Axel & Roxas - Nobodies with hearts?

[Zeffphyr]

Well, I know that nobodies aren´t supposed to have hearts but I think that there really could be some exceptions.

There´s a scene in KH2FM+ after you defeat Roxas in TWTNW where Axel and Roxas are sitting at
the top of the Station Tower in TT talking about when they first met (the subject of having aheart also comes up). At the end of the scene, Roxas is fading away as he is rejoining with Sora. As Roxas says goodbye, Axel says "See ya....Partner" as he sheds a single tear.

Here´s a link to the vid
YouTube - Axel and Roxas Scene Translated

It´s kinda hard to see the tear on Axel´s face with all the light coming from Roxas.
But in the actual video in the game it´s clearly shown if anyone remembers.

I´d like to see what people think of this. Please post your thoughts.

(btw, sorry if this has already been posted)

 

[Orion]

sorry if this has already been posted)

What? Sorry about this being posted before? How could that possibly be? I've never even heard of the concept of Axel and Roxas having Heart up until I read this revelation!

 

[Zeffphyr]

What? Sorry about this being posted before? How could that possibly be? I've never even heard of the concept of Axel and Roxas having Heart up until I read this revelation!

lol, figures. I just haven´t been on in literally about a year so I´ve probably missed a lot

EDIT: even though its been posted before wut do you think?

 

[Jesus]

lol, figures. I just haven´t been on in literally about a year so I´ve probably missed a lot

EDIT: even though its been posted before wut do you think?

woah you dude, you got killed by sarcasm
anyways axel & roxas = too cool to NOT have hearts

 

[Zeffphyr]

woah you dude, you got killed by sarcasm
anyways axel & roxas = too cool to NOT have hearts

yeah, I´m kinda getting used to it with Infinity and Grace Assassin around lol.

 

[Jesus]

lol, figures. I just haven´t been on in literally about a year so I´ve probably missed a lot

EDIT: even though its been posted before wut do you think?

ITS BEEN POSTED BE4? (sarcasm)

yeah, I´m kinda getting used to it with Infinity and Grace Assassin around lol.

yes, it seems they lack hearts as well, but are still human (it boggles the mind)

 

[Orion]

ITS BEEN POSTED BE4? (sarcasm)


yes, it seems they lack hearts as well, but are still human (it boggles the mind)

I'm apathetic as all hell, so that's certainly a trait I share with humanoid Nobodies.

 

[Zeffphyr]

I'm apathetic as all hell, so that's certainly a trait I share with humanoid Nobodies.

Ah yes, I´ve noticed lol

 

[Jesus]

I'm apathetic as all hell, so that's certainly a trait I share with humanoid Nobodies.

yes i would say you evil like xemnas except more so

 

[Orion]

I suppose it's about time I stated my opinion on this matter.

First and foremost, I don't think they have Hearts. They wouldn't be Nobodies without them. It's simply impossible. And so far, every 'true' member of Organization XIII has been a Nobody, no questions asked. For a time, I suppose it could be said, Sora wasn't making use of his emotions or his ability to wield, and so Roxas gained those things. In all honesty I'm not quite sure.

 

[Jesus]

I suppose it's about time I stated my opinion on this matter.

First and foremost, I don't think they have Hearts. They wouldn't be Nobodies without them. It's simply impossible. And so far, every 'true' member of Organization XIII has been a Nobody, no questions asked. For a time, I suppose it could be said, Sora wasn't making use of his emotions or his ability to wield, and so Roxas gained those things. In all honesty I'm not quite sure.

time to be serious

i beleive that the transfer of memories from sora to roxas gave him the IMPRESSION of feelings which then sprouted into axel
but in the name of infinity:"in all honesty im not quite sure"

 

[Zeffphyr]

I suppose it's about time I stated my opinion on this matter.

First and foremost, I don't think they have Hearts. They wouldn't be Nobodies without them. It's simply impossible. And so far, every 'true' member of Organization XIII has been a Nobody, no questions asked. For a time, I suppose it could be said, Sora wasn't making use of his emotions or his ability to wield, and so Roxas gained those things. In all honesty I'm not quite sure.

Well, we cant deny the fact that a tear shows emotion although some people can force themselves to cry but I doubt any of the writers/developers would be assholey enough to do that lol.

 

[UnstoppableSound]

Well, I know that nobodies aren´t supposed to have hearts but I think that there really could be some exceptions.

There´s a scene in KH2FM+ after you defeat Roxas in TWTNW where Axel and Roxas are sitting at
the top of the Station Tower in TT talking about when they first met (the subject of having aheart also comes up). At the end of the scene, Roxas is fading away as he is rejoining with Sora. As Roxas says goodbye, Axel says "See ya....Partner" as he sheds a single tear.

Here´s a link to the vid
YouTube - Axel and Roxas Scene Translated

It´s kinda hard to see the tear on Axel´s face with all the light coming from Roxas.
But in the actual video in the game it´s clearly shown if anyone remembers.

I´d like to see what people think of this. Please post your thoughts.

(btw, sorry if this has already been posted)

I thought Roxas joined with Sora at the end of the Kingdom Hearts II prelude? Isn't that just a flash back from when Roxas was leaving Axel to go find Sora?

 

[Zeffphyr]

I thought Roxas joined with Sora at the end of the Kingdom Hearts II prelude? Isn't that just a flash back from when Roxas was leaving Axel to go find Sora?

I guess so but thats not the point really.

 

[Jesus]

the point is i think im right and everyone else is wrong (in this subject)

 

[Zeffphyr]

the point is i think im right and everyone else is wrong (in this subject)

thats not egotistical at all

 

[Jesus]

thats not egotistical at all

i know im so selfless

 

[Orion]

thats not egotistical at all

It's also very human.

 

[Jesus]

It's also very human.

indeed! funny how this is still up when the questions been answered......
okay modman, do your thing

 

[Zeffphyr]

It's also very human.

Alas, we are flawed beings. Doomed to destroy ouselves
because of our utterly irrational and destructive behavior