My idea about the Lingering Sentiment

[Muse]

First, before I state my theory, what do we know about the LS?

• He's an optional fight in FM+.
• He is decked in armor from head to toe and wields a Keyblade.
• He says, "You are not the one I chose", to Sora, which hints that Riku was chosen to wield the Keyblade.
• He harbors an extreme hatred for a man known as "Xehanort".
  
  And, as SA reminded me:
  
  
• Nomura just about confirmed he was talking about Riku about the chosen Wielder part
• "He rapes Sora up the ass brutally with a Keyblade bigger than Sora is."

Now, despite this fight being non-canon, the Lingering Sentiment exists and is assumed to be an incarnation of sorts of Terra.

My theory is that in the final battle against Master Xehanort, MX won and fused with Terra, or whatever other silly idea you kids came up with, and Terra's lingering feelings of bitterness towards his defeat and contempt towards Master Xehanort gave birth to the Lingering Sentiment. Presumably, it remained in that area years after the battle, waiting for MX to appear before him again when Sora just so happens to encounter it in FM+.

How exactly is this possible? Well, think about Xion being said to be memories incarnate as one of the popular theories lately. This theory incorporates that idea of memories incarnate, but instead of Xion seeing as she has nothing to do with BBS whatsoever, we use the LS. LS would be Terra's lingering feelings and memories after the battle, which could go on to explain why Terra, as Xehanort, has no memories of his past, LS being those memories.

Well, that's all my theory is about. Feel free to flame the hell out of it comment on it and show me where I'm obviously and painstakingly wrong. <3

 

[Azrael]

So you're suggesting he is an Unbirth or a Nobody carved out of the memories of Terra

 

[15th member]

So our saying that the LS is the memories of terra? And Terra was fused to MX turning into Xehanort? Then tell me what happened to the memories of MX then? Maybe LS is an Unbirth since memories is the theme of the 3 new games

 

[Muse]

So you're suggesting he is an Unbirth or a Nobody carved out of the memories of Terra

No, not an Unbirth or a Nobody. Just memories that are able to walk and talk. =/

 

[Azrael]

No, not an Unbirth or a Nobody. Just memories that are able to walk and talk. =/

Ehhh...I still say he is Unbirth either way but I like your theory, it's quite plausible

 

[nobodyoftwilight]

How do we know that mx fused w/ terra? It doesnt actually make much sense. If mx had his own body and power, why would he need terras!

 

[Muse]

How do we know that mx fused w/ terra? It doesnt actually make much sense. If mx had his own body and power, why would he need terras!

You say how old MX was. Maybe he didn't want to die of old age and decided to fuse with Terra, who was a young and strong male.

But the fact that the Apprentice Xehanort looks so much like Terra with traits from MX is what started the MX + Terra = Xehanort theory. Don't flame me, I didn't come up with that theory!

 

[Azrael]

You say how old MX was. Maybe he didn't want to die of old age and decided to fuse with Terra, who was a young and strong male.

But the fact that the Apprentice Xehanort looks so much like Terra with traits from MX is what started the MX + Terra = Xehanort theory. Don't flame me, I didn't come up with that theory!

Bitch please, Terra pulled an Anakin Skywalker and became Xehanort

 

[Muse]

Bitch please, Terra pulled an Anakin Skywalker and became Xehanort

Oh, whatever! Terra wishes he was as cool as Anakin!

 

[Azrael]

Oh, whatever! Terra wishes he was as cool as Anakin!

At least Aqua has a bigger rack than Panda-bear whatever the fuck her name is

 

[15th member]

Nomura says that no Unbirts survived after BBS..........

 

[nobodyoftwilight]

sorry that last ! was supposed to be a ?. im typin on my psp its not easy.
anyway, what if terra just faded into darkness and that changed his appearance? It could be anything. as for ls, I support the idea that he is an unbirth. If xehanorts heartless could regain his human shape, and some nobodies can, too, why couldnt unbirths?

 

[Azrael]

Nomura says that no Unbirts survived after BBS..........

You actually take Nomura's words for truth.

This is the bastard who said Nobodies had no heart yet we have Roxas who is actually Ventus

 

[Muse]

sorry that last ! was supposed to be a ?. im typin on my psp its not easy.
anyway, what if terra just faded into darkness and that changed his appearance? It could be anything. as for ls, I support the idea that he is an unbirth. If xehanorts heartless could regain his human shape, and some nobodies can, too, why couldnt unbirths?

Xehanort's Heartless wasn't really a Heartless but merely an existence of a Heart. !

 

[Azrael]

Xehanort's Heartless wasn't really a Heartless but merely an existence of a Heart. !

Which is exactly what a Heartless was.

 

[Muse]

Which is exactly what a Heartless was.

Not exactly. He was like how Sora was for the whole of CoM and beginning part of KH2 until Roxas fused with him. A heart.

 

[nobodyoftwilight]

xehanorts HEARTLESS was definately a heartless.

 

[Azrael]

Not exactly. He was like how Sora was for the whole of CoM and beginning part of KH2 until Roxas fused with him. A heart.

A heart filled with darkness which was a Heartless is.

 

[Smile]

• He's an optional fight in FM+.
• He is decked in armor from head to toe and wields a Keyblade.
• He says, "You are not the one I chose", to Sora, which hints that Riku was chosen to wield the Keyblade.
• He harbors an extreme hatred for a man known as "Xehanort".

You might wanna add there that Nomura just about confirmed he was talking about Riku about the chosen Wielder part, and you forgot
"He rapes Sora up the ass brutally with a Keyblade bigger than Sora is."

Now, despite this fight being non-canon, the Lingering Sentiment exists and is assumed to be an incarnation of sorts of Terra.

The fight is non-canon, and even then it's in the sense that Nomura didn't come up with the idea originally. Nomura referencing the Lingering Sentiment's words in Another Report, however, not only gives importance to the entire issue but also canonizes the event. LS being there and having said those words, in the very least, if not also the fight.

My theory is that in the final battle against Master Xehanort, MX won and fused with Terra, or whatever other silly idea you kids came up with,

I'd sooner say Terra fused with MX as a final means to try and stop him.
It would appear that for the short range, it accomplished its goal of putting MX away, though it did later give us our Xehanort to deal with.

How exactly is this possible? Well, think about Xion being said to be memories incarnate as one of the popular theories lately. This theory incorporates that idea of memories incarnate, but instead of Xion seeing as she has nothing to do with BBS whatsoever, we use the LS. LS would be Terra's lingering feelings and memories after the battle, which could go on to explain why Terra, as Xehanort, has no memories of his past, LS being those memories.

What does make me wonder about this is two things:
1) What about MX's own Memories then? Xehanort obviously lacked those as well, though I suppose the feelings Terra harbored could be used to explain this.
2) Xemnas obviously has some Memories of Terra, otherwise why would he call Aqua's armor "friend"? Why look for the "other friend"?

Well, that's all my theory is about. Feel free to flame the hell out of it comment on it and show me where I'm obviously and painstakingly wrong. <3

Well, I do agree with the concept, and the thing is that it hardly contradicts the LS being an Unbirth. In fact, I dare say it goes for LS being an Unbirth, seeing how Terra "Unbirthed" himself to fuse with MX or whatever to become Xehanort.
It goes nicely with the name, in my opinion - the Unbirthing isn't literal - it's stripping oneself of one's Identity, yet on a much deeper level than for Nobodies.
Nobodies for the most part at least remember, and the Heartless forget. But what if the Heart was to, say, be "Formatted"? The very basic Sense of Self that was obviously there even when Sora became a Heartless - what if that was to be taken away? Yet, seeing how Terra must've been Strong of Heart, the discarded Self was not only able to become its own Being, but remain that close to its Origin.
And if we say Terra was either the Base or the Effect of the Unbirthing (say, Xehanort is made up with MX in its base, but Terra "cast off" the LS to fuse with him, he would be the only one Unbirthing while he's holding MX's "Self" at bay with his, er, remaining Self or whatever...)
*ponders*

xehanorts HEARTLESS was definately a heartless.

He was a Heartless in the sense that he was only a Heart, and liked Darkness. He was hardly anything anyone'd call a Heartless usually though. He did what Sora did - only on his own accord instead of having a PoH help him stay "Himself"

 

[keybladelegacy]

First, before I state my theory, what do we know about the LS?

• He's an optional fight in FM+.
• He is decked in armor from head to toe and wields a Keyblade.
• He says, "You are not the one I chose", to Sora, which hints that Riku was chosen to wield the Keyblade.
• He harbors an extreme hatred for a man known as "Xehanort".

Ok....agreeable

Now, despite this fight being non-canon, the Lingering Sentiment exists and is assumed to be an incarnation of sorts of Terra.

My theory is that in the final battle against Master Xehanort, MX won and fused with Terra, or whatever other silly idea you kids came up with, and Terra's lingering feelings of bitterness towards his defeat and contempt towards Master Xehanort gave birth to the Lingering Sentiment. Presumably, it remained in that area years after the battle, waiting for MX to appear before him again when Sora just so happens to encounter it in FM+.

EVen though i have doubt about terra fusing with MX...ok Maybe...but why does it have a physical appearance if it haves emotion then that lets me believe it has a heart.

How exactly is this possible? Well, think about Xion being said to be memories incarnate as one of the popular theories lately. This theory incorporates that idea of memories incarnate, but instead of Xion seeing as she has nothing to do with BBS whatsoever, we use the LS. LS would be Terra's lingering feelings and memories after the battle, which could go on to explain why Terra, as Xehanort, has no memories of his past, LS being those memories.

but emotions would let me believe that it has a heart but im probably wrong next their arent any signs that it is made of memories.

Well, that's all my theory is about. Feel free to flame the hell out of it comment on it and show me where I'm obviously and painstakingly wrong. <3

Would i do something like that to you.
No!