• Regarding KINGDOM HEARTS Melody of Memory Spoilers

    Copies of KINGDOM HEARTS Melody of Memory are out in the wild, which means spoilers are likely to appear at any point. Although this game has very few cutscenes and story content, we still request that users follow our standard spoiler procedures.

    KINGDOM HEARTS Melody of Memory spoiler policy will end on December 13th, 2020.

    Spoiler threads will need to be tagged with the "Spoiler" prefix. Discussion inside of the thread does not need to be put under spoiler tags, so it is at your discretion to use them.

    Spoilers outside of spoiler threads MUST be hidden using the spoiler tag.

    If you do not follow these rules, your account will be banned.

Roxas... Or Sora? Your decision



REGISTER TO REMOVE ADS

1 or 2

  • OMG Roxas is the coolest and he is the keyblade master that isn't sora.

    Votes: 53 41.1%
  • Yeah Sora is the coolest... Don't know why though.

    Votes: 76 58.9%

  • Total voters
    129

Masamune

Big Boss
Joined
Jul 27, 2006
Messages
2,909
Awards
0
TheMuffinMan said:
Roxas's keyblades aren't real, so really he's duel-weilding nothing =P

Sora's clothes were given to him, it's not like he picked them out. The Fairies gave him his clothes, which are POOFY, and MULTICOLORED, with STRAPS AND BUCKLES. Since when do gangbangers wear that!?

Sora has one chain, and it's a dangly necklace

If anything Gangbangers wear what Roxas has. Wrist bands, finger bands, jacket over his shirt, high collar, spikes.

Roxas doesn't look innocent and pure, Roxas doesn't act innocent and pure, Roxas isn't innocent and pure

yeah i go with u 100% yeah i have seen most gangbangers wear what roxas has and not what sora has... anyways sora is better then roxas...
 

Masamune

Big Boss
Joined
Jul 27, 2006
Messages
2,909
Awards
0
.........damn can somebody delete this

sorry for double posting
 

Puck

THE GHOST ELF of LONG BEACH
Joined
Jun 15, 2004
Messages
4,490
Awards
0
Age
33
I said, Sora is dressed like a FF version of a gangbanger. He even has those armor plates on his shoulders. But look at innocent Roxas. He is dressed normally and non threatening. Roxas is a saint compared to Sora. He acts more innocent, dresses more innocent, and looks more innocent than Sora. He even smiles more innocent than Sora.

And like I said, Roxas had two opportunities to kill Sora, but he didn't. Sora had an opening and he didn't hesitate to go for a killing stroke.

So Roxas is better than Sora because he's lighter and has a more pure personality than Sora. But Sora is cool even though he's merciless, mean, and sometimes dirty minded.
 

TheMuffinMan

Armchair Administrator
Joined
Jun 9, 2005
Messages
9,259
Awards
0
Again King-Sora-Strife, you are ignoring the point. Sora did not chose his clothes, they were given to him. You cannot say that Sora is evil for his outfit when it was not him who chose it. Roxas however choses to wear Wrist and Finger bands, his spiked zipper, his jacket over another jacket over a shirt, with the collar up, and his trademark scowl and frown

Since when does Roxas smile at all? I don't beleive Roxas smiled the entire game, whilst Sora practically does nothing but smile <_<

Roxas had ONE opurtunity to kill Sora, and had Sora not fought back, he would have done so. What do you think Roxas was trying to do in that entire battle? Just chat Sora up, see what's goin down, ask him why 'he' chose him? Of course not, Roxas wanted to Kill Sora and take his body so that he could exist, do you honestly think that all those blows that Sora were blocking would not have killed him? You think that those were just light bruising hits from a foam bat of love? No, had Sora not defended those hits would have killed him, and when Sora was left without a weapon, Roxas put his weapon to Sora's face, which is a gesture of kiling someone

Roxas is a Nobody, Sora is the Hero of Light. Roxas was born from Darkness, weilds Darkness, and worked for Organization XIII. Sora is Pure, Weilds the Keyblade of Light, and Protects the innocent and saves worlds from destruction. Roxas is evil, Sora is the savior of the universe

Sora is 'merciless' against those who wish to harm the innocent, he is never mean to anyone, and don't give me this crap about dirty minded, since when does Sora have a dirty mind?
 

Puck

THE GHOST ELF of LONG BEACH
Joined
Jun 15, 2004
Messages
4,490
Awards
0
Age
33
When did Sora have a dirty mind? In Land of Dragons, Port Royal, Halloween Town, and Olympus. This is not a bad thing by the way. It's just that if you gave each character a naughty choice, Roxas would be the one who would choose not to look at porn but Sora would choose to look at it.

As for Roxas, he did smile. He smiled when he was with his friends. And as I said, Roxas had a clear opportunity to kill Sora. But he didn't take it. He could've easily just stabbed Sora when he pointed the blade at him, but no, he didn't. Why? Because he didn't want to kill Sora. I don't know where you're getting the idea that Roxas wanted to kill Sora and take his body. He clearly wanted answers from Sora and he figured the best way to get them is by first defeating Sora. He did NOT WANT TO KILL SORA. Roxas isn't a killer. The only time he tries to kill is if someone really provokes him. He could've killed Riku in the first fight, but what does he do, he just defeats Riku instead.

Roxas is not evil. He's one of the heroes in the game.
 

TheMuffinMan

Armchair Administrator
Joined
Jun 9, 2005
Messages
9,259
Awards
0
'Sora would look at Porn, but Roxas wouldn't because he's innocent and pure'? Oh come on, you have NO base for that assumption, you're just spewing out crap right now

You list worlds, yet you do not list the scenes in question? Can you give any scenes that show that he has a dirty mind? In both discussions you seemed unable to

Again I do not recall any smiles, all I can recall are frowning, self-pity, self-doubt, staring at his hands, and if there was a smile, none that could match up to Sora's smiles. Example, him dancing around in circles with Donald and Goofy, laughing. I don't recall dancing, jumping around in circles, or smiling from Roxas

Again, you dodge the question. Do you honestly think that all those attacks that were luckily blocked by Sora were merely bruising hits, and that none of them at all could have killed Sora, and no single blow could have been an intended killing hit? Ignorance

Roxas pointed his blade at Sora as a taunt, don't you ever watch those cheesy movies where the bad guy knocks away the opponents weapon, and in sight of his victory, laughed and went on a monologue while leaving his weapon pointed at his opponent, or in the instance of a blade, running it along the defeated opponents neck?

Roxas didn't need answers, none that Sora could give him. Do you think that Sora could have explained why 'he' chose him, and not Roxas? Of course not, so all Roxas needed to do was destroy Sora, and only Roxas would be left, thus, Roxas would be able to take his body, and finally exist as himself, not someone's shadow

Of course Roxas is a killer, what do you think he was doing in Organization XIII? Planting flowers? Baking cookies? Of course not, he was taking over worlds, sending legions of Nobody to kill people, following his Superior's orders.

Again, you say that being provoked is an excuse for violant behavior, yet isn't the existance of the violent behavior itself proof enough that Roxas is not this holy, pure, innocent child you seem to think he is? He tried to kill DiZ, 'killed' Axel, destroyed a computer system in pure rage, yelled at the skies twice, on top of his personality and the way he dresses, how is this the sign of someone more innocent than Sora?

For all you know, Riku was only able to open a portal and escape in the knick of time before being killed, as Saix did. The fact that Roxas told Riku to 'shut up' and charged at him is proof enough that he wanted to finish what he didn't get a chance to before

Roxas is Darkness, he does nothing Heroic outside of being forced to sacrifice himself so that the real Hero, Sora, protector of the Realm of Light, and savior of everyone, could awake. Which stated previously, he later tried to rectify by his attack on Sora
 
Last edited:
Top