A REALLY GOOD theory about Xion- NOT ABOUT SORA/ROXAS, etc.

[Iridium]

What am I doing that's making me dig a hole? I'm not getting mad, I'm trying to not start a fight in the first place. And by doing that apparently, everyone else is getting mad! I'm not mad unless I use the Caps Lock on my words.

But you know that makes it crappy and obvious! That's why it's fun to make up theories, and stop bashing me you bastards!

So that's not getting mad at all?

And the 'digging a hole' ref is a pun.

 

[joeXnickXkev HA!]

Too many people knew Roxas was Sora's Nobody because they all but spelled it out in the Final Mix, what with him duel wielding the Oblivion and the Oathkeeper in Deep Dive, and there being an Ansem Report talking about Nobodies that are created when someone turns into a Heartless.
They're not trying to hide those "twists" nor are the twists on themselves that important.
Ok, so Roxas is Sora's Nobody. Gasp, shock, shrug. Onwards to what they're gonna do with it.
The same goes for Xion and the truth about her. They don't need to hide what she is as long as they pull the plot involving her well.

I'll take this a step further and say that if it's obvious, then it's based. Twists often tend to make people blink and tilt their heads, because no one saw them coming. That means it's not 'wow', it means the writers pulled that out of their asses.
Namine being Kairi's Nobody is a good example imo, especially since the same exact plot could've happened just as well had she been the Magical Memory Girl from Castle Oblivion instead of being Kairi's Nobody born of Sora's Body and Soul :\
To me, that was them trying to give Kairi importance when there was no reason to do so.
The rest of the PoHs were redundant even still inside KH1. Kairi didn't really prove herself worthy of staying around after that, is how I see it.
Then came Namine and of course they threw Kairi in again. Amazing.

Exactly! I mean, it's not like ANY of our theories will ever happen honestly. I'm just being creative and mindless. I share it to get opinions and see what's wrong. That's what sharing theories is for in the first place. I wanna become a manga author when I get the chance, so I test out ideas on other people's things and then use the skills and knowledge I pick up from it to help my own stories advance. You could be paying more attention like me or freaking out at opinions and learn nothing. ;P

 

[joeXnickXkev HA!]

So that's not getting mad at all?

And the 'digging a hole' ref is a pun.

I know, that's what I meant. And don't you mean a saying or something. Ah, whatever it is...

 

[Iridium]

It's a pun, also, refrain from double posting please.

 

[joeXnickXkev HA!]

wow you really dont get it...

You're being rude.. not mean, but rude.

 

[joeXnickXkev HA!]

It's a pun, also, refrain from double posting please.

Sorry. What is double posting? *slaps self*

 

[Smile]

Exactly! I mean, it's not like ANY of our theories will ever happen honestly.

...you're saying the exact opposite of what I wrote.
I showed a situation in which theories stating so called "obvious" conclusions DID come true - Roxas being Sora's Nobody.
Xion being Aqua is highly likely.

Then I showed you an "unexpected" twist - which isn't based at all and a lot of people find to be a poor plot development.
That will be Namine as Kairi's Nobody.
That would be Xion being Kairi's sister (notice a pattern?)

I'm just being creative and mindless.

Paradox.

I share it to get opinions and see what's wrong.

Did you stop to think what was right in your so called 'theory'? That's not even a theory. A theory needs to be based on something. You lack basis.

I wanna become a manga author when I get the chance, so I test out ideas on other people's things and then use the skills and knowledge I pick up from it to help my own stories advance.

Good luck, if you wanna do that through Tokyopop or something.
Get real if you wanna go to Japan (I'm assuming you're a gaijin).
And you've got a long way to go with stories.

You could be paying more attention like me

We pay attention enough to know your theory wasn't even worth posting for obvious reasons from the games.
We also pay attention enough to acknowledge other possibilities.

or freaking out at opinions and learn nothing. ;P

You're the only one I see freaking out here

 

[Wehrmacht]

Alright, this has gotten out of hand, and since the theory's since been kind of disproved/adressed I don't feel this needs to remain open any longer.

-Closed-