Xion, Ven, Roxas Theories (Do they go here?)

[feetonthetable]

I've had these on my mind for a while, and now I have the urge to just publicize it. Here goes.

Some of you played 358/2 Days already, and I understand it. This is my theory from NOT playing the game. Therefore, I'm sort of pulling this from my ass.
Xion is Kairi's Nobody. What does this make Namine? Namine is Kairi's and Sora's shared Nobody (born of Kairi's heart and Sora's body, or vice versa, I haven't worked out all the kinks). In other words, Roxas is Sora, Xion is Kairi, and Namine is something in between.

As for the Ven and Roxas looking alike, Sora has some kind of sub-conscious memory of Ven (as an older brother, probably), but due to circumstances in BBS, forgot him (forgotten, but not lost). When Roxas was created, the lost memory of Ven got "passed along" to Roxas.

There, that feels a lot better. Point out any flaws, please. And tell me if you've heard those before.

 

[Raz]

I don't think a far off memory of Ven would affect Roxas' appearance. Generally, family isn't that important in KH, so I wouldn't bank on Ven being Sora's brother.

When did Kairi become a Heartless to spawn Xion? She's a PoH, with no darkness in her heart.

EDIT: Please, guys, keep spoilers in the spoiler section. Use the spoilers tags just in case.

 

[Rytackle22]

Jack I hope that wasnt a spoiler haha cause i havnt played 358/2 days yet

 

[Raz]

Please, guys, keep spoilers in the SPOILERS section. If you have any doubts, use spoiler tags!

 

[Jack32307]

Sorry my fault, haven't been here in forever.

Im just used to helping out people that are unsure about things.

Sorry again, and ill remember that.

Off trac, Just wanted to say, that was a good suggestion for your first post! And welcome to KHI

 

[geoshippo]

family= not important in kh series!

 

[Raz]

Saying that a theory is wrong, even without explaining why, just because you've beat Days is STILL spoiling.

 

[Jack32307]

Saying that a theory is wrong

Where did i say it was wrong xD.

I complemented them. Thats it.

But, im sorry again for that, and i guess it will take me some time to get used to the Forums here.

 

[Raz]

Not you, goeshippo did.

 

[Sakuraapprentice]

I've always thought that because Kairi's heart was removed (no heartless being formed cause of the Princess of Heart thing) but Namine was still formed as a special nobody... Am I wrong? And that's why Namine formed with Kairi in KH2
BUT! I like this 'shared nobody' thing you suggested... maybe that's what Xion is (I don't know but hey nice theory!)
Hmm... family has never really been talked about but I would like to see something like that!
Welcome to KHInsider! ^^

 

[Lifes.Lover]

*sigh* Since my last post was deleted, even though I did have relevant information, I suppose I'll make it again.

Xion cannot be Kairi's Nobody.

For Xion to be wholly Kairi's Nobody, she would have had to have been made from Kairi's heart leaving Kairi's body. However, that's not possible. Kairi's heart is pure. Because of this, she cannot make a Heartless. Without a Heartless, a Nobody cannot be made. Her empty shell of a body was just that- an empty shell. It was not able to form into a Nobody.

The only reason Naminé was able to be made was because Kairi's heart exited Sora's body, thus using Sora's body as her 'anchor', I suppose could be the word. Therefore, Naminé is a Nobody made through bits of Sora's body once Kairi's heart left it.

That's what makes Naminé so special, and why she is barely called a Nobody. This is also why she has control over only Sora's memories, and the memories others have of Sora.

 

[3-D]

kairi cant have a nobody all on her own, and i doubt Xion was made in the same process as Namine

and the Ven theory is pretty good except, family isnt important in KH

welcome to khi by the way :]

 

[Rytackle22]

My theory is that Xion isn't a Nobody or anything like that, but an entirely different entity. Not sure what exactly. But maybe like the 3rd thing.

Heartless=lack of heart
Nobody=Empty Shell
??(Xion?)???=Soul

Im not sure thats my 2 cents

 

[Lifes.Lover]

Heartless are not lacking in heart.

They are the heart, wrapped in darkness.

 

[Jack32307]

??(Xion?)???=Soul

Im not sure thats my 2 cents

Im pretty sure that in a interview or something it stated that if the soul is missing, then the person just dies. But im not sure, its been ages since ive read of them :23:

But i see what your getting at :lol:

 

[xDENLINx]

My theory is that Xion isn't a Nobody or anything like that, but an entirely different entity. Not sure what exactly. But maybe like the 3rd thing.

Heartless=lack of heart
Nobody=Empty Shell
??(Xion?)???=Soul

Im not sure thats my 2 cents

As Lifes.Lover pointed out, heartless do have a heart, well they ARE a heart + darkness. Nobodies are a body and soul, correct?
There's nothing left for Xion to be.. Plus a soul by itself cannot be.

Your theory about Ven could be I guess. You're saying that the reason Roxas looks like Ven is because of Sora's memory? I like it. You'll gunna have all these people like "family has no importance in kh! zomg! Blah blah..." Just prepare for that lol

 

[xDENLINx]

Oh um... I guess someone deleted the past few messages...how do i delete this post? lol

 

[Crossroads]

Oh um... I guess someone deleted the past few messages...how do i delete this post? lol

I don't think you can. It's okay.

 

[Orion]

Some of you played 358/2 Days already, and I understand it. This is my theory from NOT playing the game. Therefore, I'm sort of pulling this from my ass.
Xion is Kairi's Nobody.

It has been directly stated and confirmed that Naminé is Kairi's Nobody.