Is Namine evil?

[khluva010]

Spoiler Show

I've heard so many different things about Namine and what she did in CoM.

But from what I've seen in KH2, she seems like Kairi's other half who tries to help Kairi and Sora.

Is she evil? or is she just being a typical nobody?

I haven't play CoM yet so please don't be upset if I have the wrong idea.

 

[TheMuffinMan]

Play COM and find out

 

[Xemna's heatless]

well if it is what she did in CoM that makes you think she was evil than no she is not becuse she was made to do it

Spoiler Show

and the typical nobody thing

i think Roxas and Namine were not normal nobody the had half a heart

becuse they say that nobody's can remeber what it was like to have hearts

but roxas did not have memory of when he was sora and still acted like he had a heart

and Namine did not know what it was like when she was of Kairi

but still acted like she had a heart

so id say that they have half a heart but thats just me

 

[jamietl]

i dont think she was evil, she seemed kind of forced to, but she puts his memories back so no problems there, maybe they feel like they have hearts because their original selves still existed so they got their emothions form them (sora and kairi)

 

[namine's shadow]

I have never heard anyone say Namine is evil in my entire life T.T It makes me cry. She's not evil. She just does as she's told or she'll probally suffer the consequences if she was getting her revenge against the org.13 or something. Besides, if she's the other side of kairi, she must be non-evil. But because Roxas' in the org, 13, does that mean he's an evil lunatic? I didn't think so...

 

[Lycanthrope]

she wasnt evil. at least, i dont think so...

 

[Spyells]

I don't believe she was evil. I believe she was just forced. I don't think that someone who is apart of Kairi could be evil. Maybe I've got the wrong idea, but that's what I think.

 

[Soren]

She wasn't evil. Marluxia said that if she didn't help him he'd lock her up in the castle forever. She simply did what she had to do to survive. Lucky for her that Axel was out to stop Marluxia's plans, or she might not have been able to set things right.

That said, Roxas and Namine aren't normal nobodies, just look at how they came into being. Normally, a nobody is born when someone of strong heart and will becomes a heartless. Namine was born when Kiari's heart hid itself in Sora's body. And while Sora did become a heartless, he went back to being Sora so quickly that Roxas lost all memory of him.

 

[black acid]

she is a mistake (as diz implied). she simply wanted to have someone there for her other then middle evil and traitoris Organization members, where as Kairi got both riku and sora. with envy Namine desided to turn the tables not knowing what her lust for attention would get sora into....


case and Point, Nobody's can't become sombody's.

 

[Mushinator!]

I dont believe Namine is evil....

 

[Spyells]

She wasn't evil. Marluxia said that if she didn't help him he'd lock her up in the castle forever. She simply did what she had to do to survive. Lucky for her that Axel was out to stop Marluxia's plans, or she might not have been able to set things right.

That said, Roxas and Namine aren't normal nobodies, just look at how they came into being. Normally, a nobody is born when someone of strong heart and will becomes a heartless. Namine was born when Kiari's heart hid itself in Sora's body. And while Sora did become a heartless, he went back to being Sora so quickly that Roxas lost all memory of him.

I guess you're right. Namine and Roxas were not normal nobodies. And Sora didn't stay a heartless long so that would explain why Roxas would not remember anything from being Sora.