IF: Kingdom Hearts Brawl??

[xhavenx]

Sorry if this subject has came up but it would be really interesting to see kingdom hearts characters in a super smash brothers kind of game. I know dissidia is the closest thing but i got really disapointed when it was only FF characters and kingdom hearts was left out. I know in an interview Nomura said the idea of Dissidia was originally for Kingdom hearts but he didnt think Disney would like Disney characters fighting each other [lame]. but wouldnt it be really cool if kingdom hears had a game like that??
[again sorry if this is a repost or something]

 

[X-Face]

Oooh, I would LOVE that! But in that case: completely leave out the story, it'll only screw up the canonical side.
A battle between Saïx and Maleficent. I'd die happy.

 

[Shadow Soldier]

No. No it would not be cool. It'd be terrible. Very terrible. So terrible it's terrible.

 

[Noir]

You know what? I just might cry now.

 

[qster]

Trust me, it may seem like a good idea, but it can easily be screwed up. Some things to think about would be:
Storyline
Okay, we can't expect Sora meeting up with Terra, Aqua, or Ven, because it would screw up the timeline.
Characters
How many and what characters should be added? I personally wouldn't want Shadows or minor Heartless/Nobodies/ Unbirths as playable characters. Plus, it would be a supreme pain trying to balance them out, especially Master Xehanhort, Terra, Aqua, Ven, and others.
Gameplay
Which would be better, a side scroller type like SSBB, or the average KH 3-D battles? Would they use health bars or adopt the SSBB percent style of health, the higher the worst. Would we use the Command menu in the traditional KH games, or reuse the CoM setup? This is very important and must be thought through PERFECTLY AND PRECISELY.
Stages
What areas can we fight in, which is also affected by characters and gameplay.
Items
If any, what items would be incorporated and used? What do they do and how can they be used to your advantage?

 

[Pinwheel]

but i got really disapointed when it was only FF characters and kingdom hearts was left out.

If I could,
I'd fill your asshole with concrete for saying such a thing.

 

[Orion]

If it could be done well, I'd like it.

But you know what? It wouldn't be done well.

 

[Teiku 5]

wow, qster. you make a good argument there.

If it could be done well, I'd like it.

But you know what? It wouldn't be done well.

pretty much.

 

[XIII Heartless]

No. Just no. The closest this would get to working would've been to include Sora in Dissidia on the side of light and Riku on the dark side. That is it. I do not want to play as a Disney character (except maybe Mickey). I didn't even like including Goofy and Donald in 358/2 Days.

 

[Crimson Jazz]

I'm pretty sure a Dissidia-like game is possible, but I don't want it to happen.

It would honestly ruin the entire series for me, especially if they gave it a storyline.

 

[Wehrmacht]

I know dissidia is the closest thing but i got really disapointed when it was only FF characters and kingdom hearts was left out.

Um, you were aware that Dissidia was made to celebrate 20 years of FINAL FANTASY, and that as such Kingdom Hearts characters had no place in it whatsoever, hence expecting them to be in it was foolish, and if they were in it'd be a disgrace, right?

 

[Crimson Jazz]

I know dissidia is the closest thing but i got really disapointed when it was only FF characters and kingdom hearts was left out.

Because Kingdom Hearts and Final Fantasy are in two totally different universes.