• Hello everybody! We have tons of new awards for the new year that can be requested through our Awards System thanks to Antifa Lockhart! Some are limited-time awards so go claim them before they are gone forever...

    CLICK HERE FOR AWARDS

i know i know... another xion theory...



REGISTER TO REMOVE ADS
Status
Not open for further replies.

black_hood_demon

New member
Joined
Sep 7, 2008
Messages
75
Location
The Darkest Part of Everyone's Being...
Now this is going to have some major holes in it, but think carefully and just maybe it could work... what if when sora stabbed himself with the evil keyblade he created roxas and namine. now namine was special because she was made from a princess of heart which would be total light,and she is tied to sora because kairi's heart was tied with sora's at the time. but what if one more nobody was created to "balance out" namine's pure good? the whole memory mumbo-jumbo would be shared with the two nobodies: one that can change and alter memories (namine), and the other one to take them away(xion). now i know its a little flimsy but i think im getting the point across... can anyone help bridge the gap in some of these holes...?
 

Byronic Hero

Resonance of Darkness
Joined
Jun 29, 2008
Messages
5,737
Awards
1
Age
34
In your theory, if Namine's "pure good" is balanced out, it would have to be something of "pure darkness" and Xion doesn't strike me as an XH type person.
 

Axie

New member
Joined
Oct 10, 2008
Messages
699
Location
Sleeping on the couch at the usual spot until such
Now this is going to have some major holes in it, but think carefully and just maybe it could work... what if when sora stabbed himself with the evil keyblade he created roxas and namine. now namine was special because she was made from a princess of heart which would be total light,and she is tied to sora because kairi's heart was tied with sora's at the time. but what if one more nobody was created to "balance out" namine's pure good? the whole memory mumbo-jumbo would be shared with the two nobodies: one that can change and alter memories (namine), and the other one to take them away(xion). now i know its a little flimsy but i think im getting the point across... can anyone help bridge the gap in some of these holes...?

It's a good idea--and it's hard to say, if she was created for "balance" (which is PARAMOUNT) then that might violate some rules of Nobodihood no matter how you look at it--but like the Masta says, it'd be really close to darkness. Xion would probably more corrupt than not (although THAT'S a fun idea all by itself), and would probably manifest more like a Heartless, which isn't likely.

There's also the fact that darkness and light is heart territory and wouldn't affect Nobodies (who reign supreme over nothingness, turned aside by both), but we have to take into consideration the fact that Namine is a special case.
 

Lifes.Lover

For the deeds of today resonate....
Joined
Oct 14, 2008
Messages
3,142
Age
35
Location
Immersed in dreams of normality.
Website
lifes-lover18.livejournal.com
The only thing that I have a problem with, is that Naminé does not show that she is pure good. Sure, she's a nice person, but she did manipulate Sora's memories, even if that was at the threat of the Organization. Plus, when she was with DiZ and Riku, she constantly ran away, trying to meet Roxas and explain things to him, which DiZ didn't want. So, I can't believe that she's pure good. And I can't believe that Xion is pure evil, which is what she'd have to be to balance out Naminé's pure good.
 
A

Audo

Guest
Nobodies arent made of light or dark... that's the whole point.
There is no such thing as a 'pure good' or 'pure bad' Nobody. They just are. Even Nami was on the fence when asked if the Organization was good or bad.
 

The Enchanted

New member
Joined
Aug 4, 2008
Messages
788
Location
Smitting Thee
Axie is correct.

Nobodies aren't typically associated with light or dark.
So Nami being more aligned with the light, is quite wrong.
Her actions at Castle Oblivion show that.

Xion being closer to the dark, like Axie pointed out, are really improbable.
She seems more lost and confused, then angry and violent, no?
 

Lifes.Lover

For the deeds of today resonate....
Joined
Oct 14, 2008
Messages
3,142
Age
35
Location
Immersed in dreams of normality.
Website
lifes-lover18.livejournal.com
That's what I thought. But, if the Organization wasn't actually entirely bad or good, then why was Sora so vehemently for destroying them? Was it just because of Yen Sid and what he said? I mean, he started killing the Organization off before he even knew they had captured Kairi, so that can't be used as an excuse for his earlier actions.
 

Axie

New member
Joined
Oct 10, 2008
Messages
699
Location
Sleeping on the couch at the usual spot until such
That's what I thought. But, if the Organization wasn't actually entirely bad or good, then why was Sora so vehemently for destroying them? Was it just because of Yen Sid and what he said? I mean, he started killing the Organization off before he even knew they had captured Kairi, so that can't be used as an excuse for his earlier actions.

Sora kills anything that gets in his way, if it sticks around long enough to die.

After killing Demyx:

Sora & Donald said:
Sora: Anyone from the Organization who'd like to be next?!
Donald: Sora! Don't antagonize them!

This happened right after he'd been slamming away fruitlessly at Ansem's computer, looking for answers. I suspect he does it to take out some frustration. :p
 

black_hood_demon

New member
Joined
Sep 7, 2008
Messages
75
Location
The Darkest Part of Everyone's Being...
The only thing that I have a problem with, is that Naminé does not show that she is pure good. Sure, she's a nice person, but she did manipulate Sora's memories, even if that was at the threat of the Organization. Plus, when she was with DiZ and Riku, she constantly ran away, trying to meet Roxas and explain things to him, which DiZ didn't want. So, I can't believe that she's pure good. And I can't believe that Xion is pure evil, which is what she'd have to be to balance out Naminé's pure good.

i didnt say pure good... i just said pure light. i just noticed how namine is all white (hair and clothes) while xion is all black... pure light, pure darkness, not good and evil!
 

Axie

New member
Joined
Oct 10, 2008
Messages
699
Location
Sleeping on the couch at the usual spot until such
i didnt say pure good... i just said pure light. i just noticed how namine is all white (hair and clothes) while xion is all black... pure light, pure darkness, not good and evil!

but what if one more nobody was created to "balance out" namine's pure good?

You did, actually--and for some reason that's what stuck in some minds. But I figured you meant "pure light," since you said that more.

If Namine is purely a Nobody, then regardless of appearance, she can't be associated with light or darkness. But if she has any other aspects to her that we don't know about (she was already born without a body, has the ability to alter memories as well as physical objects such as Jiminy's journal and Kairi's charm), then they may be polarized like that. But I doubt this.
 

Gummi Master

New member
Joined
Oct 27, 2008
Messages
25
Age
35
Location
O-town,Florida
Now this is going to have some major holes in it, but think carefully and just maybe it could work... what if when sora stabbed himself with the evil keyblade he created roxas and namine. now namine was special because she was made from a princess of heart which would be total light,and she is tied to sora because kairi's heart was tied with sora's at the time. but what if one more nobody was created to "balance out" namine's pure good? the whole memory mumbo-jumbo would be shared with the two nobodies: one that can change and alter memories (namine), and the other one to take them away(xion). now i know its a little flimsy but i think im getting the point across... can anyone help bridge the gap in some of these holes...?

I really WANT to like this theory, and agree with the main points, partly because its kinda like mine, but instead of thinking of Xion balancing Namine out, think of her more like what Roxas is to Sora.
I don't know, either Namine and Xion are unique entities but similar to one another or only Namine is the wierdo X3
 

neodusk182

New member
Joined
Oct 30, 2008
Messages
17
Age
30
Location
Swallowed by darkness
Now this is going to have some major holes in it, but think carefully and just maybe it could work... what if when sora stabbed himself with the evil keyblade he created roxas and namine. now namine was special because she was made from a princess of heart which would be total light,and she is tied to sora because kairi's heart was tied with sora's at the time. but what if one more nobody was created to "balance out" namine's pure good? the whole memory mumbo-jumbo would be shared with the two nobodies: one that can change and alter memories (namine), and the other one to take them away(xion). now i know its a little flimsy but i think im getting the point across... can anyone help bridge the gap in some of these holes...?
but, wouldnt have roxas balanced that out, because before he lost his memory, he seemed to be more dark oriented than light, meaning that he just acted darker than namine. Maybe, if this balancing thing is right, xion was created for the purpose of nothingness, to balance the two light and the darkness, i dont know but it is a good theory
 

Axie

New member
Joined
Oct 10, 2008
Messages
699
Location
Sleeping on the couch at the usual spot until such
but, wouldnt have roxas balanced that out, because before he lost his memory, he seemed to be more dark oriented than light, meaning that he just acted darker than namine. Maybe, if this balancing thing is right, xion was created for the purpose of nothingness, to balance the two light and the darkness, i dont know but it is a good theory

We can't say for sure about Namine, but Roxas is definitely a Nobody and nothing else--meaning he has no association with darkness or light.
 

Salty the Hero

self loafer
Joined
Mar 18, 2007
Messages
3,591
Awards
1
Age
30
We can't say for sure about Namine, but Roxas is definitely a Nobody and nothing else--meaning he has no association with darkness or light.


Uh, Roxas has association to light. He used light when he was in Twilight Town.
 

Salty the Hero

self loafer
Joined
Mar 18, 2007
Messages
3,591
Awards
1
Age
30
I'm not surprised; it's his element. But he has no allegiance to it or to darkness and can't be taken over by one or the other (lacking a heart).


Oh, sorry, I thought you were talking about something else.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top