What if Namine was a boy and as Ven's nobody?

[Castaras]

What if instead of Namine being a girl and being the nobody of Kairi.

What if she was a boy (still with witch like powers) but being Ven's nobody? still looking like himself maybe with different clothing? all white.

 

[NuclearCheetos15]

Then we would have a sort of triple clones thing going on. Roxas, Ventus, boy namine.. the confusion will be rampant. In terms of story, Ventus couldn't have made a nobody as the darkness in his heart was ripped out as opposed to it corrupting his heart; thus creating his heartless and nobody. It would also make the RoxasxNamine pairing at the end of Kh 2 a bit awkward..as the two being together was supposed to symbolize Sora and Kairis "relationship".

 

[Sephiroth0812]

The ratio of male to female original characters is already way off as it is, no need to tip it even more I'd say.

 

[Deleted member 246005]

What if instead of Namine being a girl and being the nobody of Kairi.

What if she was a boy (still with witch like powers) but being Ven's nobody? still looking like himself maybe with different clothing? all white.

He'd probably be around the same age as Axel but that would make more sense if he became a nobody after BBS. I find it funny that the guy who lost his memory would gain memory altering powers.

Namine was born because Kairi's heart was in Sora's so that would have to change for this to work. I'm not entirely sure where the memory powers come from so they might be innate to Kairi. Sora's a pretty empathethic dude so maybe Roxas would have gained empathic powers instead?

He might use his powers to trick Sora into thinking he was the 4th member of the team from the first game.

 

[DarkGrey Heroine]

Hmmmmm, let's actually analyze this idea. So...

♦ Namine being a boy means (s)he wouldn't be Kairi's Nobody anymore. That in turn means that he wouldn't probably have access to Sora's memories anymore, since memories define the identity of the person who has them and the key ones are connected to the most precious person of theirs. For Sora, it was clearly Kairi, so a witch with the power over his memories resulted from the whole KH1 ending stabby-McStabStab scene & process we know so well already;
​

♦ Continuing these thoughts leads to an actually natural way to connect male-Namine to another person "inside" Sora's heart, which would naturally be Ven. All considered, we have a male-Namine, Nobody of Ven, without the power over Sora's memories;
​

♦ All clear except one thing: Ven having a Nobody is, in fact, impossible if we assume the following things:
​

[time: BBS] Ven's heart was pure light > he and Vanitas "fused" togeher inside Ven's heart again before the final Ven BBS fight > Ven had both light and darkness in his heart during the battle > Ven defeated Vanitas, thus only light remained inside his heart once again*** > Ven's heart found shelter inside Sora's.
Now, darkness is needed for a Nobody to be created. Ven alone can't have a Nobody***. Then again, Kairi's heart is pure light too, but she had a Nobody because of Sora's own darkness. However, one can't compare the closeness between the hearts of Sora and Kairi with the closeness of the hearts of Sora and Ven. That, in the end, would be the factor that gives or takes the power over the memories in this situation.

*** if defeating Vanitas actually meant "erasing" all darkness from Ven's heart. As of now, Vanitas' precise situation remains unclear though.

tl;dr I would strongly assume a male-Namine-Ven-Nobody wouldn't be a memory wizard, but yeah all white would look lovely like an angel, still aesthetic pleasure is no actual argument for him xD