Namine's Keyblade?

[Epif]

I dont remember where it was confirmed that namine definatley doesnt have a heart. We didnt even know roxas had a heart at first. Maybe its a very fractured one. Im just putting that out there... Maybe it was confirmed but i dont remember when it was xP

But... it was confirmed that one needs a heart to use a keyblade...

Roxas can because Sora can. His heart is irrelevant.

... No, if Roxas didn't have Ven's heart, then Roxas would be unable to wield one. It isn't because he's Sora's Nobody.

And you don't have to spoiler, it's been implied that Roxas has a heart since 04.

I don't mean to sound like an ass or anything, but you sound like an ass when you say that.

Nomura keeps implying that it's Ven's heart, but CoM says its Sora's heart.

Not really. Vexen said that Twilight Town was tied to "the other side of [Sora's] heart", but CoM never went over Roxas.

Terra was NEVER a master!

Uh... lulz, yes he was. He wasn't one in [B]title[/B], but that doesn't mean that he wasn't one. It's like winning an award and having it held from you.

And that is still considered a spoiler. It will be a spoiler until a couple of months after the release, and then it is still expected for it to be in spoilers. Stop telling people not to spoiler things when you don't know what you need to spoiler.

 

[Box_ghost]

... No, if Roxas didn't have Ven's heart, then Roxas would be unable to wield one. It isn't because he's Sora's Nobody.

Bullshit. Where is that said? Because I got proof where it's said what I said.
Show me where it says "Roxas can wield a Keyblade only because he has Ven's heart"

I don't mean to sound like an ass or anything, but you sound like an ass when you say that.

I don't mean to sound like an ass, but you sound like a bitch when you say that.

Not really. Vexen said that Twilight Town was tied to "the other side of [Sora's] heart", but CoM never went over Roxas.

And the other side of Sora's heart, that would be where?

Uh... lulz, yes he was. He wasn't one in [B]title[/B], but that doesn't mean that he wasn't one. It's like winning an award and having it held from you.

The title is what matters.

And that is still considered a spoiler. It will be a spoiler until a couple of months after the release, and then it is still expected for it to be in spoilers. Stop telling people not to spoiler things when you don't know what you need to spoiler.

I know what needs to be spoiler'd. Kindly get off my junk.

 

[aweomeness96]

@Box_Ghost
It still is a spoiler to some who hasnt played it/finished bbs and to those who havent spoiled themselves as well

 

[SogeUsopp114]

naimine can't have a keyblade because kairi does not have one. the keyblade riku gave to kairi was funny enough his and xehanort's heartless. found the info at Ultimania or whatever the sight was called and if i'm wrong please don't shoot me thank you ^_^

 

[Key of Valor]

An individual needs a heart to wield a genuine Keyblade. This rule was already confirmed.

If Namine has no heart, then that alone would explain why she has no Keyblade.
Xion has a fake heart, which is why she could wield a fake Keyblade.
Roxas on the other hand does wield genuine Keyblades, but as of now it is up to the audience to draw their own conclusions on what that exactly means about him.

 

[~JD~]

Ok well roxas definatley had somewhat of a heart, even though it wasnt really his own, but it still wasnt said that namine doesnt have a peice of kairi's heart, i mean roxas had some of sora's. Kairi couldn't wield the keyblade until the very end of KH2, and it wasnt even her's. Nobody neccessarily gave namine a keyblade to see if she could wield it. Kairi doesnt have a keyblade, the keyblade didnt choose her, but she can wield one, which is completely different.

It doesnt matter anyway because kairi merged with namine so we will never know for sure.

(also a quick theory that if they had to merge back together that would mean she did have some of her heart, all other nobodies (except like roxas) had nowhere to go after they err (i dont want to say died but you know what i mean) "died" but roxas and namine did. Well i mean they both exsisted, the somebody and nobody at the same time. Im pretty sure lea wasnt around when axel was there becauce axel WAS lea (previously) but what im saying because namine and roxas werent completly nobodies, there sombodies were still alive but this also means they had a fractured heart of their somebody. Well thats another theory i had xP)

 

[Box_ghost]

@Box_Ghost
It still is a spoiler to some who hasnt played it/finished bbs and to those who havent spoiled themselves as well

Again, it's been implied that he does since 2004. You don't need BBS to tell you that.
I find it odd that I have to reiterate this. Did you all not play CoM?

 

[Lunarmaster54]

Orginally posted by ~JD~
It doesnt matter anyway because kairi merged with namine so we will never know for sure.

Don't forget that Namine is coming back. Just like Axel, Roxas, Xion, Terra Aqua and Ventus. Sora's going to save them from their fates. otherwise why are they seen in blank points? for shits and giggles?

 

[Lavender13]

Don't forget that Namine is coming back. Just like Axel, Roxas, Xion, Terra Aqua and Ventus. Sora's going to save them from their fates. otherwise why are they seen in blank points? for shits and giggles?

but BBS gave us a hint that coming back doesn't necessarilymean physical.

like when Lea said "in memories, i can live forever". it seems like Roxas, Axel and Xion along with Namine seem to relate more to that. for namine specifically, it's just her thank you, so she can remember sora fulfilling her promise. though it seems so unecessary for roxas, xion and axel to be in torment. roxas seemed happy in the end of kh2.

 

[Rexy]

but BBS gave us a hint that coming back doesn't necessarilymean physical.

like when Lea said "in memories, i can live forever". it seems like Roxas, Axel and Xion along with Namine seem to relate more to that. for namine specifically, it's just her thank you, so she can remember sora fulfilling her promise. though it seems so unecessary for roxas, xion and axel to be in torment. roxas seemed happy in the end of kh2.

yes because he didn't remember, i think he is in torment thanks to the sleeping memories of Xion in his body/Ventus' heart...thats another thing i cannot understand, Sora has Kairi's heart so Naminé was born, Roxas was born of Sora's body and heart (both of them took a little bit of information on the other heart inside Sora , so why is't it possible another Nobody have been created? one with Sora's body and Ventus' heart?

 

[rac7d]

namine can use a keyblade its right here
plus she made up of 2 keyblade weilders[video=youtube;zx3f-DnKzXo]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zx3f-DnKzXo&feature=mfu_in_order&list=UL[/video]

 

[Jediwielder]

Personally, I think that even though she isn't shown wielding one, she can. Thinking about it, she was born from Kairi's light and Sora's darkness. Sora can obviously wield a keyblade and Kairi is shown being able to hold on in KH2. Also, Roxas, also born from Sora's darkness can wield one was well. And

Spoiler Show

So, I see no reason why Naminé shouldn't be able to wield one. Maybe she just chooses not to =)

 

[Izayoi]

we have no way to connect namine to having a heart. her existence is closer to a "nobody" more than anyone else in the series. she was made form half of a heart. roxas we can at least tie to ven and sora's influences.

 

[Fennekinmainack]

we have no way to connect namine to having a heart. her existence is closer to a "nobody" more than anyone else in the series. she was made form half of a heart. roxas we can at least tie to ven and sora's influences.

True, I would be awesome if she had a keyblade though.

 

[Muke]

True, I would be awesome if she had a keyblade though.

Dude, this Thread is 3 years old...

 

[Oracle Spockanort]

Please do not bump threads older than a year. Please do not respond to bumped threads. Contact a moderator if a thread is bumped.