is a frightening tweet yes, but what I think has most of us freakin is it seems so sudden without a direct word from nomura.

It would be nice if he were to speak on it for some clarification if it were his choice, though I'm sure he'd have to tiptoe around the wording.

Heartkeeper

September 18, 2014 @ 03:18 amOffline

comment graphic

This good for KHIII and probably for Nomura's health but I'm sad that he put so much work in the game to get removed from the direction in the last part of the development. The trailer is awesome.

Jesus

September 18, 2014 @ 03:29 amOffline

comment graphic

Now I may be off-base here, but I think Square just wasn't going to deal with his "process". From what I can see with the way he handles KH, Nomura likes to go every which way with his ideas, takes his time on projects, and can get lost along the way. Not to say that he isn't great, but if after 8 years you haven't finished the game, they're gonna have to bring someone else to set him straight.

Maybe that didn't sit well with him and he just quit

user avatar

Kingnice92

September 18, 2014 @ 03:45 amOffline

comment graphic

Sounds okay to me i just want to play them

rawpower

September 18, 2014 @ 04:24 amOffline

comment graphic

Taochan
All we can say for certain is that Tabata was only supposed to come on to help Nomura co-direct. Something happened between that point and now that either forced Nomura to leave or made Nomura decide to leave, either of which isn't good.

Everyone is safe to assume that Nomura didn't leave the XV project happily, as he has never given any indication of wanting to do so and this was a big deal for him.


And if he didn't leave happy, that would tend to make me think that the suits up in corporate removed him. Nomura does not seem like the type of guy to just get fed up and leave.

But maybe XV was different. It's been in development hell for 8 years, but is that entirely Nomura's fault or is it partly corporate's fault? From what I understand, the suits played a pretty big role holding this game back. Now suddenly they need it to come out as fast as possible because they made it the next numbered title (and you know they can't ride the Lightning/XIII train forever) and Nomura doesn't want to sacrifice quality for a speedy release. So when he hasn't made enough progress after the E3 2013 trailer, they give him the boot. This is a hypothetical scenario, but it seems like a typical situation.

Or maybe Nomura just didn't want to deal with the corporate bullshit that surrounds a SE's flagship franchise and left on his own. Who knows.

Sign

September 18, 2014 @ 04:30 amOffline

comment graphic

Guard
Now I may be off-base here, but I think Square just wasn't going to deal with his "process". From what I can see with the way he handles KH, Nomura likes to go every which way with his ideas, takes his time on projects, and can get lost along the way. Not to say that he isn't great, but if after 8 years you haven't finished the game, they're gonna have to bring someone else to set him straight.

Maybe that didn't sit well with him and he just quit


It's not like he actually had a fully dedicated team working on the game for the past 8 years. Staff have been constantly being moved to other projects since the game was announced, followed by all the tech issues they had, then moving the entire thing over to new-gen...

Of course someone should have reigned him in and told him he needed to deliver.

I think what I'd like to know is, when exactly did he leave the project? Was it all the way back before Comic Con? Was it just before the Tokyo Game Show?

I feel like if we knew that, it could be easier to make some sense of all this.

user avatar

Gram

September 18, 2014 @ 04:37 amOffline

comment graphic

Well this is quite a shock. Hope this doesn't affect Kh3 in a negative way. (if he was indeed forced to leave the FFV project)

1keyblade

September 18, 2014 @ 04:44 amOffline

comment graphic

This is actually very disheartening considering square wanted to turn FFXV into a mobile game. Nomura fought for this game because he wanted Final Fantasy XV to be a "true Final Fantasy" and the game only looks as good as it is because of him. Hopefully Square does a good job without him, but I have very little faith in them at this point. At least Nomura will be able to see his family and focus on KH3 now that he's in a less stressful situation.

Sign

September 18, 2014 @ 04:47 amOffline

comment graphic

1keyblade
This is actually very disheartening considering square wanted to turn FFXV into a mobile game.


Maybe you're confusing XV with Agito/Type-0? Agito was originally planned to be a mobile game, but XV was always meant to be for consoles.

1keyblade

September 18, 2014 @ 04:57 amOffline

comment graphic

Sign
Maybe you're confusing XV with Agito/Type-0? Agito was originally planned to be a mobile game, but XV was always meant to be for consoles.


Yes XV may have been meant for consoles but square wanted it on mobile. I read this article earlier this year and I've had little faith in square ever since. The way I look at it now, Nomura is almost the only good thing about square.

Tetsuya Nomura Spent 3 Months Convincing Square Enix Not to Move Final Fantasy XV to Smartphones - Play4Real

KingdomKey

September 18, 2014 @ 04:58 amOffline

comment graphic

Nomura could of had the choice of being forced off of FFXV with his job reputation ruined, making him less desirable to hire in other gaming industries, or to step away from it with good graces. Which would suck big time, if that were the case. I really don't like the way the article was written up. It almost implies something had gone down in order for Nomura to leave it.

On the other hand, wasn't it stated years back that Nomura doesn't get to be with his family all that much? It's probably an unlikely scenario. I guess as long as it doesn't affect future KH titles, then I'm okay with him being off the FFXV project. KHIII can be completed that much more quicker, and we'll see other side projects that haven't come to light yet. If Nomura goes on hiatus, I won't freak out over it. The man has been working for years on both of these games, so he deserves a break.

It's still shocking to my system to think about though.

Sign

September 18, 2014 @ 05:21 amOffline

comment graphic

1keyblade
Yes XV may have been meant for consoles but square wanted it on mobile. I read this article earlier this year and I've had little faith in square ever since. The way I look at it now, Nomura is almost the only good thing about square.

Tetsuya Nomura Spent 3 Months Convincing Square Enix Not to Move Final Fantasy XV to Smartphones - Play4Real


P4Gaming is a troll website. It's 100% fake.

An easy way to tell if articles are fake is if they blatantly insult other products like "Nomura" did with Angry Birds in this one.

Sugar Lips
Nomura could of had the choice of being forced off of FFXV with his job reputation ruined, making him less desirable to hire in other gaming industries, or to step away from it with good graces. Which would suck big time, if that were the case. I really don't like the way the article was written up. It almost implies something had gone down in order for Nomura to leave it.


If these matters are ever released publicly, they'd have to be from Nomura, and you know how much he prefers to keep his private life private. He's not going to be slandered and involved in any scandals, and he's still an individual with a name that's known worldwide, so he would have no problem finding work. His name sells; that's why Square Enix has been slapping it on as many projects as possible over the past few years.

Considering the circumstances, it's very difficult to argue that this departure was made voluntarily. Nomura was going to return to KH 100% anyways after the completion of XV, and no matter who you are or what industry you're in, if you've completed work for a project, you have no reason to suddenly abandon your title and position. You just go and do the work that needs to be done. This is common sense.

khaled

September 18, 2014 @ 05:24 amOffline

comment graphic

This is good news for me.

1keyblade

September 18, 2014 @ 05:29 amOffline

comment graphic

Sign
P4Gaming is a troll website. It's 100% fake.

An easy way to tell if articles are fake is if they blatantly insult other products like "Nomura" did with Angry Birds in this one.


Just checked out more of their articles and your right, the article is fake. Still kinda bugs me that Nomura is no longer on the project but im hoping for the best.

Luap

September 18, 2014 @ 05:45 amOffline

comment graphic

1keyblade
Yes XV may have been meant for consoles but square wanted it on mobile. I read this article earlier this year and I've had little faith in square ever since. The way I look at it now, Nomura is almost the only good thing about square.

Tetsuya Nomura Spent 3 Months Convincing Square Enix Not to Move Final Fantasy XV to Smartphones - Play4Real


P4R is a satirical gaming news website; think The Onion, but video games. FFXV wasn't ever in consideration to be on smartphones lol.

Sugar Lips
On the other hand, wasn't it stated years back that Nomura doesn't get to be with his family all that much? It's probably an unlikely scenario. I guess as long as it doesn't affect future KH titles, then I'm okay with him being off the FFXV project. KHIII can be completed that much more quicker, and we'll see other side projects that haven't come to light yet. If Nomura goes on hiatus, I won't freak out over it. The man has been working for years on both of these games, so he deserves a break.


For a long time Nomura kept saying that KH3 would start development once he was done with FFXV. We have some evidence that Nomura had another KH game in mind to make after DDD that wasn't KH3, but was scrapped. Square, or even Disney, could have possibly pressured (or demanded) Nomura to start development on KH3 and that's why that game got canned and DDD's ending changed. He was in charge of Square's biggest game yet. Suddenly, he was in charge of Square's two biggest titles at the same time. That's a lot of responsibility. He has said stuff about work keeping him away from his family and personal life, so it's not too farfetched that he might of came to the conclusion that he had to give one up for his own personal health or sanity.

The article is worded oddly and it's possible he was forced off, but there are lots of of reasons he could of decided to leave.

rokudamia2

September 18, 2014 @ 05:46 amOffline

comment graphic

I'm surprised he didn't leave sooner. I wouldn't surprised if the executives him leave. I assume he was costing them a lot of money. He probably finshed a lot of the game anyway, and I wouldn't be surprised if the higher up's wanted him to get a move on with Kh3.

Sdog

September 18, 2014 @ 06:02 amOffline

comment graphic

I'm sure at this point, while it doesn't completely feel like it, good can come of this for both projects. having a director on each that has a main focus on the title will help the team out greatly, especially for three since they have been working without his full attention for a solid year now.

WhinyAcademic

September 18, 2014 @ 06:31 amOffline

comment graphic

Son of a gun.

Without XV to worry about, more focus on III. XV's planned to be released in March 2015. Maybe we can expect a release for III in either late 2015 or early 2016? 2015 will be the first year without a KH game in seven years if it doesn't come next year, which admittedly is unlikely.

This is promising news. Very promising.

Sign

September 18, 2014 @ 06:36 amOffline

comment graphic

WhinyAcademic
Son of a gun.

Without XV to worry about, more focus on III. XV's planned to be released in March 2015. Maybe we can expect a release for III in either late 2015 or early 2016? 2015 will be the first year without a KH game in seven years if it doesn't come next year, which admittedly is unlikely.

This is promising news. Very promising.


It's Type-0 HD that's scheduled for a March 2015 release, not XV.

Sdog

September 18, 2014 @ 06:36 amOffline

comment graphic

Son of a gun.

Without XV to worry about, more focus on III. XV's planned to be released in March 2015. Maybe we can expect a release for III in either late 2015 or early 2016? 2015 will be the first year without a KH game in seven years if it doesn't come next year, which admittedly is unlikely.

This is promising news. Very promising.



Sorry to break it to ya but FFXV has no plans of release in March, that's Type-0. I'm still bettin on a Fall/Winter 2015 release for XV though.

Lnds500

September 18, 2014 @ 06:38 amOffline

comment graphic

WhinyAcademic
Son of a gun.

Without XV to worry about, more focus on III. XV's planned to be released in March 2015. Maybe we can expect a release for III in either late 2015 or early 2016? 2015 will be the first year without a KH game in seven years if it doesn't come next year, which admittedly is unlikely.

This is promising news. Very promising.


It's horrible news no matter how you look at it and we will be lucky if we get a demo in March, let alone the full game. We won't be seeing the full game for some time.

user avatar

Bobizzle

September 18, 2014 @ 06:39 amOffline

comment graphic

I think people are overreacting on this. Just because Nomura hasn't released a statement yet doesn't mean that he was booted off XV.

Like everyone has said-XV was HIS project, and they aren't gonna just forcibly boot him out. It's possible they may have suggested for him to leave, they maybe could have said "XV is in good hands with Tabata so maybe you should take a load off and just focus on KH3" but I just don't see SE aggressively kicking Nomura off. For what purpose? If the game still had a very long ways to go in development wouldn't that make keeping Nomura on the project especially crucial?

i honestly think this is positive news. I think it means that Nomura feels like XV is in good enough development to where he can count on Tabata to finish it, and therefore he can help speed things along on KH3 and other projects so that they won't be in development purgatory the next 4-5 years. SE and Nomura are aware of how much KH3 is anticipated, it's not a stretch to think that they are really wanting to do their best to satisfy fans of both games.

my opinion: we could be seeing XV by Q2/Q3 2015. And a KH3 release soon after may not really be a stretch now.

ShardofTruth

September 18, 2014 @ 06:42 amOffline

comment graphic

I can't say I'm happy about this. Versus was Nomura's baby, yes there were problems with it (obviously), but stepping down as the director seems to be a pretty harsh step to me.

Especially giving how the only alternative seems to be just more Kingdom Hearts. There will be the point when Nomura becomes fed up with the series if he's only allowed to focus on this one as this happened before with other games and other directors as well.

Bobizzle
my opinion: we could be seeing XV by Q2/Q3 2015. And a KH3 release soon after may not really be a stretch now.

It's still a big stretch, I'm not expecting Kingdom Hearts III in the next three years, the development time of the former titles wasn't that short and they weren't announced this early in development as KHIII.

Lnds500

September 18, 2014 @ 06:46 amOffline

comment graphic

Bobizzle
I think people are overreacting on this. Just because Nomura hasn't released a statement yet doesn't mean that he was booted off XV.

Like everyone has said-XV was HIS project, and they aren't gonna just forcibly boot him out. It's possible they may have suggested for him to leave, they maybe could have said "XV is in good hands with Tabata so maybe you should take a load off and just focus on KH3" but I just don't see SE aggressively kicking Nomura off. For what purpose? If the game still had a very long ways to go in development wouldn't that make keeping Nomura on the project especially crucial?

i honestly think this is positive news. I think it means that Nomura feels like XV is in good enough development to where he can count on Tabata to finish it, and therefore he can help speed things along on KH3 and other projects so that they won't be in development purgatory the next 4-5 years. SE and Nomura are aware of how much KH3 is anticipated, it's not a stretch to think that they are really wanting to do their best to satisfy fans of both games.

my opinion: we could be seeing XV by Q2/Q3 2015. And a KH3 release soon after may not really be a stretch now.



Based on everything we have heard (and insiders are saying that he left for "negative reasons"), he was booted.

Best case scenario: Square needs another money maker fairly quickly so they wanted Nomura to work on KH3. Tabata was already a co-director and he could just complete Nomura's vision and release the game.

Worst case scenario: Square did not want to put up with Nomura's vision of the game any more and decided to boot him entirely. Tabata is gonna work with what they have so far, shape it into a playable, cohesive game and release it. It won't be what Nomura wanted or envisioned, but it will finally be out.

If Nomura was leaving the project on his own accord (which makes no sense, since it might have been his most crucial game ever), he would have released a statement personally explaining his reasoning.

Sign

September 18, 2014 @ 06:47 amOffline

comment graphic

Bobizzle
I think people are overreacting on this. Just because Nomura hasn't released a statement yet doesn't mean that he was booted off XV.

Like everyone has said-XV was HIS project, and they aren't gonna just forcibly boot him out. It's possible they may have suggested for him to leave, they maybe could have said "XV is in good hands with Tabata so maybe you should take a load off and just focus on KH3" but I just don't see SE aggressively kicking Nomura off. For what purpose? If the game still had a very long ways to go in development wouldn't that make keeping Nomura on the project especially crucial?

i honestly think this is positive news. I think it means that Nomura feels like XV is in good enough development to where he can count on Tabata to finish it, and therefore he can help speed things along on KH3 and other projects so that they won't be in development purgatory the next 4-5 years. SE and Nomura are aware of how much KH3 is anticipated, it's not a stretch to think that they are really wanting to do their best to satisfy fans of both games.


With this announcement, he's only going to be credited as the Main Character Designer. If this was merely a case of Nomura being satisfied with the status of the project and is confident in leaving in the hands of Tabata, he would not, under any circumstances, denounce his position as Director.

Sdog

September 18, 2014 @ 06:54 amOffline

comment graphic

Sign
With this announcement, he's only going to be credited as the Main Character Designer.


I really hope that isn't the case, especially after everything he's done for the project. If Square were to do that to him, which would be nothing short of a giant middle finger, I would understand him even bouncing after.

Unless by some weird twist of events he's cool with that...

Lnds500

September 18, 2014 @ 06:59 amOffline

comment graphic

Sdog
I really hope that isn't the case, especially after everything he's done for the project. If Square were to do that to him, which would be nothing short of a giant middle finger, I would understand him even bouncing after.

Unless by some weird twist of events he's cool with that...


from GAF



Have you considered that maybe Nomura didn't want to keep up a facade? If this is a case of Nomura being taken off the project and his final vision being compromised to ship the game, would he want his name on it as director? It takes two hands to clap. When there's internal tension between business and creative, it can be very hard to keep up the pretense.

It is entirely possible that Nomura is forcing this announcement specifically to make it look the way you say it does, because that's the only way he can communicate it to his fans and he doesn't want to lie to people. Note that Nomura hasn't given any interview or statement regarding his removal as director. Previously he would be the first to make comments about anything new regarding the title at media events. I think that's pretty telling.



.................................

Sdog

September 18, 2014 @ 07:10 amOffline

comment graphic

Probably wouldn't have thought of it that way in that way in this hype... Thanks for that

BEASTENDER

September 18, 2014 @ 07:59 amOffline

comment graphic

If the DEMO for FFXV isn't even coming out until March 2015, there is officially Zero chance of KH3 coming out late 2015. But it's fine I suppose. If it looks anything like the new FFXV only KH style, it's worth the wait. Actually, if KH3 started development in late 2012 and had a little something to show at 2013's E3 about 6 or so months later, I think it actually needs all of 2015 and some of 2016 to be all it can be.

rokudamia2

September 18, 2014 @ 08:08 amOffline

comment graphic

I think Nomura will leave SE after KHIII is released. Tabata and Yusue are in the wings and are listed as co-directors. I think they are his successors.

user avatar

kakalakingma

September 18, 2014 @ 08:10 amOffline

comment graphic

Nomura stepping down from Final Fantasy XV as the director to focus on Kingdom Hearts III.


I ain't mad at him!

Lnds500

September 18, 2014 @ 08:17 amOffline

comment graphic

Final Fantasy XV + Type-0 HD incoming next week



Next week's Famitsu is going to have a huge feature on Type-0 HD and XV, including interviews. It's going to be really interesting to see who they interview and what they say. :)



Fingers crossed we will get some info.



JANFEAE
If the DEMO for FFXV isn't even coming out until March 2015, there is officially Zero chance of KH3 coming out late 2015.


There never was.



Actually, if KH3 started development in late 2012 and had a little something to show at 2013's E3 about 6 or so months later



No it didn't. Source?

anniinan

September 18, 2014 @ 08:26 amOffline

comment graphic

I have a bad feeling about this..

If there has been some kind of fallout I hope SE can fix things with Nomura and the future if KH won't be compromised..

Fingers crossed that Nomura left willingly 'cause the development of FFXV is approaching the finish line and the project didn't need Nomuras attention anymore. I hope he left other people just to finish the job, but I have a feeling this is going to be bad

Sephiroth0812

September 18, 2014 @ 08:29 amOffline

comment graphic

On first glance it certainly seems like a weird decision on Square's part to change the director this late in production process (and it's also a novum that they seem to prioritize a KH title over a FF title as FF is clearly the bigger money maker of the two), but considering the other stuff we know as i.e. KH III being announced on E3 last year where Nomura admitted in an interview that it was unveiled too early for his tastes and FF XV being really off the reasonable time-table for development with more than 8 years, maybe the new upper echelons at Square simply chose to give more emphasis to business (and thus money) even if that means cutting corners and impede the creativity and visions of people like Nomura.
As Guard pointed out, sometimes Nomura likes to get carried away and "try out things", and maybe he just did that one time too much for the tastes of the higher ups who likely want FF XV out asap because it's already quite the PR-disaster no matter how you look at it.

I also wouldn't be surprised if Disney figuratively "stepped" into the door with a tapping foot telling Square to "get their shit together".
Disney doesn't care about FF as they have nothing to do with it, but regarding KH they could make some demands regarding it getting more attention or at least no more delays because of other projects.
KH III being unveiled too early for Nomura's tastes could also be because of Disney knocking at Square's door to get movin'.

How common is it for a director to oversee several big projects at once anyways?
I do not in any way blame Nomura himself alone for the severely long development time of FF Versus/XV, as there where many factors playing into it, among them the stupid decision to split up the team several times to help out with other titles like the Lightning-saga (apparently Toriyama and his team weren't able to stem it alone) and several difficulties with the engine.
There is no denying though that due to the mess that is Versus/XV, the KH series has suffered somewhat in one way or another, a situation that either the new boss of Square or Disney (or even both) simply don't want to tolerate anymore.

Another reason I can think of may be that with the advent of the HD Remasters, Square expects a substantial revival of interest in the KH series and wants to put all avaialable resources towards KH III as fast as possible, possibly regarding FF XV as advanced enough that someone different can finish it as well as "freeing" Nomura for other tasks.
Nomura may not share that opinion especially with XV being his "brainchild" mainly, but in the end he's only an employee as well.
I do not know on what terms Nomura and Tabata stand, but if it's reasonably well I can imagine that Tabata will keep Nomura's initial vision in mind when finishing FF XV even if he has to cut some corners to satisfy the upper echelons.

rokudamia2

September 18, 2014 @ 08:38 amOffline

comment graphic

The only other times a director has left a final fantasy game midway through development are XII, and XIV. With XII The director was ill so he had to leave, and the director XIV was kicked out after XIV's inital launch.

Vanitas666

September 18, 2014 @ 08:52 amOffline

comment graphic

I think he left because KH was his firstborn and he need to make doubly sure that everything is perfect and FF XV is probably really close to being finished now.
I'm not worried about KH III at all (at least not because of these news), hopefully FF XV really is as far along in development as it should be though, otherwise that could be a problem.

Chaser

September 18, 2014 @ 09:28 amOffline

comment graphic

From Square Enix Europe:



If that wasn’t enough news, I’ve got a little something else to share with you. Now I know you guys want us at Square Enix to be more open with you and to keep you updated with all the goings on with our games so I’m going to talk to you a little more about Final Fantasy XV since I’m sure you guys are just as excited about it as I am (which is VERY excited).

The development of Final Fantasy XV is coming along really well and as a result Hajime Tabata (the director of the original Final Fantasy Type-0 and Type-0 HD) has taken over from Tetsuya Nomura as the director of Final Fantasy XV.

Now before you start to freak out, let me explain how this is a good thing. There’s no denying that Tetsuya Nomura has been instrumental to the development of Final Fantasy XV and he’s done an incredible job. His main role as director was working on the original concept for the story and universe and also creating the characters. Now that development of Final Fantasy XV has come so far, Nomura’s work is pretty much all in place so instead of having him keep an eye on the more day to day stuff, we thought it’d be a better idea to pass the reigns over to Hajime Tabata and let Nomura move onto other projects and make games that only he could do, you know, like Kingdom Hearts III.


So now we have Hajime Tabata and the rest of his team working as hard as they can on Final Fantasy XV and making sure it’s the best game it can possibly be and we have Tetsuya Nomura and the Kingdom Hearts III team working as hard as they can to make that the best game that can be. It also means that both games will come out much sooner this way. Instead of waiting until Final Fantasy XV comes out before starting on Kingdom Hearts III, Tetsuya Nomura can now properly begin work on Kingdom Hearts III right now and with Tabata in the director’s chair, Final Fantasy XV won’t suffer either.


Hajime Tabata and his team are a bunch of really talented people and Final Fantasy XV is in good hands for the rest of its development but even if you don’t want to believe me, you can find out for yourself on 20th March 2015 when you can play Final Fantasy XV for yourself along with Final Fantasy Type-0 HD.


allenleonardo

September 18, 2014 @ 09:37 amOffline

comment graphic

I feel a little sad about that even if it means that we might get KHIII sooner. :frown:

I just cant see any reason why he should have left on his own will to be able to focus on KH3. Yes Kingdom Hearts is also his baby but it looked like he was really happy to be able to create FF15. Why would you leave one of your biggest game? I mean I would have understood it if this was after 4 or 5 years of producing this game but it really looks like the game may be out 2015/2016 so why not stick with it till the end if you managed to handle all the pressure in these long years? Even more if leaving means that you wont be credited as the director anymore.

So I think that he really had to go thanks to a decision of the company. Maybe they were not happy with him anymore. I mean you just dont strip such a position from a person that you are happy with. Especially if this means that he wont be credited as the director anymore. Being a director for two big games is not that impossible, just let the co-director do the most things for FF15 and let Nomura focus on KH3. I mean I would be so angry if they did that to me. All these years that you put your hard work in it and suddenly they make you leave with means that another one will get all the credit instead of you...

Edit:
Woah somehow that message from Square Enix europe makes me feel even worse =( I dunno why but I got a strange vibe from it..why would they write that both games would come out sooner this way? This makes it sound like the new director will make the process much faster? If it means that Nomura has to much on his plates which hinders the process of FF15 then why did they do it now and not years before?

Sephiroth0812

September 18, 2014 @ 09:48 amOffline

comment graphic

Thanks Chaser, this statement from Square's EU division really makes the issue much more clear.

The way they word it there make it really look like that all major work that Nomura had to do with FF XV is done and the rest is more concerned with day-to-day directing and overseeing which doesn't actually require Nomura to be the one to do it.
This could also explain why Tabata was installed as a co-director to Nomura first.
They planned to "free" Nomura to move full force to KH III and other projects, thus while working together on XV Nomura actually prepared Tabata to take over in full force for the last stretch of the way that XV has to go in development.

If everything wents well, I would be cautiously optimistic that a release of FF XV in the second half of 2015 is still possible.

Chaser

September 18, 2014 @ 09:53 amOffline

comment graphic

allenleonardo


Edit:
Woah somehow that message from Square Enix europe makes me feel even worse =( I dunno why but I got a strange vibe from it..why would they write that both games would come out sooner this way? This makes it sound like the new director will make the process much faster? If it means that Nomura has to much on his plates which hinders the process of FF15 then why did they do it now and not years before?

It isn't suppose to mean that the new director will develop the game faster. It's meant to mean that KH3 won't suffer from XV's development and that both games can come out in a good timely fashion without Nomura torn between the two projects, thus his work isn't delayed on one game while he works on the other.

allenleonardo

September 18, 2014 @ 10:13 amOffline

comment graphic

Chaser
It isn't suppose to mean that the new director will develop the game faster. It's meant to mean that KH3 won't suffer from XV's development and that both games can come out in a good timely fashion without Nomura torn between the two projects, thus his work isn't delayed on one game while he works on the other.


Hm you are right but still I find it a little strange. Why do it now and not all these years ago? I know that they only revealed KH3 last year but he must have still worked on KH a little in all those years. And yet all this time he was still the director even though it must have been hard all these years. Now when it looks like FF15 is near or in the final stage he has to leave the position which means that he cant take the credit as a director..Why not just let the co-director oversee the project while he takes is main focus to KH3? Why was there a need to completely remove him from his position?

Maybe its really not because their are unhappy with him and only because they wanted him to focus on something new. But for me its still unfair to take away is position. And thats probably why I read more into it than thats there and maybe they always do it like that in Japan (or SE) but I still feel that he is not that happy about that. =/ At least I would be totally sad and angry about it.

LedxirnSimon

September 18, 2014 @ 10:26 amOffline

comment graphic

Ah, I don't even care about what's going to happen with both XV and KH3, since these are Nomura's babies after all.

Tabata just steps in the developing scene as a co-director to set nomura 'free' from focusing on XV while Nomura still have his marks on it, to focus on his dear children that is Kingdom hearts and possibly The world ends with you. :P

Directing two games or more all at once can halt the development cycles of each game. :/

Bobjam

September 18, 2014 @ 10:30 amOffline

comment graphic

allenleonardo
Hm you are right but still I find it a little strange. Why do it now and not all these years ago? I know that they only revealed KH3 last year but he must have still worked on KH a little in all those years. And yet all this time he was still the director even though it must have been hard all these years. Now when it looks like FF15 is near or in the final stage he has to leave the position which means that he cant take the credit as a director..Why not just let the co-director oversee the project while he takes is main focus to KH3? Why was there a need to completely remove him from his position?

Maybe its really not because their are unhappy with him and only because they wanted him to focus on something new. But for me its still unfair to take away is position. And thats probably why I read more into it than thats there and maybe they always do it like that in Japan (or SE) but I still feel that he is not that happy about that. =/ At least I would be totally sad and angry about it.


FFXV was not in a position 'years ago' for Nomura to start committing himself to other projects. He has actually been tied down with XV up till now. That's why we have not heard or seen anything substantially new from KH3 since last October. The EU blog is very very good news for both games.

Launchpad

September 18, 2014 @ 10:41 amOffline

comment graphic

Honestly, it's too bad that he's off XV, but it only makes sense. He hasn't been delivering quality in a timely fashion. It's business. This is only for the best.

Sdog

September 18, 2014 @ 11:27 amOffline

comment graphic

After that EU statement I'm able to stomach this a lot better. This seems like something that could've been planned a while back where once Nomura felt he was done he could hand it off to go to his other projects. And since the demo is coming out in March, I'm positive XV will be released in 2015.

Bobjam

September 18, 2014 @ 11:55 amOffline

comment graphic

Nomura is still getting, original character design, writing, story concept and scenario credits for XV so it's not like that side of things is much of an issue, or at least shouldn't be. He will probably still get a co-director credit as well maybe despite the change?

limit

September 18, 2014 @ 12:40 pmOffline

comment graphic

I honestly have no idea how to feel about this. I mean, I guess the fundamentals would have been completed (story, etc.) but I can't get this deep fear out of my stomach that the game isn't going to live up to expectations anymore.

On the other hand, now we get Nomura fully working on KH3 and he's not overwhelmed anymore. I the issue of whether he left voluntarily/on good terms has been brought up, and it just feels even worse knowing there could've easily been a possibility that he was forced out.

KH3 and FFXV are both my most anticipated titles of all time, so I'm so damn torn now.

Jesus

September 18, 2014 @ 12:49 pmOffline

comment graphic

Chaser
From Square Enix Europe:


I really hope everything is fine and Nomura and Square are still in each other's good graces, and after reading this that seems slightly more possible.

Now what I want to know is if this is true, whether or not Nomura's name will be under "Director" after FF XV credits role, even if he did leave early. It hardly seems fair not to put his name up considering he did most of the work

Sephiroth0812

September 18, 2014 @ 01:31 pmOffline

comment graphic

Guard
I really hope everything is fine and Nomura and Square are still in each other's good graces, and after reading this that seems slightly more possible.

Now what I want to know is if this is true, whether or not Nomura's name will be under "Director" after FF XV credits role, even if he did leave early. It hardly seems fair not to put his name up considering he did most of the work


If not, he will definitely still be credited under "Character designer", "Main concept & story" as well as "Scenario".

Beside that though, I wouldn't consider Nomura's leave "early" as the statements of SE EU clearly state that most if not all of his own work for the game is already done.

FacetiousDreamer

September 18, 2014 @ 01:31 pmOffline

comment graphic

If we don't hear anything from Nomura himself about this matter any time soon it means they forced him to leave and keep the mouth shut about it. And this might be very bad not just for FFXV but for KHIII as well. I've very mixed feelings about this. Officials would say anything to defend the product, I don't trust them. Only Nomura can clear things up and I hope he'll do it.

user avatar

Gram

September 18, 2014 @ 02:56 pmOffline

comment graphic

Sephiroth0812

The way they word it there make it really look like that all major work that Nomura had to do with FF XV is done and the rest is more concerned with day-to-day directing and overseeing which doesn't actually require Nomura to be the one to do it.
This could also explain why Tabata was installed as a co-director to Nomura first.
They planned to "free" Nomura to move full force to KH III and other projects, thus while working together on XV Nomura actually prepared Tabata to take over in full force for the last stretch of the way that XV has to go in

That's what I got out of it as well. He's done all the important stuff he was going to so they just switch directors to wrap it up.

FudgemintGuardian

September 18, 2014 @ 03:10 pmOffline

comment graphic

No idea where I heard it, but I remember a year or so back something saying that when XV is far enough in development, Nomura will leave it and focus solely on KHIII. So this news doesn't surprise me, but things certainly felt...off. But the thing from Square Enix Europe clears things up, and yeah, Nomura did all he was going to do so there's no reason for him to hang around XV anymore.

Magnus

September 18, 2014 @ 03:27 pmOffline

comment graphic

It's entirely possible that Kingdom Hearts III is his very last commitment for the company and that he's going to leave when it's done. In a way, it also makes sense to end things on that note. It will be the last game in the original series saga. He will also have played a great role in the Final Fantasy series. I think he's ready to move on, the way Uematsu was.

Most people seem to be happy with this decision as well. As someone on NeoGAF pointed out, Tabata and Yoshi-P have the most respect among fans now because they have a reputation of getting things done and doing a good job.

It also seems that people have already forgotten that this game used to be co-directed by Kitase, too.

axel95

September 18, 2014 @ 04:49 pmOffline

comment graphic

I think this is a great business move. If Nomura willingly left FFXV, the game must be in good enough shape that Nomura was comfortable leaving. But if he was forced out FFXV may be in worse shape than we have been led to believe. Either way, it means both XV and KH3 will be released sooner, which is a good thing for Square.

Sign

September 18, 2014 @ 05:16 pmOffline

comment graphic

axel95
I think this is a great business move. If Nomura willingly left FFXV, the game must be in good enough shape that Nomura was comfortable leaving. But if he was forced out FFXV may be in worse shape than we have been led to believe. Either way, it means both XV and KH3 will be released sooner, which is a good thing for Square.


Directors don't leave a project when it's not even completed yet. If he was comfortable with its current state and decided to let Tabata handle the rest, they'd just... do it. There would be no fuss or sugar-coated PR about him leaving the project and being replaced. He would still retain his position, title, influence, etc., but would no longer have the bulk of the responsibility on his shoulders.

Bobjam

September 18, 2014 @ 05:24 pmOffline

comment graphic

Sign
Directors don't leave a project when it's not even completed yet. If he was comfortable with its current state and decided to let Tabata handle the rest, they'd just... do it. There would be no fuss or sugar-coated PR about him leaving the project and being replaced. He would still retain his position, title, influence, etc., but would no longer have the bulk of the responsibility on his shoulders.


Maybe for them, this is a positive PR move i.e. they are letting people know that things are going well and in fact Nomura is now completely dedicated to KH3 with no distractions. I don't think it has to implicate anything necessarily negative. Unless Dan Seta is now adopting the BS PR tactic, I do think this is just a positive thing that SE wanted people to know about after a year and 3 months of no news from FFXV which they know is so god damn highly anticipated by so many (even non-FF fans it seems as well) I think we should wait for any interviews that come out of TGS (famitsu etc.) until solid conclusions are made about this. There is bound to be more about this demo situation and what it actually is.

Oracle Spockanort

September 18, 2014 @ 05:25 pmOffline

comment graphic

Sign
Directors don't leave a project when it's not even completed yet. If he was comfortable with its current state and decided to let Tabata handle the rest, they'd just... do it. There would be no fuss or sugar-coated PR about him leaving the project and being replaced. He would still retain his position, title, influence, etc., but would no longer have the bulk of the responsibility on his shoulders.


And not only that, Nomura himself would be talking about it if it really was his personal decision. He'd be doing interviews on his own, interviews with Tabata, and showing his trust of Tabata and what will be accomplished in the future. Hell, Tabata hasn't even said anything yet.

Of course, TGS is still young and but since they planned to do this announcement the opening day of TGS, they would have also had statements from Nomura and Tabata ready if this was as clean of a break as they want fans to think it is.

user avatar

Bobizzle

September 18, 2014 @ 06:47 pmOffline

comment graphic

If SE Europe is saying that in Chaser's post then odds are Nomura's split from XV is more applicable than people may think. Like I said just because Nomura hasn't said anything himself yet is hardly a clear indicator that he was forced out. He may just not be ready to make an official announcement yet, or he's busy. Nothing is certain one way or the other and until it is everything is just speculation at this point.

but here's something to consider: if Nomura was unfairly forced out, wouldn't he just leave Square altogether and abandon kH3, especially with XV being "his baby"? Nomura doesn't have to stay for KH3. He could easily walk altogether and tell SE to GTH and they'd just put someone else on the director's seat for KH3.

either way even if it's bad for Nomura it's unfortunate but it does also mean that both games will move faster in development evidently. I'd be willing to bet money that we see XV release by summer or fall next year and KH3 will release by Spring/summer 2016 at the latest now. Which I won't lie that would be awesome since everyone agreed that we wouldn't see KH3 until likely 2017.

user avatar

Deleted member 34215

September 18, 2014 @ 07:50 pmOffline

comment graphic

Dunno what to think about this news. Did he willingly leave? Did they put Tabata alongside him for a lot of time so that one day Nomura could go off to work on KH3 and Tabata would continue the work on FFXV leading to the release? Did S-E just kicked Nomura out because the development was taking too long?

I'm reading so much hate towards Nomura on other boards around the internet, like he's the worst thing that could happen to S-E.
I feel like people don't know anything about how XV's development worked, caring only about the huge delay, then they see this piece of news and go crazy on Nomura because he obviously was the bad guy and now all it's better.

Oracle Spockanort

September 18, 2014 @ 07:57 pmOffline

comment graphic

Bobizzle
If SE Europe is saying that in Chaser's post then odds are Nomura's split from XV is more applicable than people may think.


I don't understand what about SE Europe proves these statements are the honest true? They are still a branch controlled by SE Japan like any other part of Square Enix, and would be told what and what not to say in these PR statements.



Like I said just because Nomura hasn't said anything himself yet is hardly a clear indicator that he was forced out. He may just not be ready to make an official announcement yet, or he's busy. Nothing is certain one way or the other and until it is everything is just speculation at this point.



It doesn't even take that long to say something, though. This decision wasn't made yesterday. This would have been something done fairly recently, yes, but certainly far back enough that Nomura would have had the time to prepare a few words.

And why wouldn't he be ready to say something if this was something he chose to do and it was likely decided awhile ago? Nomura is a private man, but if he really was agreeable to this, why WOULDN'T there be interviews and obvious support on his side to reassure people?

Nomura is certainly a busy man, but he is also the same man who makes time to watch a movie or two a day and bums his time away in the merchandise department to get stuff with his cat's face on it. He's not so busy that he, as the former director of a flagship title, wouldn't be able to fulfill the duty of addressing his departure from a project he has toiled away on & that people have been waiting eight years for.

There is just no way you can reason that away.



but here's something to consider: if Nomura was unfairly forced out, wouldn't he just leave Square altogether and abandon kH3, especially with XV being "his baby"? Nomura doesn't have to stay for KH3. He could easily walk altogether and tell SE to GTH and they'd just put someone else on the director's seat for KH3.



Because Kingdom Hearts is also his baby. He was the one who spent a year alone building the concept and story, convincing people SE and Disney to let him make the game, the one who creates the scenarios for each game, the one with the ideas. He's been working on this series for 12 years. He's not leaving this game when they are at the finish line of the saga.

user avatar

Bobizzle

September 18, 2014 @ 08:25 pmOffline

comment graphic

Master Spockanort
I don't understand what about SE Europe proves these statements are the honest true? They are still a branch controlled by SE Japan like any other part of Square Enix, and would be told what and what not to say in these PR statements.


Fair point, but at the same time it's not like SE Europe would be completely forbidden from sharing some opinions or insight, as long as they didn't completely take Nomura's side and trashed the Japan division for the move. I feel that if they really though Nomura was forced out or if they knew he was, they could have just said "Square felt that it was in the company's best interests to leave XV in Tabata's hands while Nomura moves on to other projects". The wouldn't have had to talk so positively about it. I could be wrong though.



It doesn't even take that long to say something, though. This decision wasn't made yesterday. This would have been something done fairly recently, yes, but certainly far back enough that Nomura would have had the time to prepare a few words.

And why wouldn't he be ready to say something if this was something he chose to do and it was likely decided awhile ago? Nomura is a private man, but if he really was agreeable to this, why WOULDN'T there be interviews and obvious support on his side to reassure people?

Nomura is certainly a busy man, but he is also the same man who makes time to watch a movie or two a day and bums his time away in the merchandise department to get stuff with his cat's face on it. He's not so busy that he, as the former director of a flagship title, wouldn't be able to fulfill the duty of addressing his departure from a project he has toiled away on & that people have been waiting eight years for.

There is just no way you can reason that away.



You're right that can't be reasoned away, those are valid assumptions. But my point was that no one will ever know what went on behind closed doors unless they were behind those doors, so for those who weren't it will always be speculation. Odds are you and sign are right, but it's not definite I think.



Because Kingdom Hearts is also his baby. He was the one who spent a year alone building the concept and story, convincing people SE and Disney to let him make the game, the one who creates the scenarios for each game, the one with the ideas. He's been working on this series for 12 years. He's not leaving this game when they are at the finish line of the saga.



You may be right but I just feel like if a company had exiled me from a game I was working on for so many years that was entirely my idea, then I would easily storm out and say "fine then I'll take my expertise elsewhere, good luck with XV and Kh3.

that may sound spiteful, but Nomura would have a right to be IMO.

rokudamia2

September 18, 2014 @ 08:25 pmOffline

comment graphic

Yeah I don't buy what Square Enix Europe is saying. It (and Square Enix Japan's statement) just scream damage control to me. To me it seems the higher ups at SE were getting impatient with how things we're going and moved him to KH3. Of course I could be totally wrong.

user avatar

Deleted member 34215

September 18, 2014 @ 08:26 pmOffline

comment graphic

Master Spockanort

Because Kingdom Hearts is also his baby. He was the one who spent a year alone building the concept and story, convincing people SE and Disney to let him make the game, the one who creates the scenarios for each game, the one with the ideas. He's been working on this series for 12 years. He's not leaving this game when they are at the finish line of the saga.


Not to mention that by his words KH3 is just the ending of the Xehanort's Saga. He obviously wants to make more KH games.
Maybe he shouldn't have taken the XV job. Dunno if he asked for it or was forced into working on a FF game, but maybe it was too much for him? I'm a bit concerned. All these years on a project so troubled must have been a bit of a pain.

Gexus

September 18, 2014 @ 08:48 pmOffline

comment graphic

Everything about this is just too fishy. Final Fantasy XV has been Nomura's baby. Heck, he even thought of Noctis (and Sora) as his own son. With that said, he couldn't just quietly abandon the project because he got busy with other projects "more suitable for him".

This is such utter PR bullshit, when it's quite clear that SE didn't agree with Nomura's decisions, which might've delayed the game somewhat, sure, but it's still not right.

Now the FF15 we will be getting just won't be the same game we were told to expect. It's still early to tell how the final game will be, but it just feels wrong to not give Nomura his deserved credits for this game. It's his after all.

Magnus

September 18, 2014 @ 08:48 pmOffline

comment graphic

I don't blame them though. Nomura is a talented illustrator, but he is not a talented project manager. He obviously didn't do a good job with the XV project. Just to be clear, I'm not talking about his contributions to the actual game, but his ability to be in charge of and oversee the entire project. It was too big of a responsibility for him to handle, which is why he originally had Kitase to help him out and then Tabata. He continued to take on other commitments after the game had originally been announced as Versus XIII. And now he was also going to direct KH3. Working on both projects at the same time was doomed to fail. KH is a bigger priority to him than FF, yet FF is the company's main priority now, not KH.

I also think that Nomura is the kind of person who gets carried away too easily. That he's a bit of a dreamer. His ambitions for XV seemed unrealistically big and he was probably never satisfied with the prototypes they worked on. Everything had to get bigger and better and if they didn't have enough people ready to work on the game it wasn't worth working on. Just speculation of course, but I do think there's some truth to it. Tabata seems to be more business oriented. He is willing to work hard to put out a game on time, even if it means something will be sacrificed. You can't work on a project forever.

Anyway, I can definitely see Nomura leaving the company on friendly terms after KH3.

Sign

September 18, 2014 @ 08:49 pmOffline

comment graphic

rokudamia2
Yeah I don't buy what Square Enix Europe is saying. It (and Square Enix Japan's statement) just scream damage control to me. To me it seems the higher ups at SE were getting impatient with how seems we're going and moved him to KH3. Of course I could be totally wrong.


Same. To be honest, I don't understand why SEEU bothered saying anything at all. It's even clearer in their statement how much fluff they threw in to try to sugar-coat the situation.

They can mention KH3 as many times as they want. It's not going to make a difference, especially considering they're at the point in development when Nomura isn't very involved. KH3 isn't going to come any faster whether he switched focus or not.

king_mickey rule

September 18, 2014 @ 08:56 pmOffline

comment graphic

I can understand why they did this but yeah, couldn't have been fun for Nomura all after so many years of dedication (obviously, this isn't his choice to begin with). Let's hope it turns out for the best.

Ballad of Caius

September 18, 2014 @ 09:04 pmOffline

comment graphic

This is honestly shocking. This took me by surprise. I wasn't expecting this. Damn. I'm literally writing my reactions to this announcement. I was happy with SEEU's statement, but as others have noted, it's PR damage control bull. I'm back to being honestly shocked and surprised. And as others have stated, there is something fishy behind this decision. It could be that Nomura got too ambitious with the project and the management was giving him limitations and he felt repressed, or the management wanted the game as soon as possible and he still felt repressed. I wanted to post an optimistic scenario, but I can't... I wanted to believe that he left in order to focus on other projects, mainly Kingdom Hearts III. I was even thinking that, possibly, SE was getting the people behind TWEWY ready for another full entry. But with this piece of news, I think the man will leave and will forever leave the fans with whatever he wanted to do with Birth by Sleep Volume 2 and a saga after Xehanort...

Magnus

September 18, 2014 @ 09:14 pmOffline

comment graphic

And I think his ambition is a problem. He sees no limits, even though they exist. I'm sure he could have worked on this game for 10 more years before he would be satisfied. As a perfectionist myself, I can relate to that, but I also admit it's a problem because it's easy to get so lost in your ambitions that you get nothing done, because it wouldn't be perfect.

Also, I don't buy that this is going to have any impact on the game. Nomura is still responsible for its content. Just not the framework.

user avatar

Bobizzle

September 18, 2014 @ 09:16 pmOffline

comment graphic

[QUOTE="Sign, post: 6217200, member: 89972"]Same. To be honest, I don't understand why SEEU bothered saying anything at all. It's even clearer in their statement how much fluff they threw in to try to sugar-coat the situation.

They can mention KH3 as many times as they want. It's not going to make a difference, especially considering they're at the point in development when Nomura isn't very involved. KH3 isn't going to come any faster whether he switched focus or not.[/QUOTE]

Nomura has been saying that he couldn't put KH3 in full force until he was done working on XV though. If he's no longer working on it and is focusing solely on KH3 with his team then I think it's only logical to say that KH3 will release sooner than anticipated. I'm not talking early next year or whatever, but early 2016 certainly isn't out of the question. November or December of next year may not even be impossible.


I think Nomura's whole goal was that he would put his undivided attention into XV, so that he could release it probably around May or so while the Osaka team continued to do preliminary work on KH3 with Nomura giving some direction every once in awhile. And when everything was done with XV, by next February or March or so, THEN he planned on giving his undivided attention to KH3, which is why late 2016/early 2017 was the projected release date for it. But if he's Giving 100% focus into the game now, then the Osaka team will move from preliminary development into full development earlier than expected. And preliminary development was supposedly in effect for about at least 5-6 months before KH3 was announced, so it's not like it was literally started from scratch right when it was announced.

Oracle Spockanort

September 18, 2014 @ 09:17 pmOffline

comment graphic

Gigi
Not to mention that by his words KH3 is just the ending of the Xehanort's Saga. He obviously wants to make more KH games.
Maybe he shouldn't have taken the XV job. Dunno if he asked for it or was forced into working on a FF game, but maybe it was too much for him? I'm a bit concerned. All these years on a project so troubled must have been a bit of a pain.


Well, Versus XIII was never intended to be a mainline title which was supposed to allow Nomura the freedom to make whatever he pleased as long as it was good and didn't cost much. It was when they took staff away from the project then bumped it from side game to mainline then to PS4 that I think the urgency and pressure came about.

Ballad of Caius

September 18, 2014 @ 09:22 pmOffline

comment graphic

Master Spockanort
Well, Versus XIII was never intended to be a mainline title which was supposed to allow Nomura the freedom to make whatever he pleased as long as it was good and didn't cost much. It was when they took staff away from the project then bumped it from side game to mainline then to PS4 that I think the urgency and pressure came about.

I think this was Fabula Nova Crystalis idea: have three directors make an unique game each with the same lore (correct me if I'm wrong). And yes: those aggressive shifts must have hit Versus hard.

user avatar

Bobizzle

September 18, 2014 @ 09:29 pmOffline

comment graphic

Master Spockanort
Well, Versus XIII was never intended to be a mainline title which was supposed to allow Nomura the freedom to make whatever he pleased as long as it was good and didn't cost much. It was when they took staff away from the project then bumped it from side game to mainline then to PS4 that I think the urgency and pressure came about.


You probably just hit the nail on the head. Once the game became Final Fantasy 15, and not versus 13, square's attitude towards the game likely changed completely. Before it was Nomura's pet project-a side game that he was given complete creative freedom over because it didn't organically affect the mainstream FF games.

but now that it is a main installment, it's easy to see why SE would raise their expectations because Final Fantasy is their cash cow, and no doubt they will want it released sooner rather than later. I can understand Nomura's frustration in that regard, but at the same time he has to understand why SE would want to up the ante on XV. And I'm sure Nomura is a smart enough businessman to understand that. I'm sure he never anticipated his baby transforming into a mainline FF game, and really even if he was told to move on he should be proud that Square thought highly enough of his game to turn it into a main game instead of starting one from scratch. Of course that could have just been pure laziness on their part.

Ballad of Caius

September 18, 2014 @ 09:35 pmOffline

comment graphic

It must not have been easy to be on Mr. Nomura's position for these past years. He was given a project where he could be "young, wild and free" in terms of creativity, but then is repressed by the constant shift of staff towards other projects. Then more repression comes when he has to balance his work as Kingdom Hearts' Director and the fact that his side-project was no relabeled as a new entry to the Final Fantasy franchise flagship main series. That possible shortage of staff suddenly reverted, but at the cost of more pressure because it's a main entry and the management want it released ASAP and creativity was given less priority.

I think Mr. Nomura feels repressed and saddened that, after all these years of sacrificing time and effort, he now has to leave behind his other baby and focus on his other son. I think KH3 will be filled with Nomura's sentiment and ideas he might have not entirely implemented on XV.

Sign

September 18, 2014 @ 09:46 pmOffline

comment graphic

Bobizzle
Nomura has been saying that he couldn't put KH3 in full force until he was done working on XV though. If he's no longer working on it and is focusing solely on KH3 with his team then I think it's only logical to say that KH3 will release sooner than anticipated. I'm not talking early next year or whatever, but early 2016 certainly isn't out of the question. November or December of next year may not even be impossible.


My point being that Nomura isn't the one creating assets for the game, nor is he programming, debugging, etc. He oversees the operation, but the bulk of the project that is currently being worked on is all done by modelers, texture artists, designers, and not the director.



I think Nomura's whole goal was that he would put his undivided attention into XV, so that he could release it probably around May or so while the Osaka team continued to do preliminary work on KH3 with Nomura giving some direction every once in awhile. And when everything was done with XV, by next February or March or so, THEN he planned on giving his undivided attention to KH3, which is why late 2016/early 2017 was the projected release date for it. But if he's Giving 100% focus into the game now, then the Osaka team will move from preliminary development into full development earlier than expected. And preliminary development was supposedly in effect for about at least 5-6 months before KH3 was announced, so it's not like it was literally started from scratch right when it was announced.



It's been over a year. I think it's safe to say they're already in full development, and have been for quite some time.

FudgemintGuardian

September 18, 2014 @ 09:49 pmOffline

comment graphic

I'm not sure how to feel about this anymore. Nomura is a rather ambitious dawdler. He has a huge imagination and passion for his work but wastes so much time and gets carried away easily (I can relate.)
And like Ballad mentioned, since XV, back when it was Verses XIII, was originally a project were Nomura had the freedom to make what he pleased.
With it changed to XV, the hit of limitations a lots of pressure may have finally been to much.

Still weird we haven't been given a reason. I'll take pretty much anything as long as it's true.

user avatar

Bobizzle

September 18, 2014 @ 09:51 pmOffline

comment graphic

Ballad of Caius
It must not have been easy to be on Mr. Nomura's position for these past years. He was given a project where he could be "young, wild and free" in terms of creativity, but then is repressed by the constant shift of staff towards other projects. Then more repression comes when he has to balance his work as Kingdom Hearts' Director and the fact that his side-project was no relabeled as a new entry to the Final Fantasy franchise flagship main series. That possible shortage of staff suddenly reverted, but at the cost of more pressure because it's a main entry and the management want it released ASAP and creativity was given less priority.

I think Mr. Nomura feels repressed and saddened that, after all these years of sacrificing time and effort, he now has to leave behind his other baby and focus on his other son. I think KH3 will be filled with Nomura's sentiment and ideas he might have not entirely implemented on XV.


Precisely. Once the game became XV, I think there were just circumstances that came up that Nomura just couldn't control. It's sad, but Nomura knows it's all a business and FF is Square's moneymaker. The main one anyway. Once his baby was chosen to become a flagship game, it's easy to see why he lost complete creative control.

So all in all Nomura probably was booted off, but not in a "you're a lousy director so you're being replaced!" Kind of way-but probably rather in a "we understand you have a certain vision for the game and we respect it, but with this being a main game we can't necessarily afford to go that route" kind of way. In other words I'm sure there is no disrespect placed on Nomura, and hopefully he didn't take it that way. As I said in my previous post, Square obviously loved Nomura's vision enough to make it into a mainstream FF game. So I'm sure they will give him the proper credit when everything is said and done.

gamerobber7

September 18, 2014 @ 09:58 pmOffline

comment graphic

Wow this was unexpected news but hopefully this means only good things for the KH series.

Chaser

September 18, 2014 @ 10:08 pmOffline

comment graphic

rokudamia2
Yeah I don't buy what Square Enix Europe is saying. It (and Square Enix Japan's statement) just scream damage control to me. To me it seems the higher ups at SE were getting impatient with how things we're going and moved him to KH3. Of course I could be totally wrong.


Re:Magnus
I don't blame them though. Nomura is a talented illustrator, but he is not a talented project manager. He obviously didn't do a good job with the XV project. Just to be clear, I'm not talking about his contributions to the actual game, but his ability to be in charge of and oversee the entire project. It was too big of a responsibility for him to handle, which is why he originally had Kitase to help him out and then Tabata. He continued to take on other commitments after the game had originally been announced as Versus XIII. And now he was also going to direct KH3. Working on both projects at the same time was doomed to fail. KH is a bigger priority to him than FF, yet FF is the company's main priority now, not KH.

I also think that Nomura is the kind of person who gets carried away too easily. That he's a bit of a dreamer. His ambitions for XV seemed unrealistically big and he was probably never satisfied with the prototypes they worked on. Everything had to get bigger and better and if they didn't have enough people ready to work on the game it wasn't worth working on. Just speculation of course, but I do think there's some truth to it. Tabata seems to be more business oriented. He is willing to work hard to put out a game on time, even if it means something will be sacrificed. You can't work on a project forever.

Anyway, I can definitely see Nomura leaving the company on friendly terms after KH3.

Magnus

September 18, 2014 @ 10:11 pmOffline

comment graphic

Here's a recap of the timeline:

Viewing Single Post - NeoGAF

Kind of puts things into perspective.

user avatar

Bobizzle

September 18, 2014 @ 10:14 pmOffline

comment graphic

Sign
My point being that Nomura isn't the one creating assets for the game, nor is he programming, debugging, etc. He oversees the operation, but the bulk of the project that is currently being worked on is all done by modelers, texture artists, designers, and not the director.



It's been over a year. I think it's safe to say they're already in full development, and have been for quite some time.


Thats true, but since he's the director he can decide when they work and how much work they put it on a daily basis. It's possible that since most of his focus was on XV, he gave the Osaka staff a lot of leeway when working on KH3 and probably didn't care if they procrastinated some. In other words it wouldn't be surprising if they were in studio working only two or three days out of the week instead of five or six, and the hours may not have been that long. Plus there's the possibility that they were helping the other teams with some XV stuff as well.

But now that Nomura is focusing almost exclusively on KH3, it's fair to assume that he's making the Osaka team go full throttle now-9/10 hour workdays, almost every day of the week with a more aggresive schedule to meet certain deadlines. Before they probably didn't have to meet certain deadlines or if they did they were probably easy deadlines. That's mainly what I meant when I said "preliminary" development.

Oracle Spockanort

September 18, 2014 @ 10:28 pmOffline

comment graphic

Bobizzle
Thats true, but since he's the director he can decide when they work and how much work they put it on a daily basis. It's possible that since most of his focus was on XV, he gave the Osaka staff a lot of leeway when working on KH3 and probably didn't care if they procrastinated some. In other words it wouldn't be surprising if they were in studio working only two or three days out of the week instead of five or six, and the hours may not have been that long. Plus there's the possibility that they were helping the other teams with some XV stuff as well.

But now that Nomura is focusing almost exclusively on KH3, it's fair to assume that he's making the Osaka team go full throttle now-9/10 hour workdays, almost every day of the week with a more aggresive schedule to meet certain deadlines. Before they probably didn't have to meet certain deadlines or if they did they were probably easy deadlines. That's mainly what I meant when I said "preliminary" development.


No. Osaka has always been dedicated to working on Kingdom Hearts games since Re:CoM and Birth By Sleep. They haven't touched FFXV at all, especially considering they have been working on Kh3D, 1.5, 2.5, and now a mysterious online game (that could just be KH3 MP but who knows), not to mention KH3 itself.

With 1stPD being full of staff, they wouldn't need to take from Osaka. They'd probably just hire people or outsource as they always have. (And if I'm not mistaken, they actually have outsourced for parts of FFXV)

I don't really think Nomura is that kind of director. He is more about quality and pushing limits than meeting deadlines. He isn't an aggressive guy by nature. Also that is why Tai Yasue is Co-Director. He is the one who oversees the day-to-day operations of the development team, and he'd have been the one making sure deadlines were being met and that they were hitting important landmarks with the game's development.

Elysium

September 18, 2014 @ 10:30 pmOffline

comment graphic

This news makes me happy (selfishly), since KH3 can finally progress--and the sooner, the better. Of course, I hope Nomura isn't upset; hopefully, he wasn't forced off, which would make anyone harbor some resentment.

user avatar

notnow123487

September 18, 2014 @ 10:55 pmOffline

comment graphic

Can we stop using repressed? Oppressed is the word you're looking for in this scenario lol.

Oracle Spockanort

September 18, 2014 @ 11:00 pmOffline

comment graphic

notnow123487
Can we stop using repressed? Oppressed is the word you're looking for in this scenario lol.


Who are you addressing?

user avatar

Bobizzle

September 18, 2014 @ 11:11 pmOffline

comment graphic

Master Spockanort
No. Osaka has always been dedicated to working on Kingdom Hearts games since Re:CoM and Birth By Sleep. They haven't touched FFXV at all, especially considering they have been working on Kh3D, 1.5, 2.5, and now a mysterious online game (that could just be KH3 MP but who knows), not to mention KH3 itself.

With 1stPD being full of staff, they wouldn't need to take from Osaka. They'd probably just hire people or outsource as they always have. (And if I'm not mistaken, they actually have outsourced for parts of FFXV)

I don't really think Nomura is that kind of director. He is more about quality and pushing limits than meeting deadlines. He isn't an aggressive guy by nature. Also that is why Tai Yasue is Co-Director. He is the one who oversees the day-to-day operations of the development team, and he'd have been the one making sure deadlines were being met and that they were hitting important landmarks with the game's development.


I did forget about Yasue co-directing. That probably does make my post at least somewhat invalid.

All of this is a wait and see approach, because I think logic still says that if Nomura is shifting his focus to KH3 then the development will naturally speed up. But as you said, since he's known to take his time it really may not make a difference.

I do think it's definite that FFXV releases next year regardless now. SE has made it obvious that they want it done with Nomura stepping down one way or another.

user avatar

notnow123487

September 18, 2014 @ 11:13 pmOffline

comment graphic

Master Spockanort
Who are you addressing?


I felt like I saw it a lot in this thread but I could be wrong. It could just be the one guy that mentioned it a couple times on the last page.

Lnds500

September 19, 2014 @ 03:23 amOffline

comment graphic




This image is incredibly sad.. Like they have locked him in the nut-house. :(

btw there are 2 new tweets from the KH account

https://twitter.com/_KINGDOMHEARTS/status/512802124984377344
https://twitter.com/_KINGDOMHEARTS/status/512798480444567552

Nothing related to the departure of course, probably marketing/promo material - just in case anyone is interested.

Sign

September 19, 2014 @ 03:49 amOffline

comment graphic

I know official pictures of Nomura are always of his back because he doesn't like to show his face, but this is so depressing to look at. He looks so lonely ;~;

Ruran

September 19, 2014 @ 03:55 amOffline

comment graphic

I called it but-but I didn't want to be right! At least it's not as dark as I thought it'd be. ;_;

Chaser

September 19, 2014 @ 04:34 amOffline

comment graphic

That image is about the campaign they just launched to send people in Japan to Disney World, and the other tweet was for a review for KH2.5. Nothing relevant to his departure.

Sign

September 19, 2014 @ 04:38 amOffline

comment graphic

Chaser
That image is about the campaign they just launched to send people in Japan to Disney World, and the other tweet was for a review for KH2.5. Nothing relevant to his departure.


We know that, gosh Joey!!!1!11

Chaser

September 19, 2014 @ 04:39 amOffline

comment graphic

Then why is it in this thread!!!!!1!11!!!one!!??

user avatar

Gram

September 19, 2014 @ 04:40 amOffline

comment graphic

Lnds500



This image is incredibly sad.. Like they have locked him in the nut-house. :(

This...it's just so lonely looking. ;n; *can't help but hear the Hulk ending theme when looking at this*

Sign

September 19, 2014 @ 05:03 amOffline

comment graphic

Chaser
Then why is it in this thread!!!!!1!11!!!one!!??


BECAUSE NOMURA

Lnds500

September 19, 2014 @ 02:12 pmOffline

comment graphic

Chaser
Then why is it in this thread!!!!!1!11!!!one!!??


Sign
BECAUSE NOMURA


#Nomura #Isolation


..........

FudgemintGuardian

September 19, 2014 @ 02:23 pmOffline

comment graphic

That has to be the most depressing thing I've ever seen.

king_mickey rule

September 19, 2014 @ 02:26 pmOffline

comment graphic

Lnds500



This image is incredibly sad.. Like they have locked him in the nut-house. :(


"Power 1"

DAMN IT, SE

kuraudoVII

September 19, 2014 @ 03:00 pmOffline

comment graphic

Man...I don't know how to assess this. On one hand, it's possible that Nomura was simply done with everything important that only he could have done for XV, but on the other hand, I can't help but feel like they wanted to get rid of Nomura simply so that the game could be released.

Gram
This...it's just so lonely looking. ;n; *can't help but hear the Hulk ending theme when looking at this*




I actually got more of Ventus' Theme stuck in my head seeing this (Namine's theme is just a tad bit too cheery for this). Either way, it makes me too diddlying sad to see this since it makes him look so isolated, feeling alone. I know I've had days where I felt like this. :C

LedxirnSimon

September 19, 2014 @ 03:31 pmOffline

comment graphic

Lnds500



This image is incredibly sad.. Like they have locked him in the nut-house. :(

btw there are 2 new tweets from the KH account

https://twitter.com/_KINGDOMHEARTS/status/512802124984377344
https://twitter.com/_KINGDOMHEARTS/status/512798480444567552

Nothing related to the departure of course, probably marketing/promo material - just in case anyone is interested.


That image is quite depressing.... to look at... ; A ;

Then I got a mental image of him as Naminé when doing it alone.

Oracle Spockanort

September 19, 2014 @ 04:05 pmOffline

comment graphic

LedxirnSimon
That image is quite depressing.... to look at... ; A ;

Then I got a mental image of him as Naminé when doing it alone.


Nomura is Naminé...A black-clothed Naminé. That draws better.

LedxirnSimon

September 19, 2014 @ 07:54 pmOffline

comment graphic

Master Spockanort
Nomura is Naminé...A black-clothed Naminé. That draws better.

Or maybe naminé is both the female and opposite version of himself when he was young sort of... (Just kidding but that image is soooooooo sad) ;~; *cries*

EDIT: in the picture, it looks like he's sketching sorta by judging the shape of the eyes.

Sdog

September 19, 2014 @ 08:42 pmOffline

comment graphic

So was that image actually recently taken after the announcement? If so that is very sad indeed... either way it is kinda sad but I think I see what he's getting at.

Sign

September 19, 2014 @ 08:58 pmOffline

comment graphic

Sdog
So was that image actually recently taken after the announcement? If so that is very sad indeed... either way it is kinda sad but I think I see what he's getting at.


We actually have no idea when anything takes place behind the scenes. This image is for a contest for Japanese fans of Kingdom Hearts and is completely unrelated to the XV situation.

Sdog

September 19, 2014 @ 09:04 pmOffline

comment graphic

Sign
We actually have no idea when anything takes place behind the scenes. This image is for a contest for Japanese fans of Kingdom Hearts and is completely unrelated to the XV situation.


Ooooook I thought as much, the 2.5 tags at the bottom should have been enough for me to realize.. Wouldn't see anyone allowing anything like this to be posted related to the XV thing.

Thanks again for the clear up!

doortolight

September 20, 2014 @ 12:05 amOffline

comment graphic

don't see why everyone thinks that pic is depressing. he's sitting down quietly drawing one of his most beloved characters, some people enjoy such alone-ness

Oracle Spockanort

September 20, 2014 @ 12:07 amOffline

comment graphic

doortolight
don't see why everyone thinks that pic is depressing. he's sitting down quietly drawing one of his most beloved characters, some people enjoy such alone-ness


We were joking around lol

It's just a really solitary-looking image. Nomura alone with nothing but a table, paper, and pencil.

Antifa Lockhart

September 20, 2014 @ 12:14 amOffline

comment graphic

Oh my god he's not wearing shoes that's so stinking cute.

Dr_Mario64

September 20, 2014 @ 12:38 amOffline

comment graphic

Master Spockanort
Nomura is Naminé...A black-clothed Naminé. That draws better.


The only difference being we actually know a god-forsaken-thing about him.

kupo1121

September 20, 2014 @ 01:10 amOffline

comment graphic

I'm gonna admit, when I first saw that image, I thought it was some weird game where we play as Nomura or something because of the HUD being on the image from KH O___O Why is the HUD there?!?!? Is he attacking the page?

Oracle Spockanort

September 20, 2014 @ 01:15 amOffline

comment graphic

kupo1121
I'm gonna admit, when I first saw that image, I thought it was some weird game where we play as Nomura or something because of the HUD being on the image from KH O___O Why is the HUD there?!?!? Is he attacking the page?


He's supposed to be Sora lol

user avatar

Gram

September 20, 2014 @ 01:48 amOffline

comment graphic

Dr_Mario64
The only difference being we actually know a god-forsaken-thing about him.


lmao



Is he attacking the page?


He's drawing a Sora summon to help him defeat the corporate nobodies~

Magnus

September 20, 2014 @ 01:56 amOffline

comment graphic

I don't think XV will suffer at all. Quite the opposite. I believe Nomura has already contributed with everything he possibly could. According to old interviews, he's had the basic story figured out for many, many years and everything design related seems to be finished too. The only task he had left was to direct the whole thing, but I suspect he wasn't satisfied and wanted to continue adding new pieces to the puzzle. We all know how detailed his descriptions of characters and events are in the Ultimania books and such. Yet we think the games they're for are fine without this information being fed to us within the actual games. They probably have more than enough to make things work just fine, while Nomura could probably spend a couple of more years tweaking the details.

He knows how to work on Kingdom Hearts. It's his baby. Final Fantasy is not. Even if XV was going to be "his take" on the franchise. Kingdom Hearts and its massive lore wasn't built up over a day or two. It's been expanded a little bit at a time. The first game is pretty basic, but it's also more than enough for one game. I think Nomura wanted XV to be as massive and detailed as the whole Kingdom Hearts plot but that's just not realistic. As much as the lack of plot in the latest trailer makes me worry, at the end of the day I do have faith in Tabata to do a good job putting all the ingredients to good use and bake the best cake possible with them, so to speak :P

And Kingdom Hearts 3 will obviously be exactly as good as we could hope for, so no worries there. I still believe that there's a big chance it's going to be his last project as a Square Enix employee.

digimikej

September 20, 2014 @ 05:23 amOffline

comment graphic

Gram
This...it's just so lonely looking. ;n; *can't help but hear the Hulk ending theme when looking at this*

what has been heard and seen cannot be unheard or unseen. also,


Then I got a mental image of him as Naminé when doing it alone.


Namine is Nomuras self insert, confirmed.

Ballad of Caius

September 20, 2014 @ 01:29 pmOffline

comment graphic

I just hope Nomura releases a statement towards his removal in a near future. An interviewer will most definitely bring it up on an interview related to KH3.

rokudamia2

September 20, 2014 @ 06:00 pmOffline

comment graphic

In the upcoming famitsu nterview about XV if they don't mention specifically why Nomura left it'll confirm my suspicions . The Japanese gaming press are essentially given questions to ask. If Nomura left willingly he should be brought up.

Ballad of Caius

September 20, 2014 @ 06:12 pmOffline

comment graphic

rokudamia2
In the upcoming famitsu nterview about XV if they don't mention specifically why Nomura left it'll confirm my suspicions . The Japanese gaming press are essentially given questions to ask. If Nomura left willingly he should be brought up.

Nomura's leaving is too much of an issue to not ask about.

Antifa Lockhart

September 20, 2014 @ 07:09 pmOffline

comment graphic

Ballad of Caius
Nomura's leaving is too much of an issue to not ask about.


It's not out of the question that something like that will have been blacklisted ahead of time.

Oracle Spockanort

September 20, 2014 @ 07:57 pmOffline

comment graphic

Ballad of Caius
Nomura's leaving is too much of an issue to not ask about.


If not being a blacklisted question like Tinny said, they will say the same PR line Matsuda and everybody else has been saying: "Nomura has contributed greatly to FFXV's development and will now be putting all of his efforts on KH3 and other in-development titles"

rokudamia2

September 20, 2014 @ 08:13 pmOffline

comment graphic

I'm 100% certain there's more to this story then they are telling us. The lack of a Nomura comment, and Square Enix EU's press statement is telling. If it is brought up in the famitsu interview it will certainly be the same PR response we saw from SE Japan and SE EU.

Gray Aria

September 20, 2014 @ 09:32 pmOffline

comment graphic

All sentimental value of XV being Nomura's baby aside, I do think this will be beneficial to both XV and KH3. Nomura has already contributed plenty to the point where it probably wouldn't be changed too drastically from his vision and I trust Tabata to do his best.

maleficentfan123

September 21, 2014 @ 04:31 pmOffline

comment graphic

After giving this a great deal of thought I think this can only be what's best for everyone involved.

Nomura now doesn't have to worry about FFXV, which seemed to be extremely exhausting and tiring for him. I understand it was his "baby", but I think he's in a "been there, done that" mentality at this point. And honestly, I feel like he's secretly relieved because now he has more time to devote to KH, his family and his life in general.

It'll be good for both games because they will now both release sooner due to 2 different teams/directors having involvement.

It will also be good for Square because they will obviously make more money sooner this way.

I see it as a win/win/win scenario.

rokudamia2

September 21, 2014 @ 06:06 pmOffline

comment graphic

You are probably right about it being the best for both games, but I'm just wondering why he was replaced? If this was decision Nomura agreed with why didn't he have a quote about this?

Taochan

September 21, 2014 @ 06:22 pmOffline

comment graphic

rokudamia2
You are probably right about it being the best for both games, but I'm just wondering why he was replaced? If this was decision Nomura agreed with why didn't he have a quote about this?

Likely because if it were indeed his decision, then it's probably safe to assume he left the project on bad terms.

rokudamia2

September 21, 2014 @ 06:31 pmOffline

comment graphic

I agree. It probably was on bad terms. And I doubt we'll ever get a clear answering exactly why he left. Unless Nomura leaves the company and spills the beans.

Oracle Spockanort

September 21, 2014 @ 08:08 pmOffline

comment graphic

rokudamia2
I agree. It probably was on bad terms. And I doubt we'll ever get a clear answering exactly why he left. Unless Nomura leaves the company and spills the beans.


Even Matsuno who left Square Enix after being forced off of XII hasn't talked about leaving and he's been gone for almost a decade now. So I wouldn't expect Nomura to ever talk about this if it was a bad split.

user avatar

Gonzales95

September 21, 2014 @ 10:24 pmOffline

comment graphic

I reckon there's a possibility that there's more to this than meets the eye. Someone higher up (not that there are necessarily too many more people higher up than Nomura) probably told him to switch over because let's face it, both games have made fairly glacial progress. FXV has been in development since 2006 (for the last generation of consoles) and still doesn't look very close to coming out, and whilst KH3 hasn't been in development anywhere near as long (does anyone know for sure how long KH3 has been in development?), it's been almost 9 years since KH2 came out and KH3 has somehow managed to skip an entire console generation.

I'm worried that KH3 didn't even make an appearance, even in video form, at Square's TGS conference. I possibly think rather than Nomura being removed from XV, it was more like he was moved over to III to get the game hurried along. Tabata has been co-directing since 2013, so perhaps there was a thought last year that Tabata would be brought on to eventually become the main director of the game? This then allows Nomura to finish work on his franchise without any distractions. Let's be honest, Nomura was trying to direct two huge games at the same time, and that is why both games are making glacial progress. By having him focus on KH, the game should get made a lot faster, and that's what we all want isn't it?

Chaser

September 21, 2014 @ 10:54 pmOffline

comment graphic

Gonzales95
(does anyone know for sure how long KH3 has been in development?)

If my memory serves me right, they planned the ReMIX's for 1.5 and 2.5 as a lead up to III, so by September 2012 they knew that they were making 3. By late 2012, the basic foundations for pre-production were essentially put into place. Over the next few months until June 2013 they were making a very very early build of the game to show off at E3.

Oracle Spockanort

September 21, 2014 @ 11:35 pmOffline

comment graphic

Gonzales95
FXV has been in development since 2006 (for the last generation of consoles) and still doesn't look very close to coming out


Incorrect. They started pre-planning and all of the concept work, writing, some music scoring etc. in 2006 and on. Between 2006-2009, all they ever really likely made game-wise were probably a handful of assets and those CG trailers made by Visual Works we kept getting. During that time Square Enix was having issues with developing White Engine, eventually known as Crystal Tools, on which FFXIII and Versus XIII would be built upon, so instead of working on Versus XIII, everybody was working on getting FFXIII to be a working game for the 2009 release window. In 2009/2010 they went into early development of Versus XIII (building more assets, gameplay system, retooling Crystal Tools for their needs) and made what we saw in 2011. Considering what we DID see, that was some amazing progress and probably left alone they could have gotten the game out in 2013.

Except FFXIV 1.0 was still born and the shame of the company so pretty much every free person they could get was put on FFXIV 2.0, and Versus XIII was left a small team to work on it. When SE became aware of next gen consoles, they decided to move development to that, and so we are where we are now. They likely had to redo plenty of textures and added more polygons and all that jazz to make the PS3 assets more fitting for next gen...so...Versus XIII/FFXV hasn't really been in development as long as you think it has been.

There is more than just games getting in the way of Versus XIII/XV, but likely also company politics, Nomura's ambitions, money issues, the whole upper management reshuffle after Wada left, so on and so on were part of the issue as well.

(This is more or less the history of what happened when looking at the facts)

The way things look, I'd say we are certainly closer to an early 2016 release than we ever have been.



and whilst KH3 hasn't been in development anywhere near as long (does anyone know for sure how long KH3 has been in development?), it's been almost 9 years since KH2 came out and KH3 has somehow managed to skip an entire console generation.



KH3 began early dev in late 2012/early 2013, like Chaser noted. That is why we had the four handheld titles. Nomura had always believed that Versus XIII/XV would come out faster than it has and he would move to KH3 after that, but instead that never happened.

I am honestly happy it is skipping over PS3, though. I think a better game can be made on PS4/XB1, especially since it'll be running on Luminous (unless they have changed their minds about that).



I'm worried that KH3 didn't even make an appearance, even in video form, at Square's TGS conference.



I don't think that is anything to worry about. It's only been in development a year. Give them some time to make something worth showing.



I possibly think rather than Nomura being removed from XV, it was more like he was moved over to III to get the game hurried along.



Well, that was why we had Yasue on KH3. He was there to monitor the day to day operations and keep things on track.



Tabata has been co-directing since 2013, so perhaps there was a thought last year that Tabata would be brought on to eventually become the main director of the game?



I doubt that. I personally think he was initially brought on to be Nomura's successor once FFXV was done. It was clear in 2013 they were thinking about sequels, and it was a well known fact that Nomura had no intentions of working on another Final Fantasy title as a director after XV, but Hajime Tabata has become one of the faces of FF besides Naoki Yoshida.

Also the fact that Tabata was likely hired to do day-to-day work like Yasue was for KH3. Nomura is not your typical director. He probably doesn't think along the lines of schedules, meeting goals, and solid planning. He is more about the details, letting ideas grow and change, and like pushing limits. That can be a problem when making games, especially now that we are in a new generation where there are no limits beyond that of time & money.



This then allows Nomura to finish work on his franchise without any distractions. Let's be honest, Nomura was trying to direct two huge games at the same time, and that is why both games are making glacial progress. By having him focus on KH, the game should get made a lot faster, and that's what we all want isn't it?



Having Nomura on KH3 might make things go faster, for certain, and even allow ideas to flourish more, but like I said Nomura isn't the typical kind of director. If we are working on the belief Nomura chose to leave FFXV and did it on good terms, Nomura working full-time on KH3 was likely more of a personal desire to see the work being complete first-hand rather than it being done to make the game come out faster.

rokudamia2

September 22, 2014 @ 08:30 pmOffline

comment graphic

Based on new interviews with Tabata, I'm certain Nomura was used as a scapegoat. And while he himself isn't blameless in making Versus XIII development hell, the Management was just as bad.

Ballad of Caius

September 23, 2014 @ 12:40 amOffline

comment graphic

rokudamia2
Based on new interviews with Tabata, I'm certain Nomura was used as a scapegoat. And while he himself isn't blameless in making Versus XIII development hell, the Management was just as bad.

I just hope utilizing Nomura as an scapegoat doesn't have any sort of side effects.

Gray Aria

September 23, 2014 @ 12:45 amOffline

comment graphic

Ballad of Caius
I just hope utilizing Nomura as an scapegoat doesn't have any sort of side effects.


You mean like a Keiji Inafune situation where he leaves the company, works on his own new indie projects, and speaks ill of the Japanese game industry? It crossed my mind that something like that could possibly happen if he left XV on extremely bad terms.

user avatar

Gram

September 23, 2014 @ 01:51 amOffline

comment graphic

Juggernaut6
You mean like a Keiji Inafune situation where he leaves the company, works on his own new indie projects, and speaks ill of the Japanese game industry? It crossed my mind that something like that could possibly happen if he left XV on extremely bad terms.


It crossed my mind as well as I've kept up with this thread. Not really sure Nomura would pull a Keiji though....

Ballad of Caius

September 23, 2014 @ 11:50 amOffline

comment graphic

Juggernaut6
You mean like a Keiji Inafune situation where he leaves the company, works on his own new indie projects, and speaks ill of the Japanese game industry? It crossed my mind that something like that could possibly happen if he left XV on extremely bad terms.


Gram
It crossed my mind as well as I've kept up with this thread. Not really sure Nomura would pull a Keiji though....

That makes three of us. Hopefully, that doesn't happen. I doubt Mr. Nomura would, seeing as how he values his work too much and wouldn't go to the extremes of making a counter franchise like a Kingdom Hearts look alike.

user avatar

Gram

September 24, 2014 @ 02:36 amOffline

comment graphic

Ballad of Caius
That makes three of us. Hopefully, that doesn't happen. I doubt Mr. Nomura would, seeing as how he values his work too much and wouldn't go to the extremes of making a counter franchise like a Kingdom Hearts look alike.


Yeah I don't see Nomura pulling a Keiji myself though at the same time I don't put a stunt of any kind past a persons capability of doing either cause ya never know. o_0

Sign

September 24, 2014 @ 02:42 amOffline

comment graphic

rokudamia2
Based on new interviews with Tabata, I'm certain Nomura was used as a scapegoat. And while he himself isn't blameless in making Versus XIII development hell, the Management was just as bad.


Pretty much. And it's gotten even worse since western publication has decided to label him as an incompetent director and "the guy who ruined FFXV".

WhinyAcademic

September 24, 2014 @ 07:05 amOffline

comment graphic

Sign
It's Type-0 HD that's scheduled for a March 2015 release, not XV.


Sdog
Sorry to break it to ya but FFXV has no plans of release in March, that's Type-0. I'm still bettin on a Fall/Winter 2015 release for XV though.


Lnds500
It's horrible news no matter how you look at it and we will be lucky if we get a demo in March, let alone the full game. We won't be seeing the full game for some time.


Ah, well, whatever. No bubble popping here, I'll be surprised if we get III by 2020. The sumbitch and XV have taken a decade, let's see them come out on the PS6! More reasonable time frame, am I right?

Sign

September 24, 2014 @ 09:30 pmOffline

comment graphic

Nomura made a single comment in Famitsu about this issue, confirming that it was a decision made by the company and not himself.

Jesus

September 24, 2014 @ 09:42 pmOffline

comment graphic

Sign
Nomura made a single comment in Famitsu about this issue, confirming that it was a decision made by the company and not himself.


Well that sucks. Guess he's not planning to go into detail about the situation any time soon?

Sign

September 24, 2014 @ 09:46 pmOffline

comment graphic

Doesn't look like he's allowed to, unfortunately.

Oracle Spockanort

September 24, 2014 @ 09:50 pmOffline

comment graphic

Guard
Well that sucks. Guess he's not planning to go into detail about the situation any time soon?


More like he probably can't talk about it. Guys who even left the company after being booted off their projects haven't even spoke about what happened (i.e. Hiromichi Tanaka the producer of XIV 1.0 who left the company due to "health reasons", or Yasumi Matsuno the director of XII (uncredited) who left the company due to "health reasons" though to be fair he actually did get sick from being under the stress SE was putting on him) And I think it took Sakaguchi years before he actually started discussing the shit that went on at SE during the merger and resulting chaos, and he still really talks about it vague ways.

Don't expect Nomura to talk about it more unless Square Enix allows him, but the press is eating Tabata up so there is unlikely to be an opportunity when he can.

Shamdeo

September 24, 2014 @ 09:54 pmOffline

comment graphic

I'm expecting he'll leave the company altogether in the not-too-distant future.

See: Matsuno, Tanaka, etc.

rokudamia2

September 24, 2014 @ 10:05 pmOffline

comment graphic

Shamdeo
I'm expecting he'll leave the company altogether in the not-too-distant future.

See: Matsuno, Tanaka, etc.


I'm expecting a few months after kh3 is released he'll leave SE. To where I have no idea

Jesus

September 24, 2014 @ 10:12 pmOffline

comment graphic

Sign
Doesn't look like he's allowed to, unfortunately.


Shamdeo
I'm expecting he'll leave the company altogether in the not-too-distant future.

See: Matsuno, Tanaka, etc.


Master Spockanort
More like he probably can't talk about it. Guys who even left the company after being booted off their projects haven't even spoke about what happened (i.e. Hiromichi Tanaka the producer of XIV 1.0 who left the company due to "health reasons", or Yasumi Matsuno the director of XII (uncredited) who left the company due to "health reasons" though to be fair he actually did get sick from being under the stress SE was putting on him) And I think it took Sakaguchi years before he actually started discussing the shit that went on at SE during the merger and resulting chaos, and he still really talks about it vague ways.

Don't expect Nomura to talk about it more unless Square Enix allows him, but the press is eating Tabata up so there is unlikely to be an opportunity when he can.


Well it looks like nomura's coming out of this in the worst way, what a shame for such a beloved figure in Square's employ

I guess all hail tabata? Feels dirty

rokudamia2

September 24, 2014 @ 10:19 pmOffline

comment graphic

Guard
Well it looks like nomura's coming out of this in the worst way, what a shame for such a beloved figure in Square's employ

I guess all hail tabata? Feels dirty


I've just realized that Yasue, and Tabata are his successors as directors, and there are multiple artists that are succeeding him he only designed the major characters in the XIII trilogy and in some cases only their faces.

Ruran

September 24, 2014 @ 10:19 pmOffline

comment graphic

It's only been week and we're already planning Nomura's retirement.

*crying*

rokudamia2

September 24, 2014 @ 10:22 pmOffline

comment graphic

Ruran
It's only been week and we're already planning Nomura's retirement.

*crying*


If I had to guess, he will probably still work in the industry. But I don't know to what extent. I doubt he'll ever direct a major title again. I could also see him becoming a full time character designer.

FudgemintGuardian

September 24, 2014 @ 10:31 pmOffline

comment graphic

Well, I like that we know something about it now, but this just sucks. I hope it was simply a "hey, we noticed there isn't really anything for you on this game anymore so we want your full attention on KHIII now." But everyday we don't know what really went down I keep thinking major crap happened.

Shamdeo

September 24, 2014 @ 10:33 pmOffline

comment graphic

Guard
Well it looks like nomura's coming out of this in the worst way, what a shame for such a beloved figure in Square's employ


It depends on Nomura from here on. If he feels too much of an attachment for his current projects or if he feels that another company won't put up with... to be blunt, his bullshit, he may stay despite a "diminished" role.

Guard
I guess all hail tabata? Feels dirty


Guy is gonna get the job done. Nomura's done all the creative fiddling he needs to at this point, and I don't think he has the chops for the director's chair anyway (and this isn't an insult, some people just aren't suited for it.) Nomura's best at his creative direction, not meeting deadlines and interfacing with the business side.

There are people at Square Enix, like Naoki Yoshida for example, that have to make decisions every day that may betray their own interests for the greater good. He's a long-time MMORPG gamer, and someone you might define as "hardcore", but he also has a game that doubles as a service. He may have to tell his leads to change or scrap something that may not justify the expense or knows won't satisfy a large portion of his audience.

I don't think Nomura is that kind of developer, and that's pretty much why Yasue has been running the Kingdom Hearts show as "co-director" for years now. (Spoiler?)

Tabata's first action to set a release goal for this insanely overdue project was the best thing. It's time to shit or get off the pot. I think most other companies would have nuked the project from orbit by now, and Nomura's lucky Wada (CEO and Prez at the time) gave his project (and Final Fantasy XIV) another chance.

Xehanort-X-blade

September 24, 2014 @ 10:39 pmOffline

comment graphic

maybe because KH3 have alot of work they still gone add new soundtracks new story new opening new heartless new worlds new keyblades new magics and many more maybe thats why he left FFXV because KH3 still have many things not finish and nomura need time to think of xehanort saga plot since the story already confusing lol and FFxv look like gone be done before KH3 since we saw many trailers and cutscenes

rokudamia2

September 24, 2014 @ 10:40 pmOffline

comment graphic

Shamdeo
It depends on Nomura from here on. If he feels too much of an attachment for his current projects or if he feels that another company won't put up with... to be blunt, his bullshit, he may stay despite a "diminished" role.



Guy is gonna get the job done. Nomura's done all the creative fiddling he needs to at this point, and I don't think he has the chops for the director's chair anyway (and this isn't an insult, some people just aren't suited for it.) Nomura's best at his creative direction, not meeting deadlines and interfacing with the business side.

There are people at Square Enix, like Naoki Yoshida for example, that have to make decisions every day that may betray their own interests for the greater good. He's a long-time MMORPG gamer, and someone you might define as "hardcore", but he also has a game that doubles as a service. He may have to tell his leads to change or scrap something that may not justify the expense or knows won't satisfy a large portion of his audience.

I don't think Nomura is that kind of developer, and that's pretty much why Yasue has been running the Kingdom Hearts show as "co-director" for years now. (Spoiler?)

Tabata's first action to set a release goal for this insanely overdue project was the best thing. It's time to shit or get off the pot. I think most other companies would have nuked the project from orbit by now, and Nomura's lucky Wada (CEO and Prez at the time) gave his project (and Final Fantasy XIV) another chance.


Very blunt, and to the point. That's why I said he may just become an artist, and character designer. He did seem to be wasting money.

Lnds500

September 24, 2014 @ 11:19 pmOffline

comment graphic

Shamdeo
Nomura's lucky Wada (CEO and Prez at the time) gave his project (and F". Binal Fantasy XIV) another chance.


His project is one of the most hyped games in recent memory, if ever. It's gonna be an instant hit no matter what happens with the story/gameplay/director etc and Nomura also has another ultra-hyped, long-awaited project in the works.

Meanwhile Square's console offerings for many years have varied from "OK" - at best, to "mediocre" and "awful". Besides XIV, which was another clusterdiddly at first, they have only put out Lightning trash this past generation and they have nothing exciting to show in their console line-up that doesn't stem from Nomura's vision (I am not counting remasters).

It is debatable who is being lucky here.


I've said it before. I'd love it for Nomura to leave Square without doing them the favour of finishing KH 3. From what we know so far, it only serves them right.

And my vote for the next company goes to SCEJ. Huge boost.

Oracle Spockanort

September 24, 2014 @ 11:23 pmOffline

comment graphic

rokudamia2
Very blunt, and to the point. That's why I said he may just become an artist, and character designer. He did seem to be wasting money.


Woah, let us not say it that way. Development on Versus XIII probably got expensive but it wasn't because he was wasting money because he could. Hashimoto should have been a more stern producer and kept Nomura on track, SE should have given Nomura a proper staff to work on the game, maybe SE shouldn't have made all of those CG trailers. But this is all moot now. There is WAY too much we don't know to say "Nomura was wasting money" because sorry it wasn't his fault exclusively. The blame is also on all of the management who had a hand with the treatment of the project these last 8 years.

user avatar

Some guy

September 24, 2014 @ 11:29 pmOffline

comment graphic

There's so much pessimism in this thread, let's not kiss Nomura goodbye before any confirmation ...

rokudamia2

September 25, 2014 @ 12:01 amOffline

comment graphic

Master Spockanort
Woah, let us not say it that way. Development on Versus XIII probably got expensive but it wasn't because he was wasting money because he could. Hashimoto should have been a more stern producer and kept Nomura on track, SE should have given Nomura a proper staff to work on the game, maybe SE shouldn't have made all of those CG trailers. But this is all moot now. There is WAY too much we don't know to say "Nomura was wasting money" because sorry it wasn't his fault exclusively. The blame is also on all of the management who had a hand with the treatment of the project these last 8 years.



I don't mean for it to come off as blaming him. I meant to say he will be seen as a developer who wasted a lot of money. I'm not saying he was.

Edit: @Lnds500: when did I say "Nomura's lucky Wada (CEO and Prez at the time) gave his project (and F". Binal Fantasy XIV) another chance."? I never said anything about Wada or FFXIV in that post. I'm just talking about people who ould possibly succeed him.

Ballad of Caius

September 25, 2014 @ 12:06 amOffline

comment graphic

Assuming Nomura leaves and SE/Disney decide to continue with Kingdom Hearts, I hope the franchise is given to good hands.

Lnds500

September 25, 2014 @ 12:42 amOffline

comment graphic

rokudamia2
I don't mean for it to come off as blaming him. I meant to say he will be seen as a developer who wasted a lot of money. I'm not saying he was.

Edit: @Lnds500: when did I say "Nomura's lucky Wada (CEO and Prez at the time) gave his project (and F". Binal Fantasy XIV) another chance."? I never said anything about Wada or FFXIV in that post. I'm just talking about people who ould possibly succeed him.



I have no idea what happened, I didn't quote you.. :confused:

I fixed it.

rokudamia2

September 25, 2014 @ 12:52 amOffline

comment graphic

Lnds500
I have no idea what happened, I didn't quote you.. :confused:

I fixed it.


Thank you.

But yeah it's very interesting the past week has revealed to me a lot about how thing were being run over there. (Atleast in regards to FFXV I knew what was going on with FFXIV.)

user avatar

Gram

September 25, 2014 @ 03:26 amOffline

comment graphic

Whoa, one statement and we're already thinking Nomura is leaving? o_0 (though I wouldn't put it past him)

Ballad of Caius
Assuming Nomura leaves and SE/Disney decide to continue with Kingdom Hearts, I hope the franchise is given to good hands.

I won't lie, it's hard to imagine anyone atm....if it happens though hopefully it stays good and far less convoluted.

Sign

September 25, 2014 @ 03:42 amOffline

comment graphic

don't know if you've noticed already but these beliefs are based after much more than just "one statement".

who knows what will happen? nomura's doesn't share the same mindset of most devs

user avatar

Gram

September 25, 2014 @ 03:45 amOffline

comment graphic

Sign
don't know if you've noticed already but these beliefs are based after much more than just "one statement"

I seen after posting it but meh.

Sign

September 25, 2014 @ 05:05 amOffline

comment graphic

This has nothing to do with the topic but since Lnds posted one of the earlier images a few pages ago, we might as well continue with it here and brighten up the doom and gloom.



HE SLACKED OFF THIS IS TOO CUTE


(note: the activated command in the action menu is "slack off" lol)

Antifa Lockhart

September 25, 2014 @ 05:12 amOffline

comment graphic

Aw Tetsu, I want to give you a giant hug.

Oracle Spockanort

September 25, 2014 @ 05:12 amOffline

comment graphic

NOMURA STOP BEING PERFECT. Somebody should have put his cats in the photo.

;~; <3

hemmoheikkinen

September 25, 2014 @ 06:41 amOffline

comment graphic

Oh man. Nomura looks so happy. :) I would like to see more pictures when Nomura is drawing, his art is good! Just wondering, but do you guys think he is drawing the KH1 style Sora? I wish he would make more pictures of the KH2 version too.

Sign

September 25, 2014 @ 06:52 amOffline

comment graphic

hemmoheikkinen
Oh man. Nomura looks so happy. :)


Not sure if "happy" is the right word, but he's messing around!



I would like to see more pictures when Nomura is drawing, his art is good! Just wondering, but do you guys think he is drawing the KH1 style Sora? I wish he would make more pictures of the KH2 version too.



This is promotion for the special 2.5 campaign, so he's drawing KH2 Sora. The inner shirt is a huge giveaway.

hemmoheikkinen

September 25, 2014 @ 07:02 amOffline

comment graphic



This is promotion for the special 2.5 campaign, so he's drawing KH2 Sora. The inner shirt is a huge giveaway.




Yes! More KH2 Sora! :) I guess I should know it`s KH2 since it`s the KH2.5 campaign after all. I kind of wish he would draw Riku and Kairi too, since it`s not often we see their KH2 versions.



Not sure if "happy" is the right word, but he's messing around!



Ah yes, that suits the mood of the picture better. Somebody needs to tell Nomura that even after the whole FFXV(which I am still looking forward to) deal, the KH-fandom still loves him.

user avatar

Bobizzle

September 25, 2014 @ 09:49 amOffline

comment graphic

If Nomura does decide to leave SE in the future, maybe he should go over to Konami and team up with Hideo Kojima. I'd love to see how he'd handle Metal Gear Solid's already convoluted but awesome storyline lol.

rokudamia2

September 25, 2014 @ 10:24 amOffline

comment graphic

Oh I hadn't even thought of konami. To be honest I could definitely see Kojima being one, if not the first to offer him a job if he ever left square. They are good friends after all.

Oracle Spockanort

September 25, 2014 @ 02:56 pmOffline

comment graphic

Bobizzle
If Nomura does decide to leave SE in the future, maybe he should go over to Konami and team up with Hideo Kojima. I'd love to see how he'd handle Metal Gear Solid's already convoluted but awesome storyline lol.


Konami is kind of a dead company outside of MGS and Silent Hill (and the soccer game series they have. I would mention Castlevania but they keep messing up with it).

Even if Nomura went there if he left SE after KH3 (and I have this feeling he won't because SE will do their best to have him happy even though he isn't on FFXV) I don't think he'd be given the same liberties as Kojima.

FudgemintGuardian

September 25, 2014 @ 03:14 pmOffline

comment graphic

Sign
This has nothing to do with the topic but since Lnds posted one of the earlier images a few pages ago, we might as well continue with it here and brighten up the doom and gloom.



HE SLACKED OFF THIS IS TOO CUTE


(note: the activated command in the action menu is "slack off" lol)
Aww, Nomura looks so adorable slacking off. I can just picture him swinging that Keyblade next to him and making sound effects. <3

user avatar

Bobizzle

September 25, 2014 @ 06:47 pmOffline

comment graphic

rokudamia2
Oh I hadn't even thought of konami. To be honest I could definitely see Kojima being one, if not the first to offer him a job if he ever left square. They are good friends after all.



thats true, and I think he could fit right in with him and a lot of Konami's other staff. He could help create a new project that would allow Konami to expand with more than just MGS and SH as flagship titles. It would be a slow build most likely, but I think he could excel.


Master Spockanort
Konami is kind of a dead company outside of MGS and Silent Hill (and the soccer game series they have. I would mention Castlevania but they keep messing up with it).


Even if Nomura went there if he left SE after KH3 (and I have this feeling he won't because SE will do their best to have him happy even though he isn't on FFXV) I don't think he'd be given the same liberties as Kojima.



I doubt Nomura leaves either, I'm just pointing out that Konami could be an option. And while they aren't quite known for many great franchises, MGS is enough to keep them alive basically forever lol. And no Nomura wouldn't get the same privileges as a director immediately, but I doubt he'd start off as director. He probably would work with Kojima for awhile and could maybe take over the Metal Get franchise once Kojima retires, then move on to other things. But like you said it's probably a moot point cause I don't see him really leaving SE.

Sdog

September 25, 2014 @ 07:04 pmOffline

comment graphic

Sign
This has nothing to do with the topic but since Lnds posted one of the earlier images a few pages ago, we might as well continue with it here and brighten up the doom and gloom.



HE SLACKED OFF THIS IS TOO CUTE


(note: the activated command in the action menu is "slack off" lol)


Man is such a great artist, what I'd give to have a 1on1 lesson with him for a day.

Plus he looks so content and laid back I love it!

Even if Nomura went there if he left SE after KH3 (and I have this feeling he won't because SE will do their best to have him happy even though he isn't on FFXV) I don't think he'd be given the same liberties as Kojima.


I'm sure after Square sees the success of KH3 (whether its a 10/10 game or not) they'd do their best to make sure he's happy as well. Give him a break and let him have more time for other projects I say. Though I don't want to wait another 10 years for a Kh console game. =p

Ballad of Caius

September 25, 2014 @ 08:01 pmOffline

comment graphic

Master Spockanort
Konami is kind of a dead company outside of MGS and Silent Hill (and the soccer game series they have. I would mention Castlevania but they keep messing up with it).

Even if Nomura went there if he left SE after KH3 (and I have this feeling he won't because SE will do their best to have him happy even though he isn't on FFXV) I don't think he'd be given the same liberties as Kojima.

Oh God, you make it sound as if Nomura will be SE's Kojima... Keeping in mind all that stuff of creativity limitations and wanting to do other stuff...

kuraudoVII

September 26, 2014 @ 12:42 amOffline

comment graphic

Master Spockanort
Konami is kind of a dead company outside of MGS and Silent Hill (and the soccer game series they have. I would mention Castlevania but they keep messing up with it).

Even if Nomura went there if he left SE after KH3 (and I have this feeling he won't because SE will do their best to have him happy even though he isn't on FFXV) I don't think he'd be given the same liberties as Kojima.


Gah. Tell me about it.

Anyway, I agree that they will most likely try to keep Nomura in the company. They've relied on him for too much over the years now and I'd like to think that there is some semblance of loyalty from all sides.

Sdog
I'm sure after Square sees the success of KH3 (whether its a 10/10 game or not) they'd do their best to make sure he's happy as well. Give him a break and let him have more time for other projects I say. Though I don't want to wait another 10 years for a Kh console game. =p


Agreed. We need a little bit more consistency than we've had in recent years.

KHRULER

September 26, 2014 @ 01:43 amOffline

comment graphic

"It was a company decision. That's all I can say right now."


Poor Nomura, can't even imagine what he's feeling right now. :/

Chaser

September 26, 2014 @ 01:47 amOffline

comment graphic

KHRULER
Poor Nomura, can't even imagine what he's feeling right now. :/

KHRULER

September 26, 2014 @ 01:49 amOffline

comment graphic

Chaser

Lol, that actually made me laugh.Seems he was happy drawing Sora.

Sign

September 26, 2014 @ 02:08 amOffline

comment graphic

KHRULER
Lol, that actually made me laugh.Seems he was happy drawing Sora.


Sora's special to him~

Taochan

September 26, 2014 @ 02:26 amOffline

comment graphic

Chaser

This is pretty flipping adorable.

Javelin434

September 26, 2014 @ 03:01 amOffline

comment graphic

Sign
This has nothing to do with the topic but since Lnds posted one of the earlier images a few pages ago, we might as well continue with it here and brighten up the doom and gloom.



HE SLACKED OFF THIS IS TOO CUTE


(note: the activated command in the action menu is "slack off" lol)

This... This just made my day xD

Roxas1X

October 10, 2014 @ 04:44 amOffline

comment graphic

I'm a bit disappointed but it's good to see Nomura back on the KH wagon :)

rokudamia2

October 10, 2014 @ 04:50 amOffline

comment graphic

He does seem to be upset about it. I don't blame him for being upset about it. But, holy shit did a lot of anti Nomira statements come out of the woodwork.

Gray Aria

October 11, 2014 @ 06:12 pmOffline

comment graphic

I guess Final Fantasy XV is...

*puts on sunglasses*

Tetsuya No-more-a.

kuraudoVII

October 11, 2014 @ 06:40 pmOffline

comment graphic

Juggernaut6
I guess Final Fantasy XV is...

*puts on sunglasses*

Tetsuya No-more-a.




In all seriousness, while Nomura may be upset about it, at least it looks like he is trying to move forward through all of this.

Xickin

October 19, 2014 @ 04:58 amOffline

comment graphic

I heard KH3 might not be out till 2019...scary thought

Xehanort-X-blade

October 19, 2014 @ 05:00 amOffline

comment graphic

Xickin
I heard KH3 might not be out till 2019...scary thought

ohh lol no way it's in 2015 or maybe 2016 tho hope not at 2016 i heard it's in MAY 2015

Xickin

October 19, 2014 @ 05:02 amOffline

comment graphic

Xehanort-X-blade
ohh lol no way it's in 2015 or maybe 2016 tho hope not at 2016 i heard it's in MAY 2015

Where'd you hear/read that?

Xehanort-X-blade

October 19, 2014 @ 05:05 amOffline

comment graphic

Xickin
Where'd you hear/read that?

i saw it on youtube and all people saying MAY 2015 what about you lol how said it's in 2019


EDIT: there wasn't confirmed that it's in 2015 may but don't worry it's in 2015

Taochan

October 19, 2014 @ 05:08 amOffline

comment graphic

Xehanort-X-blade
i saw it on youtube and all people saying MAY 2015 what about you lol how said it's in 2019


EDIT: there wasn't confirmed that it's in 2015 may but don't worry it's in 2015

There has to be confirmation to be able to say it as fact. There is no release date set for Kingdom Hearts 3.

Xickin

October 19, 2014 @ 05:08 amOffline

comment graphic

Mmmm...I'm thinking you trust the words of youtubers too much. Square Enix hasn't even given out a release date

Chaser

October 19, 2014 @ 05:13 amOffline

comment graphic

May 2015 is just when the latest financial report or w/e ends. That document was released and there was nothing about KH3 or FFXV on it so everyone jumped the gun and yelled that KH3 won't be out until after that, which was very obvious.

Hobbe

October 19, 2014 @ 05:14 amOffline

comment graphic

I'm going to have faith in the YouTubers for now despite them obviously knowing nothing because... well... 2019 is more horribly depressing than scary ×_×*

Xehanort-X-blade

October 19, 2014 @ 05:14 amOffline

comment graphic

Xickin
Mmmm...I'm thinking you trust the words of youtubers too much. Square Enix hasn't even given out a release date

lol really says the guy who was afraid it's on 2019 with out

release date out you trust those ansewrs two but don't worry it's not on 2019

Taochan

October 19, 2014 @ 05:17 amOffline

comment graphic

Hobbe
I'm going to have faith in the YouTubers for now despite them obviously knowing nothing because... well... 2019 is more horribly depressing than scary ×_×*

Unless there are some horrendous development issues it won't be 2019.

Oracle Spockanort

October 19, 2014 @ 05:22 amOffline

comment graphic

Hobbe
I'm going to have faith in the YouTubers for now despite them obviously knowing nothing because... well... 2019 is more horribly depressing than scary ×_×*


Why would you trust YouTubers when they have no empirical data for their prediction?

KH3 is not going to come out 2019. Disney and SE need this game to come out long before then, but it certainly isn't coming 2015. Set your sights more towards 2016 and 2017 as the latest.

robvandam111

October 19, 2014 @ 05:23 amOffline

comment graphic

I still have faith that it'll be 2016, Exactly 10 years....10 YEARS! After Kingdom Hearts 2.

Hobbe

October 19, 2014 @ 05:46 amOffline

comment graphic

I should point out that I don't actually believe it'll be here in 2015 or 2019. 2015 is more of an 'I'll be pleasantly surprised but not bloody likely' and 2019 is like a 'Seriously guys get your shit together!'

Personally expecting mid 2016 and thinking 2017 is pushing it.

Trusting YouTubers is definitely faith-based :p Evidence be damned when it comes to wishful thinking.

Xehanort-X-blade

October 19, 2014 @ 06:00 amOffline

comment graphic

Hobbe
I should point out that I don't actually believe it'll be here in 2015 or 2019. 2015 is more of an 'I'll be pleasantly surprised but not bloody likely' and 2019 is like a 'Seriously guys get your shit together!'

Personally expecting mid 2016 and thinking 2017 is pushing it.

Trusting YouTubers is definitely faith-based :p Evidence be damned when it comes to wishful thinking.
hmm i don't know how to say this in english since im arabian but listen if you keep saying its in 2016 or 2017 and you say like ohh it's gone take long believe me than it's gone take longer just believe that it well come faster

Xickin

October 19, 2014 @ 01:18 pmOffline

comment graphic

Xehanort-X-blade
lol really says the guy who was afraid it's on 2019 with out

release date out you trust those ansewrs two but don't worry it's not on 2019


The only reason I said that was because there is an official report of Tetsuya Nomura saying he's going to be busy with different plans up until 2019, excluding Kingdom Hearts 3

kuraudoVII

October 20, 2014 @ 03:46 pmOffline

comment graphic

robvandam111
I still have faith that it'll be 2016, Exactly 10 years....10 YEARS! After Kingdom Hearts 2.


Diddlying A. This right here makes me feel old...

k99y77

October 24, 2014 @ 08:40 pmOffline

comment graphic

do you guys remember the "expect a long wait between FFXV and KH3" news last year? do you think that gap is now smaller since KH3 is now using a different engine and got its director back?

Antifa Lockhart

October 24, 2014 @ 08:50 pmOffline

comment graphic

k99y77
do you guys remember the "expect a long wait between FFXV and KH3" news last year? do you think that gap is now smaller since KH3 is now using a different engine and got its director back?


Probably not. Even taking out the actual timeframe of when Nomura left, you have to consider that KH3 is still very much early in production and FF XV is like 55% finished. Ish.

robvandam111

October 24, 2014 @ 09:21 pmOffline

comment graphic

Tinny
Probably not. Even taking out the actual timeframe of when Nomura left, you have to consider that KH3 is still very much early in production and FF XV is like 55% finished. Ish.



Let's hope by now that's actually 60-65% done by now lol.

Oracle Spockanort

October 24, 2014 @ 09:54 pmOffline

comment graphic

robvandam111
Let's hope by now that's actually 60-65% done by now lol.


They wouldn't make a 10% increase in a month. Keep in mind development doesn't work in percentages. They definitely give percents to the audience to help us understand the amount of work done, but this is a pretty difficult process to tally.

robvandam111

October 24, 2014 @ 10:08 pmOffline

comment graphic

Master Spockanort
They wouldn't make a 10% increase in a month. Keep in mind development doesn't work in percentages. They definitely give percents to the audience to help us understand the amount of work done, but this is a pretty difficult process to tally.


For some awkward reason I was thinking the news was from E3. That's right, it was from the Tokyo Game Show. Feels so long ago already.

kuraudoVII

October 25, 2014 @ 04:19 pmOffline

comment graphic

robvandam111
For some awkward reason I was thinking the news was from E3. That's right, it was from the Tokyo Game Show. Feels so long ago already.


To be fair, it kinda was. Well, at least it means that the Jump Festa is inching closer.

ThePumpkinQueen

February 12, 2015 @ 03:16 amOffline

comment graphic

I'm excited to hear this. Means they are putting some serious time into KH3. But, being a fan of Final Fantasy as well. I really hope Hajime can fill his shoes. though he was previously co directing i hope he sticks with whatever they were doing. I have not played type O. so i have nothing to compare by.

Either way I hope both games come soon. Clips i've seen of both are driving me mad.

as for when it comes out. I have a feeling it will probably be mid to late 2016 even though it was being said that it was going to come out late this year. I don't think thats likely. 2016 or 17 seem likely but who knows how much is developed on Kingdom hearts three.

I think Final Fantasy 15 will be out before KH 3

user avatar

emotionengine

July 30, 2015 @ 07:35 pmOffline

comment graphic

k99y77
do you guys remember the "expect a long wait between FFXV and KH3" news last year? do you think that gap is now smaller since KH3 is now using a different engine and got its director back?


Yes, the gap is smaller. It seems many people here and around the internet are still stuck in the 1990's when it comes to the way Square-Enix works (and, to be fair, Square-Enix themselves were stuck in the 1990's until relatively recently). It does all come down to the engine.

The reason previous S-E games were stuck in development for so long is due to their proprietary engines. Imagine this example: I want to make you dinner, so I get in my car and go to the grocery store, get the food, come back and make you dinner. If S-E would make you dinner, they would first have to design and build a car before going to the grocery store. This obviously takes a ridiculous amount of time and resources that would be better spent on developing the game itself.

S-E, thank God, realized this when it came to KHIII. They saw that FFXV was taking forever due to the proprietary engine, so they switched to Unreal 4. Unreal 4 is extremely robust, probably every bit as good as the in-house S-E engine (in terms of technical capability, if not better!), with the important *huge* advantage that it is much easier to learn and use. In addition, it has great external support from its creators, Epic. Epic have made it conscious priority to evangelize and support Unreal 4 for Japanese devs this gen. This is a big, big deal. Now instead of fighting the war on 2 fronts (engine development and game development), everything can be focused on game development.

The Japanese developers got crushed last gen due to their insistence on going in-house for engines. For some it paid off, temporarily. But S-E was firmly behind. They saw the light this gen, and went with a robust third-party engine with excellent support and documentation. Unreal 4 is lightyears ahead of Luminous Studio in terms of flow and support. Epic is very committed to the Japanese developers this time around and is actively helping them get more out of it, and do so quicker.

Taking 10 years to deliver a game due to an in-house engine is embarrassing and unacceptable. If KHIII was on Luminous, it would indeed probably take another 3 years to finish. Instead, I fully expect it to be released at some point in 2016. At D23, they will probably reveal "coming in 2016". But they may not give specific date(s) until after the New Year. I would be very surprised if KHIII is ready for sale by Spring 2016, but likewise I would also be shocked if it doesn't go on sale by holiday season (Q4) 2016. The real bad news is for FFXV fans (I never played that series, so I could care less)...that game will probably be upstaged by KHIII and delayed until 2017, precisely due to issues with the Luminous Studio. They'll probably release another demo next year to hold people over. It probably takes anywhere from 2-5 times longer (minimum) to accomplish things in Luminous Studio compared to Unreal 4. For a "simple" Keyblade transformation, it could mean the difference between 1 week to design and compile a change, versus mere minutes.

People need to quit living in the past. S-E used to take forever to get you games because they were in a p*ssing match with other Japanese studios, seeing who could build the better in-house engine. And, to be fair, the previous Unreals didn't have great support for Japanese devs from Epic. They *all* learned their lesson this time around. Why kill yourself to make an engine in-house that in some ways is massively inferior (complexity and support) to what is available third party?? Expect more from S-E going forward, not the same-old-same.

Bottom line, I am confident that KHIII will be released in 2016, and we have Unreal 4 to thank for that.

+ Reply

©2016 KHInsider. KINGDOM HEARTS official artwork, trailers, characters, merchandise, and music is copyrighted to Square Enix and Disney.
Original material is licensed under a Creative Commons License permitting non-commercial sharing with attribution.
Please read our privacy policy for more information | Legal Information