I will admit that as I read this my mind might keep biasing itself because of my beliefs in the Terra = Xehanort = Xemnas.
The frist quote I don't understand, but I can see what you mean by the second one, though it could just be out of context; meaning that he misjudged Sora as a fighter and thought he would defeat him easily.
I feel as though that what you're saying about apearance could just as easily be said about Xemnas, who looks much more like Xehanort and Terra. And to be picky, Aqua and Saix have different shades of color, meh.
I'm seeing assumptions here. Obiovusly something big happened with the KH during that BBS scene, but we really don't know that Terra has so much darkness in his heart. MX most likely does though, but "hate" seems to get thrown around a lot, since Terra probably doesn't know MX personaly and his fighting him for his master. The only evidence we have os his darkness is his eyes turning orange, which means he could have been just using darkness rather than having it.
And that last part is just out of nowhere and really isn't how KH works.
Pretty much one big assumption, but an excusable one considering the theory's basis.
Wait, so. Terra lives past BBS to be turned into a Heartless by XH? I'm just seeing plotholes there. Of course he would become a Heartless, to have a Nobody, Saix in this case, but this would mean that Terra's Heartless would be a sentient Heartless, much like XH, who was the first of his kind. Also, killing a random Nobody seems to be something not normally on XH's agenda.
Eh, assuming.
I ust don't like this because I think it assumes too much of the mentality of the character, and I'm still not sure why Saix would want to kill Xemnas in the first place. Stopping his goals? Saix, a legendary Keyblade wielder wanting some form of revenge, would probably want to become whole again thanks to Xemnas.
I just felt like this was a theory that could use debating, my apologies if it went too far or anything. Hope it was a good read for you, but I just saw some hole that I wanted to point out.
It starts off with this. I think Saix is Terra’s Nobody. At first it may sound like bullcrap, but listen to one of Saix’s battle quotes, “All shall be lost to you!” and “I misjudged you.” Terra also lost everything, going off of BBS. Terra also chose Riku to wield a Keyblade.
The frist quote I don't understand, but I can see what you mean by the second one, though it could just be out of context; meaning that he misjudged Sora as a fighter and thought he would defeat him easily.
There are also similarities in there fighting styles that are both based on strength. They also have similar appearance, but yet again it could be laziness from Nomura. That would be what I would say, if his hair wasn’t blue. That could be because of memories from Aqua, because memories greatly affect a Nobody. Also, take in mind that Saix is also a Berserker Nobody. This fits Terra’s hatred for MX.
I feel as though that what you're saying about apearance could just as easily be said about Xemnas, who looks much more like Xehanort and Terra. And to be picky, Aqua and Saix have different shades of color, meh.
Next is how Xehanort was formed. We all know something dramatic happened when the blue Kingdom Hearts hit. First, we know that Terra has an immense amount of darkness in his heart. MX also has lots of darkness in his heart. Therefore I believe that because they have such strong hate for each other, the blue Kingdom Hearts took darkness from both Terra and MX to make a heart, body, and soul that would become Xehanort.
I'm seeing assumptions here. Obiovusly something big happened with the KH during that BBS scene, but we really don't know that Terra has so much darkness in his heart. MX most likely does though, but "hate" seems to get thrown around a lot, since Terra probably doesn't know MX personaly and his fighting him for his master. The only evidence we have os his darkness is his eyes turning orange, which means he could have been just using darkness rather than having it.
And that last part is just out of nowhere and really isn't how KH works.
There are also several holes in this theory, but I can explain them. The first flaw is the name. If Saix was truly Terra’s Nobody, he would have to be Terra scrambled with an X. This can be explained by Terra feeling regret from what he has done in BBS. He becomes so guilty that he changes his name to “Isa” which stands for Moon. This name was chosen because of the blue Kingdom Hearts that personified his darkness
Pretty much one big assumption, but an excusable one considering the theory's basis.
Next is why Saix is so loyal to Xemnas? First, I will say that Terra did eventually become a Heartless. Yet, I think that was XH’s doing so he can have protection. I would say that XH would try to kill Terra after he got his heartless, but Xemnas would have interfered. Therefore, Terra would be grateful in the eyes of Xemnas, get the name Saix, and try to earn second in command to make sure Xemnas doesn’t complete his goal.
Wait, so. Terra lives past BBS to be turned into a Heartless by XH? I'm just seeing plotholes there. Of course he would become a Heartless, to have a Nobody, Saix in this case, but this would mean that Terra's Heartless would be a sentient Heartless, much like XH, who was the first of his kind. Also, killing a random Nobody seems to be something not normally on XH's agenda.
Next is the fact that Saix doesn’t have a keyblade. That’s because Terra gave into darkness.
Eh, assuming.
Last, why does Saix seem willing to kill Sora, and why doesn’t Saix treat Roxas like Ven? Well the Sora thing is too obvious. Saix wants to kill Xemnas himself, not Sora. Also, Sora has his Keyblade. The Roxas thing is sort of not so obvious. Yet, it is simple. Roxas is not Ven. Saix surely knows that, so he doesn’t befriend Roxas. Also, would you want to see someone who reminds you of a friend who is probably dead? I don’t think so. It also doesn’t help that Roxas is Sora’s Nobody.
I ust don't like this because I think it assumes too much of the mentality of the character, and I'm still not sure why Saix would want to kill Xemnas in the first place. Stopping his goals? Saix, a legendary Keyblade wielder wanting some form of revenge, would probably want to become whole again thanks to Xemnas.
I just felt like this was a theory that could use debating, my apologies if it went too far or anything. Hope it was a good read for you, but I just saw some hole that I wanted to point out.