Naught's Reminiscence?

[XIII's follower]

Hey, everyone

I have a question:

If a person becomes a Nobody, but regains their heart and becomes whole again, do they remember their time as a Nobody? Do they remember what they did and/or what happened to them when they were a Nobody?

What do you all think? Or does anyone know?

 

[Audo]

We can't say for sure. Technically, Roxas was a Nobody, and he got his heart back by fusing with Sora. We've seen that Roxas remembers everything. Yet Sora is clueless about Roxas. Though, one could say that Roxas and Sora didn't really fuse back until TWTNW. In that case, we don't know if Sora had access to Roxas' memories after that or not. Also given that Roxas/Sora and Kairi/Nami are extremely rare cases of Nobodies, they may not qualify either way.

In short, we don't know.

 

[Byronic Hero]

If the Terra = Xemnas theories are true, then it could have the same sort of effect. Maybe they wont remember anything at all. But we wont know for sure until we see Xehanort return in the future.

 

[Chakolat Strawberry]

I agree with Audo and Byro. Kairi was also clueless about Namine when they fused. But they're not normal so we actually don't know.

 

[Colours]

Well A person can't get there heart back if they have a nobody, they have to regain themselves
back with there original selves.

We can't say for sure. Technically, Roxas was a Nobody, and he got his heart back by fusing with Sora. We've seen that Roxas remembers everything. Yet Sora is clueless about Roxas. Though, one could say that Roxas and Sora didn't really fuse back until TWTNW. In that case, we don't know if Sora had access to Roxas' memories after that or not. Also given that Roxas/Sora and Kairi/Nami are extremely rare cases of Nobodies, they may not qualify either way.

In short, we don't know.

This.^

 

[Number XVI]

We can't say for sure. Technically, Roxas was a Nobody, and he got his heart back by fusing with Sora. We've seen that Roxas remembers everything. Yet Sora is clueless about Roxas. Though, one could say that Roxas and Sora didn't really fuse back until TWTNW. In that case, we don't know if Sora had access to Roxas' memories after that or not. Also given that Roxas/Sora and Kairi/Nami are extremely rare cases of Nobodies, they may not qualify either way. QUOTE]

That's the best explanation you're gonna get. I've no idea myself.

 

[Clowde]

We've seen Sora cry over Hayner, Pence and Ollete and yet he barely knew them. So he probably has the memories but can't access them.

 

[Reika Noko]

We've seen Sora cry over Hayner, Pence and Ollete and yet he barely knew them. So he probably has the memories but can't access them.

No, that was merely Roxas influencing Sora due to Roxas' memories. So Sora only acted that way subconsciously because of Roxas.

 

[Angel]

Like Audo said, Roxas is a unique case.

Sora may be the only person with another side to his heart, and for all we know, the sides are seperated by a wall.

However, Roxas and Namine seem to cross this wall (and Vexen), so maybe. Sora would need to try and draw the memories from the other side, and for all we know, that could awaken Ven.