A Theory on Xion. Small spoilers.

[Keyblade Spirit]

Somewhere I read that Xion looks a bit like Kairi, and this is my theory on why.

My theory is because Kairi's heart was inside Sora's body, it created two Nobodies instead of one. The two that I'm talking about are Roxas and Namine, and because Kairi already lost her heart, creating Namine, Xion was created when Kairi's heart went back to her. To put it simply, my theory is that a Nobody is created whenever a heart leaves a body, not just its original body.

What do you guys think?

EDIT: I have revised this theory. You can see the new version here: http://forums.khinsider.com/future-kingdom-hearts/111890-theory-xion-small-spoilers-2.html#post3201952

 

[Colours]

Well it has been some rumors that Xion sounds like kairi, but she doesn't look like her. She has dark blue hair thats all we can conclude.

 

[khinsiderfan]

dude i had the same theory, but kudos to u for also thinking of it.

 

[Keyblade Spirit]

dude i had the same theory, but kudos to u for also thinking of it.

Really? I'll look at at it.

 

[khinsiderfan]

yeah.... well actually if u want to be creative u could assume that aqua's heart went into kairi (no evidence at all mind u just simple thinking) and that why aqua's armor is in the room of sleep, cuz she became a lifeless doll when her heart left, much like when kairi became lifeless. i myself doubt this, but it would explain xion's appearance.

 

[♫]

Well it has been some rumors that Xion sounds like kairi, but she doesn't look like her. She has dark blue hair thats all we can conclude.

-_-

It hasnt been confirmed that she has blue hair.

 

[Smile]

Somewhere I read that Xion looks a bit like Kairi, and this is my theory on why.

Olette looks like Kairi too. Selphie looks like Kairi too. Aqua in the secret ending looks like Kairi too. Sora looks like Kairi too.
Keep in mind we're talking about how the lower half of her face looks - no one saw how she looks wholly.
It's called game graphics. They make Maleficent and Pete look alike sometimes.

and because Kairi already lost her heart, creating Namine, Xion was created when Kairi's heart went back to her. To put it simply, my theory is that a Nobody is created whenever a heart leaves a body, not just its original body.

What do you guys think?

I think you're a very confused, lost child.
Namine was created when Kairi's Heart left Sora's body, not Kairi's. As far as we know, no Nobody was created when Kairi originally lost her Heart so it could move into Sora's body. If anything you can say that was when Xion was born, but that would make me ask you what was Kairi in KH1 then, seeing how she was the Body and Soul of a PoH left behind without its Heart. This would've went on to create Xion by your theory, but then - what does that leave Kairi with?
The only reason Kairi even has a Nobody at all is because Sora - someone with Darkness in his Heart that could create a Nobody - was involved in the process.
Kairi on her own could never create even one Nobody let alone two. That leaves us with Namine as Kairi's Nobody, and Xion - something else.

 

[khinsiderfan]

i agree with the thoery of namine and xion...... no one knows the true rules for becoming a nobody and so it possible.

 

[Smile]

i agree with the thoery of namine and xion...... no one knows the true rules for becoming a nobody and so it possible.

...we very much do know the rules for becoming a Nobody.
Heart leaves Body and Soul behind, yey.
Namine is special because two Hearts left the same Body-Soul, thus creating one Nobody based on Sora, and another lesser Nobody, in a way, one that barely had enough substance to it - that would be Namine.

 

[khinsiderfan]

yes but if the theory that part of ven was in sora thus creating roxas's appearance then we don't know all the rules now do, we lonely know the basics of normal bodies and souls.

 

[♫]

yes but if the theory that part of ven was in sora thus creating roxas's appearance then we don't know all the rules now do, we lonely know the basics of normal bodies and souls.

Thats mere speculation. It doesnt prove true and it doesnt change anything.

 

[Smile]

I go with Charge on this one. Even if you want to say they're "irregulars", there's still all the issues we already brought up about this theory.
That and I hardly think a part of Aqua was inside Kairi, especially because Kairi and Aqua lack between them everything Sora and Ven have that remotely tie them together.

 

[khinsiderfan]

true. all i'm saying thought is that i think we will get a better idea of nobodies and the irregular ones that better expalin roxas and namine and especially xion.

 

[Smile]

true. all i'm saying thought is that i think we will get a better idea of nobodies and the irregular ones that better expalin roxas and namine and especially xion.

What makes you think Xion is a special Nobody at all?
If she's Aqua's normal, regular, everyday, boring Nobody, it would explain just about everything from the looks to the Keyblade to the relation to Roxas via Ven, just because she's Aqua.

 

[♫]

What makes you think Xion is a special Nobody at all?
If she's Aqua's normal, regular, everyday, boring Nobody, it would explain just about everything from the looks to the Keyblade to the relation to Roxas via Ven, just because she's Aqua.

LOOKS?!?!?!?

Aqua and Xion look NOTHING alike. Xion is a SMALL SKINNY B**** while Aqua is teh HAWTNESS, TIFA BOOBED, PORNSTAR!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

 

[khinsiderfan]

if xion can weild a keyblade then she special... granted at this point the keyblade is stated to be fake, but xion doesn't believe that which makes me question a few things. like roxas can weild cuz sora can, but roxas had no heart and so shouldn't have been able to regardless. it's these things that make me think xion is special as is roxas and namine.

 

[Smile]

LOOKS?!?!?!?

Aqua and Xion look NOTHING alike. Xion is a SMALL SKINNY B**** while Aqua is teh HAWTNESS, TIFA BOOBED, PORNSTAR!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

1) Physical changes between a Somebody and a Nobody
2) Org Cloak killing everything worth showing
3) Willed change of appearance like DiZ did.
And I was talking about what we did see of her face that makes people say she looked like Kairi; she looks like Aqua to me. So mur.

if xion can weild a keyblade then she special...

No, it means that whomever's Nobody she is was special - that that person was a Keyblade Wielder and that ability went on to her when the Somebody moved on to being a Heartless.

granted at this point the keyblade is stated to be fake, but xion doesn't believe that which makes me question a few things. like roxas can weild cuz sora can, but roxas had no heart and so shouldn't have been able to regardless.

We don't know that at all. They're, I won't say special, but one of a kind. You have nothing to say that Wielding a Keyblade doesn't transfer to the Nobody when the Wielder's Heart moves on to being a Heartless.

it's these things that make me think xion is special as is roxas and namine.

It makes me think she's the Nobody of someone special.
Also, constantly saying "Roxas and Namine" in the same sentence isn't Healthy. They each have their reasons to being special but those reasons are different between them. Roxas is far more a standard Nobody and the main point of interest about him is his loss of Memories which were taken from him (as opposed to Namine that simply never had them), and the Keyblade, but we don't know for certain that's because he's a special Nobody, or because Sora was special in that aspect.

 

[khinsiderfan]

sry suffering angel.. ur right. the person before the nobody was special, my bad on that, but do u see wat i'm saying about heartless being able to wield keyblades..... i can accpet this, it's not like i'm fighting this fact or anything but it would also mean that there is a loop hole and u don't need a heart to weild a keyblade... which i used to think was the only way.

 

[Smile]

Actually, a Nobody seems more likely to Wield a Keyblade to me than a Heartless. There are only two known cases in which a Heartless kept his sense of self, and the rest weren't really their own Hearts - making them weak.
A Nobody, on the other hand, has the necessary force of Will needed to Wield. If we say the Ability transferred from the Somebody when he turned into a Heartless and was left in the Nobody, or beyond that - that it's based in the Soul or something - a Nobody would have a higher chance of Wielding than a Heartless, imo.
Throw in the fact the Keyblade chooses the one to Wield it, and there you have it.

 

[E.J.]

LOOKS?!?!?!?

Aqua and Xion look NOTHING alike. Xion is a SMALL SKINNY B**** while Aqua is teh HAWTNESS, TIFA BOOBED, PORNSTAR!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Wow. That is just.....wow.