DarrcEnigma said:
Problem is, they have absolutely no proof to back up their claims. There also happens to be immeasurable proof against it.
A lot of the things you list as "proof" aren't really proof, but opinions. Just because you claim that "Naminé isn't dark; nor is Kairi" doesn't make it true, since you don't have evidence to back that up either, other then your own opinion, which is as perfectly valid as other people's opinions regarding the true nature of Naminé.
You say that:
DarrcEnigma said:
Riku and the BFU are one and the same (Watch ending scene from R/R)."
But is this really the case? At the end of R/R we see Riku and Mickey dressed in Organization garb (which was also shown in the footage of COM shown at the Tokyo Game Show, I believe), but Riku's not blindfolded, which means that he could potentially be the Blindfolded Unknown, or he could be another one of the unknowns in Deep Dive. Granted, the Dual-Wielding Unknown is in all likelihood the BHK, since we have game-footage of KH2 with the BHK wielding two keyblades, but that still leaves two other Unknowns that could be Riku. I'm not saying I disagree with you, because I do in fact believe that Riku is the BFU, but the "proof" you claim to have is not really proof at all, just a strong hunch, since all we know is that Riku is one of the Unknowns in Deep Dive, and nothing else...
Another point you bring up:
DarrcEnigma said:
"They didn't say Naminé was Kairi's shadow, they just said she was shadowing Sora's memory of Kairi."
.This is also not true. In one scene of Chain of Memories Naminé refers to herself as Kairi's shadow, in so many words. I don't think that anyone ever says that Naminé was "shadowing Sora's memory" (as far as I recall; if I'm mistaken someone please correct me and say when this takes place), so I have no reason to believe that over the possibility of Naminé actually being somehow connected to Kairi.
As a final point to mention, you say:
DarrcEnigma said:
"Sora and BHK don't look identical, and therefore aren't the same person; Kairi and Naminé don't look identical, and therefore aren't the same person."
What are you basing this on? How do you know that someone's shell, to use the term used by the Unknown in Final Mix, is physically identical to the original person, or that the fact that they are more dark/light then the original altered their looks somehow? They look enough alike (BHK --> Sora, Naminé --> Kairi) to leave this whole issue very ambiguous and impossible to resolve without more information.
I think it's pretty useless to flat-out DENY a possibility when a case can be made for it, even if it's not as strong as we'd like, and your "evidence" to prove the contrary really isn't evidence at all...