That's not the point; the point is you had nothing to do with the thread at all. You expressed NO interest in fighting the thread creator. You were NOT the one challenged at all. And I'll say it again; it was over a month old. Being on the front page does NOT mean a thread is active. After a month or more without activity it should be obvious something roleplay related is not happening.
What did you contribute to the thread that was necessary?
As ..far as reviving an old thread goes, no, you had nothing to do with it and no one asked for criticism over a challenge that was never accepted. You were better off just ignoring the topic, you had no part in it. No offense but that's just how it is. I mean no one posted in it for over a month, you were better off just moving on.