I've had this idea for a while, and now the English BBS is out, I wanted to bring it up again. (Prepare for cheese. This is why I don't write much fanfiction, guys.)
Most of this crap is from the Xehanort reports, and from Grandma's Story, which it would help to read if you haven't already. Bear with me...
Once upon a time, there was only one World in which people lived; the Realm of Light. The Realm of Light had a giant and powerful core of light, from which all people's hearts were born and where the heart went to sleep after death. Keyblades were created as counterparts to this core of light, which I will call KH1.
However, people realised that if they controlled KH1, then they would have control over all living creatures. And so they fought over it, and a Keyblade War began, which led to darkness opening up in hearts for the very first time in history.
Darkness and Light are eternal, and one cannot exist without the other (no light without shadow), and a Realm of Darkness had existed side-by-side with the Realm of Light forever.
But now, using the darkness in people's hearts as a doorway, darkness flowed out from the Realm of Darkness, into the Realm of Light. It devoured the giant heart, KH1, just as in the future creatures of darkness would devour human hearts.
After this, there was nothing left of the Realm of Light, save for some tiny pieces of light floating in the darkness. Some people (children? Keyblade Wielders?) collected that light up, and used it to rebuild the realm. However, there was not enough power. Without the power (gravity?) of the giant KH1, they could not rebuild their entire realm as it was. Instead, they had to make smaller worlds, using the pieces of light they had saved as new cores. Instead of the entire realm sharing one heart, now every world had its own heart, protected behind a door. Barriers were set up around the worlds to protect them from the darkness, and also to prevent another Keyblade War.
But, KH1 still remained deep in the Realm of Darkness. If it were to be brought back to the Realm of Light, then all the smaller fragments of the old Realm would be brought back into one whole again. A key came into existance that could unlock the Door to Darkness upon KH1, called the Keyblade of heart. It could be created out of seven pure hearts.
KH1 was also still the place from which all hearts were born, and where all hearts were destined to sleep. This meant that every heart had to travel through the Realm of Darkness and into the Realm of Light to be born, and this meant that unlike the pure people of the old Realm who had no darkness until the War, every person in the new Ream of Light has some darkness in their heart.
However, though KH1, the original heart of the original Realm of Light is locked away inside the Realm of Darkness, 'Kingdom Hearts' is simply a term that describes an 'aggregate of hearts'.
A long time later, a group of scientists discovered a way to create a new Kingdom Hearts, which I will call a KH2. By redirecting the natural path that hearts take when returning to KH1, they managed to collect a mass amount of hearts and create an artificial KH2.
Now, I believe that the 'Kingdom Hearts' we see in Birth by Sleep is also something created through obtaining an aggregation of hearts, which I will call a KH0.
It is my interpretation that when the χ-blade is forged, a KH0 is created by bringing the small core hearts of all the worlds in the Realm of Light together. This creates an aggregation of hearts, right? And not just any aggregation of hearts; by bringing together all the cores in the Realm of Light, this aggregation would techincally be almost the same type as KH1: one core for the entire realm.
But, it is still not the same object as KH1 itself. That is still locked away in the Realm of Darkness.
edit edit: more clarification.
So, my theory is that there is a trinity of types of Kingdom Hearts, just as there is a trinity of realms (and a trinity of pretty much EVERYTHING in this damn series).
World hearts combined: KH0. Only seen in BBS.
Original core of old RoL: KH1. Only seen in KH1.
Human hearts combined: KH2. Only seen in KH2.
This explains why MX could summon the friggen thing without needing to unlock the Door to Darkness; it's a whole new 'Kingdom Hearts', built outside the Realm of Darkness.
The one little hole I see in my theory: if the fragments of light weren't enough to create a KH1 level 'Kingdom Hearts' back when they first tried to fix the realm, then why would those pieces be enough to create a 'Kingdom Hearts' in the time of BBS?
edit: this is why I thought they weren't strong enough:
Maybe they grew in power over time...?
Also, MX implies in his reports that the barriers between each world are there mainly to stop the inhabitants from meeting and setting off another Keyblade War. So perhaps now, someone with the power could break down the barriers and join the realms, but that would
a) put everyone at risk from the Darkness that's all around (see what happened when Ansem SoD tried something similar)
b) make people aware of light and hearts again, and maybe cause another War.
c) seeing as hearts are still born from KH1, then people would have darkness in their hearts anyway, which is dangerous
So, perhaps KH1 is needed to banish the Darkness into its own Realm for good, eliminating the need for the gummi barriers. And, KH1 needs to be back inside the Realm of Light so that newborn hearts don't get tainted anymore.
tl;dr the Kingdom Hearts in BBS is NOT the same as the Kingdom Hearts we hear about in KH1.
Imo, anyway. Am I completely wrong here? Tell me!!
edit: keyblade graveyard is in the realm of in-between, not the realm of light, lol.
But I think even without the cute correlation the theory stands...
Most of this crap is from the Xehanort reports, and from Grandma's Story, which it would help to read if you haven't already. Bear with me...
Once upon a time, there was only one World in which people lived; the Realm of Light. The Realm of Light had a giant and powerful core of light, from which all people's hearts were born and where the heart went to sleep after death. Keyblades were created as counterparts to this core of light, which I will call KH1.
However, people realised that if they controlled KH1, then they would have control over all living creatures. And so they fought over it, and a Keyblade War began, which led to darkness opening up in hearts for the very first time in history.
Darkness and Light are eternal, and one cannot exist without the other (no light without shadow), and a Realm of Darkness had existed side-by-side with the Realm of Light forever.
But now, using the darkness in people's hearts as a doorway, darkness flowed out from the Realm of Darkness, into the Realm of Light. It devoured the giant heart, KH1, just as in the future creatures of darkness would devour human hearts.
After this, there was nothing left of the Realm of Light, save for some tiny pieces of light floating in the darkness. Some people (children? Keyblade Wielders?) collected that light up, and used it to rebuild the realm. However, there was not enough power. Without the power (gravity?) of the giant KH1, they could not rebuild their entire realm as it was. Instead, they had to make smaller worlds, using the pieces of light they had saved as new cores. Instead of the entire realm sharing one heart, now every world had its own heart, protected behind a door. Barriers were set up around the worlds to protect them from the darkness, and also to prevent another Keyblade War.
But, KH1 still remained deep in the Realm of Darkness. If it were to be brought back to the Realm of Light, then all the smaller fragments of the old Realm would be brought back into one whole again. A key came into existance that could unlock the Door to Darkness upon KH1, called the Keyblade of heart. It could be created out of seven pure hearts.
KH1 was also still the place from which all hearts were born, and where all hearts were destined to sleep. This meant that every heart had to travel through the Realm of Darkness and into the Realm of Light to be born, and this meant that unlike the pure people of the old Realm who had no darkness until the War, every person in the new Ream of Light has some darkness in their heart.
However, though KH1, the original heart of the original Realm of Light is locked away inside the Realm of Darkness, 'Kingdom Hearts' is simply a term that describes an 'aggregate of hearts'.
A long time later, a group of scientists discovered a way to create a new Kingdom Hearts, which I will call a KH2. By redirecting the natural path that hearts take when returning to KH1, they managed to collect a mass amount of hearts and create an artificial KH2.
Now, I believe that the 'Kingdom Hearts' we see in Birth by Sleep is also something created through obtaining an aggregation of hearts, which I will call a KH0.
Kingdom Hearts could be described as an aggregate of hearts. Worlds, too, have hearts, just like people; each world's heart is concealed from sight, beyond a hidden door. By gathering all the hearts of all the worlds in a single place, one may complete Kingdom Hearts.
At the time of its forging, Kingdom Hearts appears. It must be noted, though, that this Kingdom Hearts is special. Unlike the Kingdoms brought about forcibly and artificially through the collection of hearts, THIS Kingdom Hearts is a perfect and complete union of ALL the worlds' hearts. Surely it was over this that the ancient Keyblade War was fought.
If so, the walls that divide the worlds today are of little consequence. With the χ-blade, all their hearts could be instantly reunited--and the Keyblade War, refought.
It is my interpretation that when the χ-blade is forged, a KH0 is created by bringing the small core hearts of all the worlds in the Realm of Light together. This creates an aggregation of hearts, right? And not just any aggregation of hearts; by bringing together all the cores in the Realm of Light, this aggregation would techincally be almost the same type as KH1: one core for the entire realm.
But, it is still not the same object as KH1 itself. That is still locked away in the Realm of Darkness.
edit edit: more clarification.
When he says
THIS Kingdom Hearts is a perfect and complete union of ALL the worlds' hearts. Surely it was over this that the ancient Keyblade War was fought.
I take it to mean that 'a perfect and complete union of all the world's hearts' is what they fought over, rather than something artificially made from human hearts. What fits that better than KH1? It WAS the perfect and complete core of all the realm.
KH0 is just like it, only created in a different way.
Spoiler Show
![]()
So, my theory is that there is a trinity of types of Kingdom Hearts, just as there is a trinity of realms (and a trinity of pretty much EVERYTHING in this damn series).
World hearts combined: KH0. Only seen in BBS.
Original core of old RoL: KH1. Only seen in KH1.
Human hearts combined: KH2. Only seen in KH2.
This explains why MX could summon the friggen thing without needing to unlock the Door to Darkness; it's a whole new 'Kingdom Hearts', built outside the Realm of Darkness.
The one little hole I see in my theory: if the fragments of light weren't enough to create a KH1 level 'Kingdom Hearts' back when they first tried to fix the realm, then why would those pieces be enough to create a 'Kingdom Hearts' in the time of BBS?
edit: this is why I thought they weren't strong enough:
Well, a while ago I translated Kairi's Grandma's story from BBS literally, and it said:
But, because the true light was still sleeping deep inside the darkness, the world couldn't be joined as one, and had to be split into many small worlds.
I assumed that this meant, without the true light, they didn't have the power to put all the worlds as one.
However, the English localisation of that line is simply
But the true light sleeps, deep within the darkness. That's why the worlds are still scattered, divided from each other.
So... who knows...
Maybe they grew in power over time...?
Also, MX implies in his reports that the barriers between each world are there mainly to stop the inhabitants from meeting and setting off another Keyblade War. So perhaps now, someone with the power could break down the barriers and join the realms, but that would
a) put everyone at risk from the Darkness that's all around (see what happened when Ansem SoD tried something similar)
b) make people aware of light and hearts again, and maybe cause another War.
c) seeing as hearts are still born from KH1, then people would have darkness in their hearts anyway, which is dangerous
So, perhaps KH1 is needed to banish the Darkness into its own Realm for good, eliminating the need for the gummi barriers. And, KH1 needs to be back inside the Realm of Light so that newborn hearts don't get tainted anymore.
tl;dr the Kingdom Hearts in BBS is NOT the same as the Kingdom Hearts we hear about in KH1.
Imo, anyway. Am I completely wrong here? Tell me!!
edit: keyblade graveyard is in the realm of in-between, not the realm of light, lol.
But I think even without the cute correlation the theory stands...
Last edited: