People say the truth will set you free.
REGISTER TO REMOVE ADS |
"You were never supposed to exist, Roxas."
And even though he was the one who needed her, I love how when she's talking about her dilemma with her powers, he feels bad that he can't help her figure it out. The way she smiles, you can tell she thinks it's cute because she wasn't really asking him to help her, but it's nice to know that he cares.
There's a RokuNami HC now? *sigh* Can't say I'm not surprised.
Yaaay! Another minion for the Magical Pony Overlord! CBI actually decided to give it a try after I saw that it was so highly recommended on TV Tropes and available on YouTube, and WHOA I DID NOT EXPECT IT TO BE THAT GOOD! O_O
Anyways, guess what, Neo? You inspired me. I am now working on a fanfic that involves Roxas, Namine, and MAGICAL PONIES! (It's not an MLP crossover though.)
Y'know what's even worse? When you're in the mood to write... but you can't tear your eyes off the fascinating internet thing you're reading because it's so very sparkly...YES! It drives me crazy sometimes, but I think it happens to most writers. You write whatever you're in the mood to write, and since I love so many different pairings, I guess it makes sense that I would rotate on which ones I enjoy the most at certain times.
Reminds me of the infamous SoRiku reunion scene from KH2... which makes me think, don't fans have a tendency to take things that support their views and well... twist them around? And even if you're not twisting what actually happened, you're still biased to look at it one way or another.I never saw anything wrong with that line in the first place anyway. It's just one of those lame attempts to make a sentence look worse than it is just to make said pairing appear negative. When I first witnessed the scene, all I saw was Naminé being genuinely honest. Not to hurt him, but to, like you said, answer his question the way she interpreted it to be. Especially since she doesn't think much of herself in terms of a Nobody either. Her tone, her looks, her movements. There was absolutely no ill will. She obviously didn't think it was going to be taken the wrong way. Is anything tactless "evil" now? I come to KHI, and now there's this whole thing that it's such a horrible thing to say OMG and that she doesn't care about him, and whatnot. I'm like...really?
I'll say, especially with them smiling at each other at the end of the game. <3Not that it matters, considering both didn't blow it out of proportion, if at all. They just kept talking, thought nothing of it, and still became good companions. If it doesn't affect the characters or their opinions about each other, hell I care what others think. They weren't the two in the conversation. And, apparently, it ended well.
*tries to read Japanese subtitles*
LOL. There is? I wonder who opened it.
...
...please tell me I'm at least a little bit off on who I think it is before I check...
EDIT: FACK IT xD.
I'm surprised it took so long. But hey, we've got the Rion HC. And it's....RIGHT.
And even though he was the one who needed her, I love how when she's talking about her dilemma with her powers, he feels bad that he can't help her figure it out. The way she smiles, you can tell she thinks it's cute because she wasn't really asking him to help her, but it's nice to know that he cares.
Agreed. If anything, it sounded like she thought she was helping him. She tells Roxas what he needs to hear, not what she thinks he wants to hear. And judging from his attitude in Days and KH2, that's really what he wanted, even if the truth hurt.
I never saw anything wrong with that line in the first place anyway. It's just one of those lame attempts to make a sentence look worse than it is just to make said pairing appear negative.
When I first witnessed the scene, all I saw was Naminé being genuinely honest. Not to hurt him, but to, like you said, answer his question the way she interpreted it to be. Especially since she doesn't think much of herself in terms of a Nobody either. Her tone, her looks, her movements. There was absolutely no ill will. She obviously didn't think it was going to be taken the wrong way. Is anything tactless "evil" now? I come to KHI, and now there's this whole thing that it's such a horrible thing to say OMG and that she doesn't care about him, and whatnot. I'm like...really?
I expected better.
Not that it matters, considering both didn't blow it out of proportion, if at all. They just kept talking, thought nothing of it, and still became good companions. If it doesn't affect the characters or their opinions about each other, hell I care what others think. They weren't the two in the conversation. And, apparently, it ended well.
LOL. There is? I wonder who opened it.
...
...please tell me I'm at least a little bit off on who I think it is before I check...
EDIT: FACK IT xD.
okay, while i know how much of a bad idea this is, i'm just gonna bite
what makes it so BAD to have differing opinions over pairings? :v
what is it about not sharing the same opinion over couples that automatically turns clubs into mortal enemies?
I don't think she meant it like that, Rali. ^^;
Personally, I'm fine with differing opinions. I do admit that the re-opening of the SoKai CC worries me, though. Not because it implies dislike to the pairing, but rather that animosity will arise between the CC and the FC. When I re-opened the FC, the CC was created not long after in a form of retaliation (as the owner admitted to me after the club's opening), and it sparked a few arguments that ended in a warning or two. I just hope that doesn't happen again; I'd like it if everyone involved (both in the FCs and the CCs) can and will respect each others difference of opinion this time around. I'm glad, Rali, that you're one of the people who can do just that. =)
I said this in the CC and I'll say it again here; I personally would be happy if the CC and the FC made an alliance, but IDK where Smile stands on that matter. Remember; I initially made the CC as a HC and turned it into the CC once I realized I liked SoKai again. The Critic Club is neutral ground for haters and lovers to meet and realize the positives and negatives of the pairing and try to agree on ways to improve the pairing.
There's one thing I don't get though: WHY do we need a Critic Club to criticize? Criticism is not a bad thing, it doesn't mean you're any less of a fan. So why can't we just criticize the couple in the FC? D: I'd like to believe that most of the FC members are not part of the fandumb and can admit that there are flaws in the couple we love. And haters can also come to the FC and criticize with us, so long as they're respectful about it; debates are in and of themselves are not hateful, not like arguments. Hell, Kairi HCers used to do that all the time at the Kairi FC.
I don't think she meant it like that, Rali. ^^;
Personally, I'm fine with differing opinions. I do admit that the re-opening of the SoKai CC worries me, though. Not because it implies dislike to the pairing, but rather that animosity will arise between the CC and the FC. When I re-opened the FC, the CC was created not long after in a form of retaliation (as the owner admitted to me after the club's opening), and it sparked a few arguments that ended in a warning or two.
I just hope that doesn't happen again; I'd like it if everyone involved (both in the FCs and the CCs) can and will respect each others difference of opinion this time around. I'm glad, Rali, that you're one of the people who can do just that. =)
okay, while i know how much of a bad idea this is, i'm just gonna bite
what makes it so BAD to have differing opinions over pairings? :v
what is it about not sharing the same opinion over couples that automatically turns clubs into mortal enemies?
Is anything tactless "evil" now?
Not that it matters, considering both didn't blow it out of proportion, if at all. They just kept talking, thought nothing of it, and still became good companions. If it doesn't affect the characters or their opinions about each other, hell I care what others think. They weren't the two in the conversation. And, apparently, it ended well.
Yaaay! Another minion for the Magical Pony Overlord! CB
Spoiler ShowBasically, it takes place in an alternate universe. Five-year-old Roxas is playing with Namine and she suggests that they pretend to be "Magical Ponies." But the fun and games comes to a screeching halt when their antics annoy his big brother, Axel, too much, and he tells them that boys who pretend to be ponies always end up turning into ponies themselves. Cue Roxas and Namine freaking out as they try to figure out how to "save" Roxas from his doomed fate...
Y'know what's even worse? When you're in the mood to write... but you can't tear your eyes off the fascinating internet thing you're reading because it's so very sparkly...
Reminds me of the infamous SoRiku reunion scene from KH2... which makes me think, don't fans have a tendency to take things that support their views and well... twist them around? And even if you're not twisting what actually happened, you're still biased to look at it one way or another.
That surprised me, too. xD I doubt it'll stay active; most couple HCs usually become inactive quickly.
Oh, I know. <3 You can practically hear her silent 'thank you'.
I also love how her helping him was her choice. Some haters believe Namine only helped him to manipulate him to go back to Sora (despite the fact that this act would be the complete opposite of her character; Namine wouldn't want to manipulate someone again, not after how it affected Sora when she did it to him - to believe that she would do it again makes her seem like the Sora-obsessed bitch people claim Kairi to be), but DiZ already had that covered, so manipulation on Namine's part would be completely unnecessary. Yet, despite that fact, Namine even went against DiZ to help Roxas. Why would she do that if she didn't care about him?
The Hunger Games said:I don't care. I'm sick of people lying to me for my own good. Because really it's mostly for their own good.
I wasn't trying to make my comment sound like that. Not at all. I just saw the reasons in the HC and wanted to talk about why I disagreed with the one that keeps getting brought up the most, about how Namine told Roxas he was never meant to exist. But I didn't want to invade the HC with cries of, "YOU'RE WRONG! YOU'RE WRONG!" and ruin their fun, so I thought it would be better to just come here instead to explain how I felt about that exchange between Roxas and Namine. I hope I didn't offend you in any way!
Spoiler Show
Because no one ever really criticizes in the FCs. xD And HCers going to FCers territory and vice-versa can be a bit unfair at times, as it's a smaller visiting group approaching the entirety of the opposing views. It'd be easy to be overwhelmed in such encounters and end up being offensive about it.
So the CC is neutral ground where both ends of the spectrum can have their say without having to feel overwhelmed, and it'd be easier to keep in check with behaviors (let's be honest here folks; bias can blind us on our friends' and our own behaviors).
tbh, i wasn't referring to her when i first said that :c
see, now i can understand why you'd be apprehensive about something like that, and that's a completely valid point
honestly i'd prefer it if there weren't any arguments either~
really now, squabbling over things like that is completely unnecessary and childish
and i'm glad that you are as well C:
Spoiler ShowBasically, it takes place in an alternate universe. Five-year-old Roxas is playing with Namine and she suggests that they pretend to be "Magical Ponies." But the fun and games comes to a screeching halt when their antics annoy his big brother, Axel, too much, and he tells them that boys who pretend to be ponies always end up turning into ponies themselves. Cue Roxas and Namine freaking out as they try to figure out how to "save" Roxas from his doomed fate...
I wonder why that is? I guess it actually goes back to the "no pairings are canon" rule; since they're not likely to happen (unlike, say, Xion's possible return or Kairi getting a Keyblade), people can simply speak their minds and then move on to other things.
It's such a sweet scene! :3 <3<3
You hit the nail on the head. You know, Roxas' plight reminds me of a moment in the third book of The Hunger Games, when the protagonist, Katniss gets angry at one of her best friends for hiding something from her. I won't say anymore in case anyone here hasn't read it yet (though you really should; they're excellent books), but this quote in particular reminded me of Roxas:
The Hunger Games said:I don't care. I'm sick of people lying to me for my own good. Because really it's mostly for their own good.
That's more or less what happens to Roxas, even from people who really do care about him, like Axel and Xion. So, IMO, Namine's probably the best fit for him, because she doesn't just care about him, she understands and respects him as a person who can take care of himself and who doesn't want or deserve pampering.
the biggest thing that gets me, that i'm probably going to offend people over, is the fact that it doesn't seem like there's any real hostility behind the idea of the club, whatever it may be but that the hostility is behind the person who MADE the club
it really feels as though sometimes, the only reason conflict rises up between clubs is because of past hostilities and arguments and honestly, i don't think that's fair
joinage? love this pairing (OTP of KH lol)
SoKai, however, seems to be a hot topic in KH drama (actually, just about anything regarding Kairi, period, is a hot topic in KH drama), so I am a little concerned about that.