Xehanort/Master Xehanort/DS Idea

[Muse]

Still though, why can SGD see her? What makes them so special that they can see her and no one else can't? If SGD can see her then why can't TAV see DS?

Who said TAV couldn't see DS? It's quite obvious they can, otherwise they wouldn't fight against him and MX in the trailer.

 

[Pheonex]

Interesting theory, although I still stand by the idea of MX=Terra.

 

[Muse]

Interesting theory, although I still stand by the idea of MX=Terra.

I wasn't aware that that was a theory. =/

Or do you mean the MX + Terra = Xehanort theory? Which is still plausible, even if this theory originally created by BH and SA were to be true.

 

[kurokitsunefang]

Ok so basically wat is going on with Tifa is that she isnt exactly human, she is just a sorta physical manifestation of Cloud's light. If that is so, how do all of the children from midgar see her in FF7:AC? and wats more so, how wud she fight alongside Leon, Yuffie, and Cloud in the Underdrome?

 

[Memory Master]

^The Tifa from FF7:AC is not the same Tifa from KH. Do not compare the two.

 

[Muse]

Ok so basically wat is going on with Tifa is that she isnt exactly human, she is just a sorta physical manifestation of Cloud's light. If that is so, how do all of the children from midgar see her in FF7:AC? and wats more so, how wud she fight alongside Leon, Yuffie, and Cloud in the Underdrome?

Buh. She's a cameo from FFVII. That does not mean that her appearance in KH is canon or anything. KH =/= FF.

Not only that, but when you fought against Tifa, wasn't it just Tifa? As in, no one fought besides her? In that case, since SDG were the only ones able to see her, besides Cloud and Sephiroth, then that makes sense why you were able to fight against her. It doesn't make sense why you're able to see her, but hey, maybe Sora is just that special.

 

[O a t h keeper]

Actually, the 49th fight in the Hades Cup is Leon, Yuffie, Cloud, and Tifa. =o But then again, Cloud is able to fight in the battle even after disappearing in a flash of light with Sephiroth, so that makes two things about that battle that don't make sense. xD

 

[Muse]

Actually, the 49th fight in the Hades Cup is Leon, Yuffie, Cloud, and Tifa. =o But then again, Cloud is able to fight in the battle even after disappearing in a flash of light with Sephiroth, so that makes two things about that battle that don't make sense. xD

Meh, well, I don't count the Underdrome fights as canon, as well really, they have nothing to do with the plot. They're just there for fun. They're optional, just like the Sephiroth fight.

 

[zappopunk182]

well... If MX splits himself and makes DS by means of seperating his light and dark then Terra and crew would see him in bbs and maybe sometime during bbs DS and MX combine again and he retains a younger form again. and then he becomes the current Xenahort. Maybe Xemnas's hair is Silver because it shows his true age. Then after losing his Memory he decides to hunt the power of darkness

 

[Muse]

well... If MX splits himself and makes DS by means of seperating his light and dark then Terra and crew would see him in bbs and maybe sometime during bbs DS and MX combine again and he retains a younger form again. and then he becomes the current Xenahort. Maybe Xemnas's hair is Silver because it shows his true age. Then after losing his Memory he decides to hunt the power of darkness

>.> Riku has silver hair. Sephiroth has silver hair. Silver hair =/= age.

 

[zappopunk182]

to be fair rikus hair is more of a bluish silver then a grey tone

look
heres rikus

http://da.img.v4.skyrock.com/da2/kingdomheartsxiii/pics/904700600_small.jpg

heres xemnas

http://rctmkh.com/images/art/fan/xemnas.jpg

 

[Muse]

Still. Silver hair =/= age. At least, not in KH.

 

[zappopunk182]

well if you look at MX his goatee is quite the grey tone. Where as all the characters throughout the game have silver hair. The difference is small in color but huge in appearence. Riku with grey hair would be whack.
The hair isn't even the main part of my arguement.

 

[Orion]

Not to mention Xehanort's hair was very nearly white.

 

[zappopunk182]

Id say its a light grey at best. But still. What im saying is that maybe they broke apart making MX and DS and DS was a young looking Xenahort. Then maybe MX died and since we dont know exactly what would happen because hes not a heartless or a Nobody maybe DS gained physical form. And he would be absent of his memorys

 

[Muse]

Id say its a light grey at best. But still. What im saying is that maybe they broke apart making MX and DS and DS was a young looking Xenahort. Then maybe MX died and since we dont know exactly what would happen because hes not a heartless or a Nobody maybe DS gained physical form. And he would be absent of his memorys

If DS is the darkness in MX's heart, then how would he be able to retain a physical form or still be around if MX died? He would be dependent on MX's existence in order to maintain his own existence, I should think.

 

[zappopunk182]

If DS is the darkness in MX's heart, then how would he be able to retain a physical form or still be around if MX died? He would be dependent on MX's existence in order to maintain his own existence, I should think.

what i imagine is that they share an existence. Where as with cloud and Sephiroth and Tifa Tifa and sephiroth are dependent on cloud because they are his light and dark MX and DS are different because they are the physical manifestion of his two Halfs. There is No CLoud from which theyd be projected from.

id imagine the relationship is kinda like with a heartless and a nobody where they can exist without the other.

 

[3-D]

but MX and DS are not nobodies and heartless they are extremely different do not compare the two
in MX and DS situation if the heart goes so does the darkness

 

[zappopunk182]

No if the heart goes it makes a heatless and a nobody

 

[Orion]

If the person had a strong Heart when they were alive, and the Heart was taken/corrupted by Darkness.