Is Ven a Nobody?

[Monoochrom]

I was just wondering, if Vens Heart is in Sora, what is left of him would be the Body and Soul, therefore a Nobody, right? I mean, I otherwise can't really explain why he wouldn't age (and I'm sure we can all agree that him aging is less likely).

While we are at it. If Sora was basically just a Heart inbetween KH 1 and 2 and Roxas, his Nobody is basically using his Body and Nobodies don't age, how can Sora physically grow in that period?

I'm sure something is wrong with this, I must have something here wrong.

Edit: I didn't notice the Handheld section, just move this if necessary.

 

[Orion]

Nope, he didn't lose his Heart to Darkness or Heartless.

 

[Monoochrom]

Yeah I know, but is that really necessary to create a Nobody? I mean, he currently doesn't have a Heart, so what is he then? And about that aging thing, if he isn't a Nobody, wouldn't he kind of have to age over 10 years by the Time he is saved?

 

[NotaHero21]

Yeah I know, but is that really necessary to create a Nobody? I mean, he currently doesn't have a Heart, so what is he then? And about that aging thing, if he isn't a Nobody, wouldn't he kind of have to age over 10 years by the Time he is saved?

He does have a heart, its just fractured. Thats really the end...

 

[Dr_Mario64]

Yeah I know, but is that really necessary to create a Nobody? I mean, he currently doesn't have a Heart, so what is he then? And about that aging thing, if he isn't a Nobody, wouldn't he kind of have to age over 10 years by the Time he is saved?

Technically, Ven has a partial heart. He has the light side and Vanitas has the dark side. As for the aging, I don't have an answer, but you'd think that even with part of a heart he'd have aged a little.

 

[Orion]

Yeah I know, but is that really necessary to create a Nobody? I mean, he currently doesn't have a Heart, so what is he then? And about that aging thing, if he isn't a Nobody, wouldn't he kind of have to age over 10 years by the Time he is saved?

You only get Nobodies if a strong-hearted person loses their heart to Darkness of the Heartless. You can consider the remainder a technical Nobody, but it's not an actual one unless the Heart's been lost.

 

[Monoochrom]

I mean at the end of BBS, isn't his Heart locked inside Soras? I mean, the whole Series is kind of wierd with it's Hearts and Hearts and 3 people in 1 Body and what not. I probably just misunderstood something, but if so, clarification would be nice.

 

[NotaHero21]

I mean at the end of BBS, isn't his Heart locked inside Soras? I mean, the whole Series is kind of wierd with it's Hearts and Hearts and 3 people in 1 Body and what not. I probably just misunderstood something, but if so, clarification would be nice.

I would hesitate to say that its locked there, it is connected but locked does not seem to be the case.

 

[Stars]

Ven's heart was inside Sora for recovery of his fractured heart, and never create a nobody and heartless.

 

[Crystal]

Ven's heart didn't lost into darkness, therefore no Heartless.
He was stay in Sora' to recover his injured heart.

 

[Sephiroth0812]

A body onl ages if a functional heart is within it. That's why nobodies and also Ven's comatose body in Castle Oblivion don't age (physically, that is, of course chronologically they all do age).
Roxas also didn't age because the heart in him (Ven's) was not fully functional.

Ven's heart is sleeping inside Sora's to rest, as its heavy injury couldn't sustain Ven's awake status anymore.
So Ventus is/has no nobody, he just lies in a coma in Castle Oblivion while his injured heart hides inside Sora's, resting there and waiting to be healed so that it can be put back where it belongs.

 

[Stars]

Didn't Roxas and Namine aged?

 

[Crystal]

Didn't Roxas and Namine aged?

I think Nobodies don't aged, but i don't know for them since they were special case.

 

[Stars]

I think Nobodies don't aged, but i don't know for them since they were special case.

Because I saw it somewhere Roxas and Namine having age same as Sora and Kairi

 

[Dark Wing]

ven is basically in the same state after bbs that kairi was in during most of KHI

 

[Crystal]

ven is basically in the same state after bbs that kairi was in during most of KHI

Yeah, since Kairi get her heart back and awake, i hope this happen to Ven too.