I wasn't crazy surprised, though; season two was arguably underwhelming and it's only gotten worse (and more convoluted) since. A few really good moments doesn't sell a show, unfortunately, no matter the potential. :C
And can I just say that I think Tara herself is kind of a shitty character? When she said she was tired of being the least interesting personality, I couldn't help but think "No; just the most annoying." I swear she made some of the most arbitrary bonking decisions this season.
I'm pretty much in love with everyone else, though (including the alters, but excluding Bryce, who is stupid; and Moosh's annoying new boyfriend just doesn't count).