Xion theory(?) may have been said already, maybe not...

[Vesper]

My first time on the site, not sure what's been said or not so don't kill me.

Anyway, has anybody even considered if Xion might actually be Sora's true nobody? She does use the keyblade like he does and if you look in the scans has the same fighting stance as he does. Didn't people start question Roxas' connection with Sora when we first saw Ventus? Why do Ven and Roxas look so similar? and also why would Nomura hide the character's face from us?

Once again, don't kill me, it's just a thought

 

[Cissy]

Well, Xion is a girl. Most people connect her more to Aqua or Kairi.

Roxas is definitely Sora's nobody. He wields a Keyblade also.

Namine was Kairi's nobody, but came from Sora.

So, I'm not sure where Xion would fit in there.

 

[Smile]

Didn't people start question Roxas' connection with Sora when we first saw Ventus?

I think all possible doubts anyone could've ever had about Roxas being Sora's Nobody ended when he disappeared into him at the beginning of KH2.
Then to make it worse they fought inside their Inner World.
Then he came out of Sora, chatted with Namine, and sealed the deal by disappearing back into Sora.

Why do Ven and Roxas look so similar?

Ask these guys *points at Days, BBS, possibly Coded and probably KH3*

and also why would Nomura hide the character's face from us?

For the same reason we didn't get to see Roxas's face in any of the KH1 secret endings - we'd know who she is and that would kind of be giving away one of Days' biggest plot twists?

 

[key_of_destiny94]

Xion as Sora's Nobody??? ROFL she's a girl 4 heaven's sake. If a guy cn produce Nobodies which r the opposite of their own gender, KH will b in turmoils. It will b waaaay 2 confusing.
Yeah, the similarities between Ven and Roxs is freakishly uncanny. They may hav relationship wth each other, bt who knos?
And welcum!!! XP
Edit: (refers 2 SA's post) Ok, sry me bad. 4gtten she's there 2. XP

 

[Samurai777]

I think Xion has more of a connection to Aqua. nice try though

 

[Ren]

Proven by KH2, Roxas is Sora's true nobody, so Xion can't be. I don't buy this :/

 

[XkaiteX]

Well I haven't been on in a long time (like since the day after I made this account thing), so please don't be mad if it has already been discussed.

(I have no idea how to word this but here it goes) When Sora stabbed himself in KH, isn't that when Namine and Roxas were created? Well maybe Xion was created then too. Like Namine is Kairi's nobody and Roxas is Sora's nobody, so maybe Xion could be part of the two of them?

That wasn't exactly what I was trying to get across but maybe you get it. It was close enough.

 

[Smile]

Xion as Sora's Nobody??? ROFL she's a girl 4 heaven's sake. If a guy cn produce Nobodies which r the opposite of their own gender, KH will b in turmoils. It will b waaaay 2 confusing.P

Do you know of this girl?

Lovely little thing, her name is Namine, she is a girl, yet came from Sora

I'm not trying to base Xion being Sora's Nobody.
I'm just saying that there could be complications to make a Nobody emerge from someone of the opposite Gender.

I have no idea how to word this but here it goes) When Sora stabbed himself in KH, isn't that when Namine and Roxas were created? Well maybe Xion was created then too. Like Namine is Kairi's nobody and Roxas is Sora's nobody, so maybe Xion could be part of the two of them?

Probably not. I'd wager a Nobody like that would have less substance than Namine did. Also, what would she be based on? Kinda contradicting the whole "Get Sora whole again" issue DiZ at least claimed he had on.
IF she is related to Kairi, I'd wager she has less to do with Sora in that aspect and maybe more to Kairi herself.
I'm still betting her being related the most to Aqua though.

 

[Vesper]

ok so here's what going through my head...

-Something happens to Ven that maybe he ends up losing his heart in BBS or something like that
-Xion appears after Sora loses his hearts and (maybe) is his nobody
-Xion is defeated and disappears
-somebody decides to replace her with Ven and gives him the name Roxas

I think Ven and Roxas are the same person, Roxas being a little older than when he was Ven

 

[Cissy]

Perhaps as long as the heart was originally intended for a female, the nobody would be a female.

Ven: Let's make that dress! It'll be simply fffaaabbbbuuulllloooouusssss!~

I'd love to see his nobody.

 

[Smile]

-somebody decides to replace her with Ven and gives him the name Roxas

oO
We'll start by saying Xion is number 14. Roxas is 13. You deduct who came first here.

I think Ven and Roxas are the same person

Killed by fire when Nomura said they aren't.

 

[Informal Gluttony]

I'd seriously laugh if Ven has absolutely no connection to Roxas and Sora.

Like, they just look similar, or something.

Xion, Sora's true nobody?

Well, I'm not feeling it.

 

[Lexeon]

I kind of believe this in a way. I mean no one ever said that a guy couldn't have a girl nobody? As for Roxas supposedly being his nobody, he might weild the Keyblade because he might have connections to Ven who is a keyblade weilder. He might've been born like a nobody when Kairi's Heart was released from Sora (Which would include the theory that Ven is inside of Sora).

 

[Cissy]

I'd seriously laugh if Ven has absolutely no connection to Roxas and Sora.

Like, they just look similar, or something.

Xion, Sora's true nobody?

Well, I'm not feeling it.

That would be a let-down. Luckily, Nomura definitely said that Roxas and Ven are connected.

Hey, I just realized that we both have the same birthday. April 16th. =D

 

[Smile]

I wish people would stop spewing Nobodies out of that scene. It's enough Nomura upped the Nobody count to two with Namine.
Ever thought those Nobodies would have to be created from Something? Sora could only give substance to so many Nobodies.

 

[Antiquity]

I never really thought of that idea, but I doubt it.

If Xion was Sora's Nobody, chances are Riku would've mentioned her to him somewhere in there or Roxas could've let him know also, but then again Nomura's ever changing thingsness after KH2 was released and all that stuff wouldn't have a place or make a whole lot of sense.

The whole Aqua and Xion connection makes somewhat more sense.

 

[Ren]

That would be a let-down. Luckily, Nomura definitely said that Roxas and Ven are connected.

He had to, or else people would have just passed it off as his lazy designing again. XDD

 

[Vesper]

Suffering Angel,
Although Xion is the 14th and Roxas the 13th, i don't necessarily think that it immediately makes Roxas the one that came first. i mean i don't think the other organization members numbers determine who was born before the other.

 

[Smile]

Suffering Angel,
Although Xion is the 14th and Roxas the 13th, i don't necessarily think that it immediately makes Roxas the one that came first. i mean i don't think the other organization members numbers determine who was born before the other.

To be completely precise, it's when they joined the Organization.
However, Roxas was drafted almost immediately after he was born, and seeing how Xion has had very little options to be born from Sora otherwise, I doubt she came from him.

 

[Vesper]

That definitely does make more sense