- Joined
- Oct 14, 2008
- Messages
- 3,142
- Age
- 34
- Location
- Immersed in dreams of normality.
- Website
- lifes-lover18.livejournal.com
First of all, may I just say that I can't believe I cracked and made a Xion theory.
Second of all, I don't wholly support this theory myself, nor do I have much evidence (if any) to prove it.
But asides from that, I thought that it might be an interesting idea, that, if someone were able to come up with a bit more evidence, might hold some merit.
However, I like to straddle the fence where the new games are concerned, simply because of the lack of proof. Therefore, you are allowed to flame me, disagree with me, in general belittle this theory, because it only recently came to me, and I decided to post before I completely formed my thoughts.
Now, I thought this up from a post (read: post, not theory) that Suffering Angel recently made. Yes, it happened.
Okay, now that the quote's out of the way, I'll explain my theory. If this has already been made (which it probably has, considering the amount of Xion theories gallivanting around), then I'm truly sorry, and feel free to do with this what you will.
Xion has been confirmed to be a Special Nobody. Of that there is no doubt. There is also no doubt of the fact that she looks a lot like Kairi. However, it's pretty much impossible for Kairi to have her own true Nobody, considering that her body never truly left, her Heart having been pure.
Hence where Naminé came from- the hybrid Nobody of Sora and Kairi, and the first actual Nobody that embodies the most qualities of a Nobody, as explained in the Ansem Reports.
However, there's nothing saying that Xion couldn't have come about during the Hollow Bastion scene where Sora sacrifices his Heart to release Kairi's- along with all of the other hearts of the captive princesses.How come they don't have little Sora/PoH hybrid Nobodies running around, much like Kairi?
This is where the above quote comes into play. Suffering Angel was talking about this very same scene where Sora lost his heart, and became a Heartless, thereby making both Roxas and Naminé.
And it made me wonder. What if Xion wasn't made through the Darkness in Sora's Heart, when he released it, but the light of either his Heart, or Kairi's?
There's nothing saying that a Nobody can't be made from light. It's not like they're actually made from the darkness in a Heart, either. They're the cast-off body and soul once the Heart has left, transforming them into automatons, unless the Heart was strong.
In fact, Nobodies teeter on the edge between darkness and light, neither accepting them, nor rejecting them. They, in Xemnas' words, teeter on the edge of nothingness.
If Xion was made a Nobody through the release of the light in Kairi's heart, or Sora's (I'd rather it be Sora's, but, meh. She does look more like Kairi), then it would explain why she is a Special Nobody.
Of course, this theory could be disproven by the fact that a Nobody is made through the body and soul being left behind, as stated above.
However, this is pure Light we're dealing with. The Princesses are able to do some pretty cool stuff with that Light- i.e be able to open the Door to Darkness, turn Sora into a Heart, instead of being Heartless, open a pathway for Sora and Riku to return home... even if they did it all inadvertently, they were still able to do it, because of their status, and their latent powers.
What if Xion isn't a Nobody in the same essence as other Nobodies, much like Naminé isn't?
What if I'm just spouting off at the mouth? What if I should just shut said mouth and let you disprove this to Hell and back?
Of course, as I've said, there's no proof that this is, at all, possible, so perhaps it's not a theory more as it is an idea. I also have a feeling that I didn't explain this well at all, and that I should not post this... but....
Also, Suffering Angel only inadvertently inspired this, so she is not to be blamed in anyway for the utter crappiness of this post. She can't help what goes on in my brain.
EDIT: The utter failure of this theory may also have something to do with the fact that it's after five in the morning where I am, and I haven't slept yet. Goes to show that my brain can't fuction without that necessity.
Second of all, I don't wholly support this theory myself, nor do I have much evidence (if any) to prove it.
But asides from that, I thought that it might be an interesting idea, that, if someone were able to come up with a bit more evidence, might hold some merit.
However, I like to straddle the fence where the new games are concerned, simply because of the lack of proof. Therefore, you are allowed to flame me, disagree with me, in general belittle this theory, because it only recently came to me, and I decided to post before I completely formed my thoughts.
Now, I thought this up from a post (read: post, not theory) that Suffering Angel recently made. Yes, it happened.
Suffering Angel said:1. The circumstances in which he turned into a Heartless brought about the Light in him, not only his Darkness.
Okay, now that the quote's out of the way, I'll explain my theory. If this has already been made (which it probably has, considering the amount of Xion theories gallivanting around), then I'm truly sorry, and feel free to do with this what you will.
Xion has been confirmed to be a Special Nobody. Of that there is no doubt. There is also no doubt of the fact that she looks a lot like Kairi. However, it's pretty much impossible for Kairi to have her own true Nobody, considering that her body never truly left, her Heart having been pure.
Hence where Naminé came from- the hybrid Nobody of Sora and Kairi, and the first actual Nobody that embodies the most qualities of a Nobody, as explained in the Ansem Reports.
However, there's nothing saying that Xion couldn't have come about during the Hollow Bastion scene where Sora sacrifices his Heart to release Kairi's- along with all of the other hearts of the captive princesses.
This is where the above quote comes into play. Suffering Angel was talking about this very same scene where Sora lost his heart, and became a Heartless, thereby making both Roxas and Naminé.
And it made me wonder. What if Xion wasn't made through the Darkness in Sora's Heart, when he released it, but the light of either his Heart, or Kairi's?
There's nothing saying that a Nobody can't be made from light. It's not like they're actually made from the darkness in a Heart, either. They're the cast-off body and soul once the Heart has left, transforming them into automatons, unless the Heart was strong.
In fact, Nobodies teeter on the edge between darkness and light, neither accepting them, nor rejecting them. They, in Xemnas' words, teeter on the edge of nothingness.
If Xion was made a Nobody through the release of the light in Kairi's heart, or Sora's (I'd rather it be Sora's, but, meh. She does look more like Kairi), then it would explain why she is a Special Nobody.
Of course, this theory could be disproven by the fact that a Nobody is made through the body and soul being left behind, as stated above.
However, this is pure Light we're dealing with. The Princesses are able to do some pretty cool stuff with that Light- i.e be able to open the Door to Darkness, turn Sora into a Heart, instead of being Heartless, open a pathway for Sora and Riku to return home... even if they did it all inadvertently, they were still able to do it, because of their status, and their latent powers.
What if Xion isn't a Nobody in the same essence as other Nobodies, much like Naminé isn't?
What if I'm just spouting off at the mouth? What if I should just shut said mouth and let you disprove this to Hell and back?
Of course, as I've said, there's no proof that this is, at all, possible, so perhaps it's not a theory more as it is an idea. I also have a feeling that I didn't explain this well at all, and that I should not post this... but....
Also, Suffering Angel only inadvertently inspired this, so she is not to be blamed in anyway for the utter crappiness of this post. She can't help what goes on in my brain.
EDIT: The utter failure of this theory may also have something to do with the fact that it's after five in the morning where I am, and I haven't slept yet. Goes to show that my brain can't fuction without that necessity.
Last edited: