ok so today i was just thinking about Xehanort and his memory and all. now im not sure if this has been stated though i thought it might have been in COM. since memories are in the heart, if you lose your heart does that mean you lose your memories aswell? or if you lose your heart do you lose your memories? well i thought of this applying to Xehanort. since he lost his memories sometime before he met Ansem the Wise, he could have lost his heart too. and this connects to his name Xehanort rearranged makes No Heart. i dont know what do you guys think? am i really wrong or am i onto something?
just a little theory
- Thread starter KingdomSealer
- Start date
|
REGISTER TO REMOVE ADS |
|
- Status
i think the chasers wiped his memory, from everything ive heard.
I think you're going pretty good there. Those are all facts no doubt about it so no one can say that your theory is lacking a foundation.
antiformkeyblade, that can be a possible way of erasing memories.
In fact, I'll add to your theory, With a bit of my own.
Say the 'Chasers' as we refer to them now, wanted to wipe Xehanorts memory.
What better way than to remove the heart?
We shall use the Roxas/Sora case.
Roxas did not retain the memories of Sora because Sora was returned so quickly.
If the chasers took Xehanorts heart, and instead of letting it become a heartless, they simply stuffed it into his nobody.
Guess what? The heart didn't, like in Sora's case, become a heartless. So suppose they can hold the heart until the nobody gains all the memories. Then, as in the Roxas/Sora case, they send the heart back to the body, the heart has no knowledge of what the nobody knows now, and the nobody's experiences aren't transfered, therefore the new complete version doesn't have any memories at all.
Thus it might explain why xemnas only has memories of being ansem's apprentice. It might also explain why Xehanorts heart didn't turn into a heartless when it was separated, it could have been used to not being in its body since it would have been the second time.
However there is one loophole or something that hasn't been explained yet, and I don't want to hear anything about it, because noone alive besides Nomura could explain it.
How did Xemnas AND his counterpart Xehanorts heart BOTH retain the memories of apprenticeship? that is where the true answer lies.
antiformkeyblade, that can be a possible way of erasing memories.
In fact, I'll add to your theory, With a bit of my own.
Say the 'Chasers' as we refer to them now, wanted to wipe Xehanorts memory.
What better way than to remove the heart?
We shall use the Roxas/Sora case.
Roxas did not retain the memories of Sora because Sora was returned so quickly.
If the chasers took Xehanorts heart, and instead of letting it become a heartless, they simply stuffed it into his nobody.
Guess what? The heart didn't, like in Sora's case, become a heartless. So suppose they can hold the heart until the nobody gains all the memories. Then, as in the Roxas/Sora case, they send the heart back to the body, the heart has no knowledge of what the nobody knows now, and the nobody's experiences aren't transfered, therefore the new complete version doesn't have any memories at all.
Thus it might explain why xemnas only has memories of being ansem's apprentice. It might also explain why Xehanorts heart didn't turn into a heartless when it was separated, it could have been used to not being in its body since it would have been the second time.
However there is one loophole or something that hasn't been explained yet, and I don't want to hear anything about it, because noone alive besides Nomura could explain it.
How did Xemnas AND his counterpart Xehanorts heart BOTH retain the memories of apprenticeship? that is where the true answer lies.
(tap, tap) ok i give. to wipe memory, take heart. ok.
I see what ya saying... Good idea... Sounds like something SE would do.
Could be. I'm not sure that it would have anything to do with COM, though.
Were you trying to say "If when you lose your heart do you lose your memories as well? Or maybe if you lose your memories, maybe you lose your heart?", because if that's the case, then I wouldn't be suprised if you were on to something...
if you lose your memories you dont lose your heart. cause sora lost his memories in CoM. but he didnt lose his heart agian.
- Joined
- Dec 24, 2005
- Messages
- 240
I think you are forgetting 2 very important facts,
1)Xehanort HAD his heart when he was called Xehanort so it would be pointless rearranging his name into NO Heart X as he would have had a heart, i think the org adding an x to their names was a throw back to xehanort being to first one to give up his heart willingly.
2) Xehanort can also rearrange into Another X.
1)Xehanort HAD his heart when he was called Xehanort so it would be pointless rearranging his name into NO Heart X as he would have had a heart, i think the org adding an x to their names was a throw back to xehanort being to first one to give up his heart willingly.
2) Xehanort can also rearrange into Another X.
Sora didn't lose his memories, they where altered by Namine, and then restored.
oh yeah...sorry bout that. never mind. i was wrong.
whered you hear that? i never heard anythig like that cept like in theorys and speculations.
from the theorys and speculations...thats what has been said yes? thats just what i heard. not claiming it as my own theory. i just saying, its a good theory.
- Joined
- Mar 25, 2006
- Messages
- 1,573
- Age
- 38
he never said that if you lose your memories then you lose your heart. he said that if you lose your heart, you lose your memories.
i know its from theorys its just that the chasers wiping out xehanorts memory dosen't seem right. that's the only thing about this theory im a little skeptical on. evrything else is great.
- Joined
- Dec 14, 2006
- Messages
- 51
that sounds like a good theory/ this is my first post ever!!
- Joined
- Dec 13, 2006
- Messages
- 3,212
- Awards
- 4
welcome rikuskeyblade..............
- Status